Intelligent people less likely to believe in God, page 2
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 22 times


reply posted on 12-6-2008 @ 07:52 PM by acewilliams
reply to post by Anti-Tyrant



That may be true but you can't deny that his briliant mind did open the door for science. With science we have shown where the fabled garden would have been because of the finding of the first homosapien fossils. Science has shown that evolution does exist and played a part in our creation. Now the man who has intelligence would say that god must not exsist because of these facts. But a man with faith and intelligence might say god willed it, and I wish to take the point of the philosopher, and say, how long is a day for god? Or will it change the world to prove or disprove the existance of god?



[edit on 12-6-2008 by acewilliams]



reply posted on 12-6-2008 @ 07:59 PM by DaleGribble
reply to post by acewilliams



when you can prove evolution you can bring this argument to the table. all the evidence for evolution is random fosils that have a slight resimblance to one another. it full of missing links and assumptions much like religion. and if im not mistaken it was the guy who came up the the theroy of evolution that said some thing along the lines of, "their is too much wonder and beauty for their not to have been a devine creator."


reply posted on 12-6-2008 @ 08:05 PM by argentus
Just playing Athiest's Advocate here, but the Telegraph also promotes a hearty story about the wholesome and beneficial value of the Carbon Trust. www.telegraph.co.uk.../money/exclusions/supplements/carbonaction/nosplit/index.xml

whoof. Things that make you go waaaaaaah. Just a point of perspective, folks, whilst we wallow in our relative intelligence.

[dang, that blows the whole dramatic effect, IF I have to correct the link because I wasn't bright enough to do it right, doesn't it ]

[edit on 12-6-2008 by argentus]


reply posted on 12-6-2008 @ 08:09 PM by slackerwire
reply to post by Anti-Tyrant



And those lords would emphasize obeying the church why?

Think the church is merely an innocent bystander?


reply posted on 12-6-2008 @ 08:13 PM by Anti-Tyrant
reply to post by slackerwire



Like many innocent bystanders, it can be brainwashed into believing something contrary to it's nature.

Oh, and the fuedal lords would place emphasis on obeying the church, because it was seen as chivalric to place God as one's Lord of Lords.

Perhaps... we are victims of our own inbred desire to best the other man - after all, those were the times in which warring states would compete in one way or the other - who is to say that they would not compete in such a way that proving one's faith was the means to show who the better man was?



reply posted on 12-6-2008 @ 08:19 PM by argentus
reply to post by DaleGribble



Man, did you open a bubbling cauldron of puss with that statement. ALL? Listen, I don't care to derail this current thread with off-topic comments, so this will be it..... unless you choose to open one of your own. If I get the off-topic mod slap, then so be it, because your statement was rife with absolute slanted hyperbole. The evolutionary record demonstrates a gradual (although sometimes fairly sharp in the broad spectrum of things) change in various species. I personally don't believe that God made hundreds, no thousands, of varieties of species. It is science. It has monumental strata of evidence. Understand this...... I don't see how it conflicts with religious beliefs, unless, of course, you subscribe to the absurd notion that the world and universe are a mere thousands of years old. Perhaps you and I should U2U about this.

Okay. My apologies to the OP. I will endeavor to stay on topic or not at all.


reply posted on 12-6-2008 @ 08:23 PM by argentus
reply to post by DaleGribble



My bad. "Puss" was way over the top. No sense in starting a debate with someone, be it U2U or otherwise with loaded words.

My apologies. Mail if you choose. We'll discuss.

cheers


reply posted on 12-6-2008 @ 08:28 PM by acewilliams
reply to post by AKnight



I agree, atheism does not provide a person with intelligence. There have been too many intelligent people who where religous. Like Einstien, and Hitler, and George W. Bush, and many others. But the point, is that intelligence can not be assigned to any faction, religous or not. Those who say that only their religion is is right, are wrong; and those who say that any religion is wrong, are also wrong. The fact is that religion brings hope to those who might otherwise give up. Anything or anyone who can inspire like that must be respected but not followed blindly.


reply posted on 12-6-2008 @ 08:30 PM by Quazga
Originally posted by Peepers
I have thought about why people fall on faith as a means to justify existence. Intelligence cannot be pointed out as a significant factor since people in general, together in a group, whether a rock concert, political rally or religious ceremony all tune to mass hypnosis of the focus. That focus could be the lead singer, the political appointee or god.

I think its the thrill of a mass movement with people singing, clapping and glorifying.



The most fundamental reason for faith is actually due to logic. For example, when we are in a really tight situation, let's just say we are oh I dunno, being crucified. In those situations, the mental faculty will need a reason to go on functioning, or else snap under the strain. Without a "faith" that either "this is for a purpose" or that "A higher power will save me", the mental faculty breaks down.

Of course I used an extreme situation, but we see this in 12 step programs all the time. An addict is twice as likely to recover if they believe in a higher power who can help them. The fact that there is or isn't a higher power doesn't really mean anything, what means something is that the mind has something to chew on, so as to continue without breaking under the strain of a nihilistic future.


Faith has the same reason for being as does ego, survival. Think about the "death bed" conversions we hear about so much. When do people start believing in God the most? When they feel they are about to meet their end, and all other avenues of logic point to an end. The mind has a *real* hard time accepting it's own demise, because it is made of genetic code which is programed with one priority "continue". So, people start getting religion right before they die, quite often. Not all, but the vast majority.

Survival is the ultimate reason for everything that is an attribute of life.


reply posted on 12-6-2008 @ 08:35 PM by Rren
www.telegraph.co.uk...'less-likely-to-believe-in-God'.html


But the conclusions - in a paper for the academic journal Intelligence - have been branded "simplistic" by critics.





Ya think? This same Professor has established that men are more intelligent than woman too [ Sex differences in intelligence and brain size: A paradox resolved ] *hears the atheists' back-slappin' slowly fading away*

Of course, according to his paper here maybe us believers are just malnourished.

A blogger has been disseminating the paper here

Some highlights:


Granted that he has shown some limited correlation, but this shows nothing close to causation. In fact, these statistics are more than adequately covered when you factor in self selection of the groups, motivation for unbelief and an alternative reason for the correlation.


[...]


Notice that Dr. Lynn doesn't examine the IQ of those in religious service. If he had, he may have found many of those highly intelligent religious people that he found absent in academia.



[...]


Specifically, are people atheists BECAUSE they have a high IQ or could there be some other factor involved?


[...]


In short, rather than seeing atheism as correlating directly with intelligence, it is more likely that it is INVERSELY proportional to wisdom.




A bit of cherry-pickin' and seeing what one wants to see. I'm sure nobody will fall for it though, certainly not those intelligent-type folks who'll look into this paper and its conclusions, and how they were arrived at.

"Well duh!"

" I agree, great post "

" And there you have it folks, scientific evidence."


"personality/mindset when it comes to religion,that completely negates any common sense"


Y'all wouldn't happen to be atheists, would ya? You guys are precious. Oh, and smart.... really really smart.


reply posted on 12-6-2008 @ 08:39 PM by rjmelter
reply to post by Rasobasi420



Actually, The most intelligent individuals do not believe in organized religion but they do believe in an unspecified creator. Good try. tho. Its very cool that one mans research proves you right... I could interview 20 potheads and ask the benefits of smoking pot and get something really positive out of it. Its all in perception... Everything is what you make it... Within Reason.
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5  >>    ^^TOP^^