Vatican: It's OK for Catholics to Believe in Aliens, page 3
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 7 times


reply posted on 14-5-2008 @ 08:24 AM by MareNostra
'Aliens Are My Brother'.
news.bbc.co.uk...

Well, as a Catholic, and a believer of the possibility of alien existence this news doesn't affect me personally.

But then again, I said I was a Catholic, I never said I was a good one.

True, just as we once thought the sun revolved around the earth...the earth was flat...and all the other theories that have been proven wrong - we (humans not necessarily CatLicks) have to continue to evolve in our thinking.

And being proven wrong isn't an issue for me - I think of it as being enlightened. I welcome enlightenment.

If at the end of my life I find that there is no God - and that I wasted hours of my life going to mass and volunteering with Catholic church organizations (eg. the local homeless shelter) it doesn't really matter. I did what I thought was good and right and positive in this life - and if there isn't any judgment at the end of it all I'm not worried and really won't feel I wasted my time.
That's not why I go to mass - its not why I live my life the way I do.

I used to have alien dreams for years - they ended as I got older (and in my dreams my eggs were too old to harvest). I told a buddy (priest) about it years ago and he thought it was completely plausible that they weren't just dreams thus he may have been ahead of his time...or just not a very "good Catholic" like me. ;-)

I also believe its very healthy for the Vatican to be under constant scrutiny - shouldn't every large organization's activities be monitored closely?

Just my 2 cents...and that's CDN 2 cents so possibly 1.5 cents US.


reply posted on 14-5-2008 @ 09:02 AM by tsloan
Just my thought on this. Nothing more. You guys remember that movie Contact with Jodie Foster? And no...I'm not say the writer knew any thing and was using the movie as a propaganda tool. But the movie does give a very watered down look at how peoples belief system would be affected if news of some sort of tangable life was out there. Now seeing that the vatican is the last word to some of the bible thumpers this could be very well a pre-emptive strike to get people the people who would almost become militant at the thought of another life form that wasn't clearly explained in christian belief and biblical text. Cause we all know that if dis-closure came today there would be a select few who would go off the deep end and come out guns ablazing at anyone who accepted this information.

So I don't know why,what they are up to. But, I feel that this is some pretty interesting happenings. Now you can chalk it up how ever you like but I see this as clearly a coded message to millions of christian believers that this world as we know it is about to become a very confusing world and it is best that no-one go off the deep end and keep and open mind of "acceptance" if you will of things that you might not understand at first. Or is it ..Don't judge??? Never the less as odd as it seems this is a pretty strong statement from a institute that holds millions of people with faith so it's a pretty damn big statement.



reply posted on 14-5-2008 @ 09:04 AM by 1nelove
What kind of elite mind actually believes the Vatican are a bunch of lost puppies.

First off, don't talk about the spiritual realm if you don't understand it. The weight of all the greatest minds, philosopher's and the billions of believers throughout time will flatten you in a second. It's only mystical if you believe in the physical imaged (the inverse) form of it.

Second, the Vatican has a sickening amount of resources. Have paraded around the world for hundreds and hundreds of years, taking over all of the land. Whether your mind makes it's own false reality or not, they are dominant.

Do you really believe they are this lost? I think this thought needs to be directed within you if you believe that.
They are ahead of the public, they always have been. This is the source of their power - knowledge. Not some physical act..image thinking again...that allowed them to take over, over and over again. Knowledge. This precedes the acts and allows them to succeed in the intended ways.

They control, and feed the public it's opinion, yet people buy into the movie like it was Philadelphia all over again.
'Those bible thumpers, always believing in silly things.'

It's enforced belief for a reason, not because they 'believe' and are scared of things proving them wrong.
ARE YOU KIDDING?? This is a subconsciously burnt idea, it's the only way that such incredible association can be made to a power like this.

Look into the evidence, they knew very well about the astronomical and astrological concepts of this universe the whole time.
Why do you think they killed off every single religion that was close to nature and astronomy? That's their power, and only theirs if they want to maintain it.

The Bible was secretly put together in a final form (much of it was in public circulation before this). The Bible was pumped out. The Bible was then taken out of the public hands. The Bible then started to be changed. Now the Catholic Bible has like thousands of changes and many inverse ones at that.
All done by the Roman Catholic Church. Gee...I think it might be a tool of some sort? Maybe?
It's called a Talisman. The spirituality associated with that (and the obelisk as another obvious example), will shed light on what they believe.

[edit on 14-5-2008 by 1nelove]


reply posted on 14-5-2008 @ 09:19 AM by Alethia
Originally posted by MareNostra
Originally posted by Alethia
Posted this question in the other thread on this:

If Catholics believe there are aliens, do they believe God created these aliens too?

And if these aliens ever did contact us, and said they didn't believe they were created by God but had some other belief, would Catholics say the aliens were wrong?


Obviously, I can only speak for myself and as I've stated I'm not a "good" Catholic, but my answer to you is as follows:

1. I don't know if God created aliens - or if aliens created God for that matter.

2. Nothing would enlighten me more than a theological discussion with aliens. And I would never say the aliens are wrong. Just as when I've had discussions with my friends from other religious backgrounds I completely enjoy learning about their doctrine etc. and I get a lot out of it. Does it make me question my own beliefs? No. Do I think they are wrong? No.

Call me the bad Catholic fence sitter...I just believe in "Live and Let Live".



I think it's cool you think and act and believe in live and let live. I guess the point I want to understand though is doesn't this contradict the standard Catholic doctorine on creationism. I mean God created the universe, so if he created the universe, he had to have created everything in it, and therefore the Vatican is saying you can believe in aliens, but according to the Catholic faith on the history of the universe, they had to have been created by God.

Alternatively, as you suggest, maybe aliens created God. But if they did, then God is not the all powerful being Catholic doctorine states, aliens are because they created God, they're the true power.

But what if these aliens don't believe that? I mean they are way more advanced than us, so theorectically they should have a deeper understanding of the history of the universe and it's creation.

Furthermore, if the aliens did believe they were created by God, again how does that fit with our ideas. Apparently humans are all Gods children and were created in Gods image. So what are aliens then if their not human and don't look like us and are therefore not created in Gods image? Are they just an animal?

Could this be considered the start of a plan by the Vatican to admit it's thoughts on the creation of the universe need to be updated and changed?

I can't see why the Vatican would make this statement, to me it opens up many more questions about the reality of a God in the first place, questions which according to their documented stance on creationsim they can not have an answer for.

[edit on 14-5-2008 by Alethia]


reply posted on 14-5-2008 @ 11:12 AM by 1nelove
Originally posted by Pjotr


I have a better question: WHAT is evolution.

That is something that is not backed up by anything but people's minds. Darwinian evolution, at it's core, does not have much scientific backing.

General evolution has a lot of truth in it, but your suggestion is it's something that it's not, so I'm doubting your grasp of what it is.

Biological evolution was simply left in a dark spot of understanding for a long time, and all the higher scientific minds knew this. Darwin's explanation (and if you know anything about this man, he was just a politician for the Philosophical Society's Athiest movement started by his Grandfather - just like the ideas where) doesn't hold ground in science.
Epigenetics is further proof of evolution WITHIN a species. All of these scientific facts can be twisted, because truth can always jump between two interpretations, just like the entirity of this reality is between a postive and negative charge. Darwin's explanation of species to species was something that made sense based on observed facts that we should be able to easily tell he twisted. A highly religious man when we look back (of course, an Egyptian like one), was pushing the Athiest movement while his family watched division in their comfortable riches? Obvious.

The Darwinan concept of species growth is speculative at best. It wasn't accepted by science at the time, and only after it was pushed for nearly a century through the obvious means, has it been common belief. Then after years of fighting, epigenetics finally breaks through as a practice (Too late though because most minds have been owned, and they don't even know what it is). Yet, there are thousands of scientists who officially denounce it. There are thousands who promote it and there are probably more that believe the whole argument is a stupid loop that is all bull# on both sides.
In an actual debate (I don't know if you've witnessed top debate teams argue this common debate for example), Creationist sides almost always win. And yes, you better believe logic is strengthened by science (obviously). So if anything, it looks like the opposite is true but really the debate is trying to argue two different forms of organized religions.

Do you know what the oldest story in the world is? It existed in every ancient civilized part of this planet.
It's that a superior race of being came here and genetically altered the existing lifeforms. The main goal was to create a slave race, which was us.
Now I understand that this is hard to believe because it goes against the enormous amount of experienced images seeped into the subconscious; but it's still what was believed by cultures that on some levels were more mathematically superior than us.

There's also outstanding proof (logic + literacy(of images or text)) which points to the fact that the story of creation in the Bible, and many more, are offsprings of these previous beliefs.

It's extremely naive to actually believe the Vatican believes in what they make us think they do/what they give us. I say make us think, because they often say what they believe, but what people think determines the interpretation of that.

So put that together (and yes it's an extremely simplified version of accounts) and the announcement of 'God created man out of apes' is nothing new, and the idea is just something they want to be official word at this point in time. Pretty significant.

Couple that with 'It's ok to believe in Aliens'.

Hmmmm.

Well sure, a more physical/illusionary minded person will not accept this, but the concept of Evolution vs. Creationism is irrelevant to all of this from that level. What created that accepted division within an illusionary state (I call a movie) is relavent, but clearly was not what you're talking about.


[edit on 14-5-2008 by 1nelove]


reply posted on 14-5-2008 @ 11:58 AM by Skipper1975
reply to post by Paulite



good news...humans need to know the truth..we are ready(or enough of us are imo)

just tell us and it's all good...amnesty for the cover-up..it's understandable why it was handled that way,but it's time to steer us in the right direction imo.


or at least let the people who want to know the truth find it at some special website or something..(you can pretty much find everything you want to know on the net as is,just takes time and lots of searching and whatnot)

very interesting.
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5  >>    ^^TOP^^



Russian scientists reach buried Antarctic Lake Vostok
  Posted 5 days ago with 83 member flags
Monsanto quits as GM results announced (EUROPE)
  Posted 7 days ago with 72 member flags
Strange noises reported around North Battleford
  Posted 18 days ago with 67 member flags
Ayatollah: Kill all Jews, annihilate Israel
  Posted 6 days ago with 49 member flags