Originally posted by jsobecky
I won't address your assessment of Israel's origins in the current geopolitical arena, but I will say that *I* was the one who questioned RP's
bias. I have reasons:
In the video there is a caricature of Uncle Sam entwined, lock-style, in a Star of David. It is held together by a "Master Lock" - nice choice,
eh?
Another shot...Condi talking to Netanyahu, with Israeli and American flags in the background.
When RP begins to describe what, in his opinion, are neocon views, there is a Star of David as a backdrop.
View #3 is a knockoff of a recruiting poster of Uncle Sam pointing out at us, and the caption reads
I WANT YOU
TO DIE FOR ISRAEL
There's probably more.
Am I reading too much into this? I don't think so.
First off, I don't think it's at all inappropriate to address any assessment of Israel's origin (even though I didn't make one) in the
"geopolitical arena", just in this post since it wouldn't be on topic.
Second, others have already pointed out that the images on the clip weren't Paul's. Only the speech. Who knows who put the sound and audio together.
Third, what's wrong with using a country's flag to decry the country? The Star of David is on Israel's flag. If one wanted to draw any artistic
rendering or artistic satire of the interaction of two countries, why wouldn't you use the flag or iconography of said country(s) to do so?
Though, yeah, I agree that the whole Uncle Sam in the Star of David was messed up - mainly because I think it was meant to bring up that whole "the
Jews crucified Christ" thing that's been done to death (no pun intended).
Seriously, I really don't care if someone is Jewish, I don't really even understand why it even matters anymore. For the last 60 yrs. you've been
able to "convert" to Judaism - totally against the matriarchal orthodoxy by the way - so by now it's kind of moot, anyone can be Jewish. Big deal.
Most of us are to some extent or in some percentage anyway if we're taking into consideration both paternal and maternal lineage.
Synopsis - Paul didn't put together the iconography of the clip that was linked to by the OP. Though I don't think I would be wrong in my feeling
that he doesn't believe it's worth the international implications to support what I, at least, consider to be an illegal occupation.
You can be Anti-Israel without being Anti-Jewish.