reply to post by internos
As per my earlier comments on ATS and on Youtube, the video quality
is TOO POOR to make any objective comment regarding the possibilities
that the lighting is "Bad" or that there are JPEG artifacts on the edges
or any other type of OBJECTIVE Forensic-Quality Video study
that DEFINITIVELY PROVES that the Italian UFO video is a CGI or Real.
In fact, the video to me, looks like it was taken using a Hi-8 or Digital-8
video camera simply because of the crushed black levels (i.e. no detail
in the dark areas) and blown out white levels (i.e. no detail in highlights)
and then poorly compressed using windows media maker or even
possibly the Cinepak codec on Quicktime - the video is just too piss poor
quality to make an OBJECTIVE statement of FACT!
HOWEVER, The MOTION of the Aviano craft is VERY realistic
in how it rotates, baubles around and twirls as flaps open & close.
I also see what I think is a HEAT SHIMMER surrounding the craft
but this could be an artifact of the video compression codec used.
The only part that looked UNREALISTIC was the last few seconds
when it zoomed into the distance.
At that part of the video, it looks like somebody cut out the real craft
and did a scale-down over a period of empty background frames
to make it LOOK LIKE the craft zoomed off into the distance.
That part DEFINITELY looked like an edited clip and the "Fakeness"
of that zoom-to-distance jolted me.
Again, there is NO POSSIBLE WAY to disprove or prove the state of
the Aviano craft as CGI or "REAL". And as another poster asked, what
software did they use, how did they do it and where is the 3D model
file if it truly IS a fake CGI craft?
If the video is TRULY REAL, then who is the camera person,
what camera did they use, what tape format was used,
and how was the video encoded to Youtube?
The Haiti craft was VERY WELL done, and as a 1993 graduate of
the Southern Alberta Institute of Technology's Cinema, Television,
Stage and Radio Arts program (2 years) in Broadcast Television
(Videographics), and after 15 years of Professional Video Experience
and 20 years of Computer Software Development Expertise, I can say
with some professional opinion that the Haiti UFO videos have been
the BEST and MOST REALISTIC of the fake UFO videos
that I have seen YET! And the reason was not just the lighting
and render quality...but also the REALISM of their motion
which made me say WOW !!!!!!
So if the Animator of the Haiti Video is reading ATS, then I say to YOU
that those videos were TRULY PROFESSIONAL QUALITY with Top-Notch
motion-realism and GREAT lighting! A TRUE EXPERT YOU ARE !!!!!!
And also with some professional opinion, I can say that the Italian
UFO video is ALSO a WOW type of video, because if it IS fake,
then the motion realism was done by a TRUE EXPERT in Animation.
but due to other qualities shown within the Aviano video, even with the
"Fake" looking zoom-to-distance at the end, I am inclined to say
on a SUBJECTIVE BASIS (not provable objectively though!) that
the majority of the video segment is of a REAL UAV craft
or at least of a decent real-world RC model aircraft!
If any two Italian Animation Geniuses would like to prove me wrong,
then send me your animation file and further details and I'll
be the FIRST to congratulate you on your animation genius!
Any other comments or links to TRULY superb Fakes
or possibly REAL UFO videos? Detail them here on ATS!