12,000 Year Old Temple Found in Turkey, page 3
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5    6  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 55 times


reply posted on 19-4-2008 @ 07:09 AM by Scott Creighton
reply to post by Cythraul


Hello Cythraul,

Nice to see your post and thank you for the vote of confidence re my ATS forum.

Absolutely agree with your comments. The most important thing I consider that this discovery demonstrates is that complex human societies (i.e. civilisation) categorically does not hinge upon that society relying on farming/agriculture for its subsistence/development. The whole arguement that such societies could have arisen and existed only with the arrival of agricultural farming has been comprehensively blown apart with this discovery. Or, perhaps we will find out in the future that this society were indeed farmers thus pushing back farming/agriculture even further back into remote antiquty.

Exciting times.

Best



reply posted on 19-4-2008 @ 08:37 AM by wayno
As has been pointed out, a great deal of time, organization and manpower/womanpower would have been required to design, quarry and construct this temple site. The people doing this work; especially the "site boss", labourers and artisans would have had to spend a lot of time on-site. They themselves would not likely have been participants in the hunter-gatherer lifestyle as well; at least not while they were doing this work.
Thats a lot of bellies to feed. What would the logistics of feeding this group have been?
Were the actual hunter gatherers continually resupplying the workforce from the game and edible wild fruit and vegetables available around the area?
Was there indeed enough surplus wild stuff around to feed such a group? I had the impression hunter gatherer groups are usually not large congregations, and need to keep moving due to depletion of local resources and the need to find fresh sources for their sustenance.
Would not some sort of domesticated source of grain have been needed to maintain such a "permanent" population, as this site required, or was the area really that abundant/ bountiful at that time?
Were the suppliers, preparers and transporters of the food paid, or did they just "support the cause?"
I am leaning towards a scenario where, like most things in life, there wasn't a hard demarcation point between when farming was or was not done. My hunch is that some sort of gradual process took place whereby even if large fields weren't tilled and seeded, selective productive wild areas were nurtured and taken care of in some way to enhance/ensure the availability and supply.
The society that enabled this architectural feat had to be quite sophisticated, relying on a high degree of specializations in skills, and structured so that the various specializations supported the larger community. Besides experts in hunting and gathering, there had to be experts in "cultivating", in baking/cooking, in transportation; etc. etc.
A sense of co-operating for the common good and/or strong leadership as well as, obviously, faith in some larger power had to be a part of the mix.


reply posted on 19-4-2008 @ 08:44 AM by Dan Tanna
bldgblog.blogspot.com...

An older version of this beautiful underground city in turkey.

All of this stuns me when you look at the sheer hard work and effort put in - and 12,000 years old ? wow, makes 2500 years look positively fresh!


reply posted on 19-4-2008 @ 12:20 PM by Scott Creighton
reply to post by Star Ranger



Hello Star Ranger,

Many thanks for your post. You write:

:Star Ranger: ...but there may very well be something Cyclical ...


SC: You may be interested in my work here:

www.abovetopsecret.com...

Best wishes,

Scott Creighton


reply posted on 19-4-2008 @ 03:42 PM by grover
reply to post by agent_01



Graham Hancock is nothing more than a current day Erich Von Danikien and is just rehashing his old stories.
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5    6  >>    ^^TOP^^




Newest topics getting replies, in real-time:

Stop Bashing Us Military Folks.
  Rant, Posted 15 hours ago, 185 replies
Anonymous hacks CIA
  Breaking Alternative News, Posted 11 hours ago, 101 replies
Free Psychic Readings
  General Chit Chat, Posted 6 hours ago, 71 replies