Originally posted by chrisonabike
I think its strange that you mention band wagons? which one am I on?

I always thought appearing on Live8 at the same time as a comeback was suspicious. But again, I'm a cynic.

But i think it best to be skeptical all the same...

In the case of this thread, yes it is. If you stayed anonymous and did not mention your member name you'd be avioding sceptical questions (and attacks by others)

I'm not above your suspicions but then Again niether are you mine...all the best either way...

You have suspicions of me?
Sadly, I am neither MI5/MI6 or apart of the British media.

original email from Robbie Williams
It was dusk and, suddenly, a big ball of light appeared over the san fernando valley. We were standing on my balcony at the time. When the song finished it disappeared .......when we played it again it came back on...once again, when the song finished it disappeared.......this happened 4 times.

Dear Rob!

I know, it was asked several times – but again:

It seems, you had a lot of time in between the several appearances – why didn’t you made photos of it? I know there’s at least always a pretty good mobile close to you!
I believe, that you saw what you tell us – but I ask myself this all the time!!

Thanks for the replies, Rob and Cthulhu,

Well perhaps that's that idea out the window.

It's confusing this one...LOL

How about the unusual sounds/frequencies/instruments angle?

Anything to work with there do we think?

Originally posted by Lurch

Anyone who seriously thinks that aliens swooped down to Robbie Williams' house when they heard him playing a song about aliens...well I don't want to offend anybody. Let me just say that I find it highly unlikely. Not that I'm saying chrisonabike is lying, because I doubt that he would be, I find it infinitely more likely that there is another explantion. Maybe you were so into the song and had aliens on the brain that your mind was playing tricks on you.

Is there not such a thing as coincidence? People see ufo's whilst out looking for them, is it coincidence, luck or are they all talking rubbish?

I think it's far too easy to call BS when it has'nt happened to you personaly. Far harder, but way more interesting is to try and find out what it really could have been.

CX.

If I think about that what happened to chrisonabiky and his friends. I just think that may we are the aliens. I mean "they" are maybe here all the time in a form we cannot see. Perhaps they`re watching us and also do this what we`re doing now?
And perhaps they also try to communicate to us.
Like this whistle for dogs.... understand? they can hear it.....

Hi Rob or Chris,

I have a few questions for you.

1.)
How has your belief in UFOs had an effect(if any)on your religious beliefs?

2.)
Being an American myself, I know that we are very skeptical about any belief in UFOs. Our government seems to always have an answer to what people see and percieve to be UFOs. Do you believe that what people are seeing could be government or military related.

3.)
I've read FEEL. (Yes I am a fan.) It is written that you tend to get bored quickly. Is this study of UFOs something you are dedicating yourself to completely? (Sorry like I said I'm American and we are very cynical)

One of the things that has so far not been considered in relation to the music is that the effect was not on the "UFO" but on RW and his friends.

Considered in this light, UFOs could be buzzing about unseen, cloaked or whatever, and it was the music, perhaps certain tones or frequencies, that opened the perception of them to those emmersed in the music.

Such a thing would explain the reports of people seeing UFOs from their cars, yet other people on the same road seem to show no reaction, as if they saw nothing. It could be that there was a certain tone played in the vehicle that caused those who heard it to be more perceptive, while other cars had different sounds that did not match the needed pattern for recognition to take place.

Not saying that this is so, just passing along an idea that occurred to me. If this was true, then such a song as "Arizona" might have a chord, or combination of chords, that increased mental awareness in the listener/participant.

Maybe that song needs to be made after all.

Deleted for content.




[edit on 18-5-2008 by NGC2736]

Originally posted by Heidi1823It seems, you had a lot of time in between the several appearances – why didn’t you made photos of it? I know there’s at least always a pretty good mobile close to you!
I believe, that you saw what you tell us – but I ask myself this all the time!!

Please read back two or three pages because he has already answered this.

No i'mm not making a one liner post! i'm saying people ned to take the time to read through the thread.

[edit on 18/5/2008 by Floh]

I don't know if this has been asked but did you feel as if the "Black light" was intelligent and observing you as if it had a mind of its own?