reply to post by Neiby
Woefully incomplete. Well, obviously, I would have a hard time summing up in two paragraphs all the works that have been written on the subject, both
pro and con. Darwin's work alone took quite a few pages, and that was only the origin of the theory. However, I think I did a little better
than:
Actually, I will present a short summary: "God did it."
Not a bad tactic though. If someone cannot meet the expectation of being able to recant every nuance of a theory in a debate, simply state they do not
understand and toss out all arguments made.
I was taught evolution in school, just like, I assume, everyone else here. Unlike most of those who have responded to me, I do not believe everything
I am told. I examine the issues. I have examined evolution and found some circumstantial (non-repeatable, non-recordable) evidence in its favor. I
have also found several potential problems with the theory that have not been resolved to my satisfaction. From a scientific standpoint, I see
something similar in certain aspects of creationism. Some circumstantial evidence seems to support it, while other areas have problems, the biggest if
these being that there is no (and I believe can be no) direct evidence of God.
This means that, to my eye, the theories are pretty much equivalent in their scientific standing, although due to the excessive amount of study
involved with evolution, it would obviously have the edge in that respect. But, I believe there is a God. That sways the balance for me, since it
explains in a non-scientific way the potential problems that a scientific examination of creationism has.
The question before us here is not whether one or the other is 'correct', but rather should one be taught while the other is not? I say both are
theories, and should therefore be taught as such. Evolution is already taught, exclusively in many schools. Apparently, creationism should be as well,
since it seems no one arguing against it has any idea what it even is... except of course, for your 'complete' answer: "God did it."
TheRedneck