reply to post by zarzar
I think in my reply to Haidan I have acknowledged that even though he and me share the same opinion, but there are still many millions Chinese not
sharing the same idea. However, I do have a feeling the general consensus is what we both have said, this is based on my observations and experiences
in China. And also as stated before, this is also that the foreign countries are starting to observe and experience. And bare in mind that millions is
in proportion not the majority in a 1.4billion populace country.
As for the point of the "human rights" "violations". As said, for example there are basic issues that we do share and can agree on. Hmmm, let me
give a more extreme right opinion, to tingle some brains. However, would you agree on that for example the organs of a convicted death penalty
criminal are being sold? Well I am one of those who will vote for yes if I am allowed to have a say in it, WITH the conditions that the criminal was
convicted in an open and transparant system ruled by the law AND that the selling of these organs will help people in need, save lifes of good people
and not merely another tool to enrich some corrupted oficial. I believe I have shared enough opinion about what we do need to tackle on, corruption,
introduction rule by law etc.
Is this contradicting with my buddhistic belief? At least not with my way of living I do believe. Maybe tomorrow I will form a different opinion and a
different version of the truth. But today I will do what I believe is the right thing to do. Eventually you can say I am more a realist and try to
balance the bad karma with more good karma. Yes, I am acknowledging that taking someone's life who comitted a bad deed is bad karma, but equally I do
believe by having this death penalty system in place it is eventually creating more good karma for the Chinese society and the majority of China is
benefitting from a stable, orderly society.
And by the way, not to waive off or dismiss the "voices of dissidents", but I always am skeptical. Skeptical for anything, even it is only a
statement made by Hu Jintao, Donald Tsang or Ma Ying-Jeou. This make me also as skeptical for any anti-China "evidence". Too often I have seen
so-called "ultimate evidence to show the evilness of China", but more often I do see how skewed and biased certain reports are.
And by having presented those articles before, I tried to let you know that there might b more behind certain claims. One article that comes in mind
when talking about this:
From the “Tiananmen Massacre” to the "Lhasa
Protests”
I began to see the wisdom in my parents’ warning. True, in any political confrontation, the opposing sides would be tempted to use lies to
win justice, and naïve participants would be caught in between. To blindly believe in either side would be dangerous.
....
It is not too late for the media to report on Tibet issues with a critical eye, which will ultimately benefit the Tibetans, the Han Chinese,
the Olympics and the world.
I could not have said it better, and share this author's opinion. After all, I was like him back in '89....
[edit on 23/5/08 by IchiNiSan]