Well, youtube tends to remove anything that it deems to be "violent" or "unacceptable" to them. As to whether the video is real or not, I can't say. However, I will say that youtube has a track record of removing videos it deems "inappropriate." It certainly has nothing to do with youtube being supporters of our troops, if that is what you were insinuating in the OP.

I always wish I never clicked on those sick vids but I tell myself I have to see what these cruel people did to know what the truth is. Well the truth makes me want to puke and leave this sick world, if its real yes I want an IED to have that "Motari's" name on it or have him in the latest alquaeda beheading video. Yes I know 2 wrongs dont make a right but I have gotten to the point where I value animal life over human life because I dont think we even deserve to be here for the most part and people like this prove my point.

Yes its war and yes war messes up ones mind but I guess that says how bad their training is when they are supposed to represent the #1 military in the world according to any American. I belive in Karma so I will keep an eye out on CNN for that Motari's face next time they show a casualty report from Iraq.

Hey AMericans send your kids to Iraq where they will become demented killers and have no compashion for life! Then show on CNN how soldier over there love and care for stray dogs but then release NUMEROUS videos on youtube that shows American soldiers doing some of the most sick stuff I would expect from the terrorists they are supposed to be killing.

So, let me get this straight, even though there is a video stating that it's fake, you choose to believe it's real? Hmmmmm... funny how people use things to prove or disprove their own preconceived notions. Yet, I bet if it were a video claiming that a bigfoot or UFO was fake, you'd be all over it as proof that it was fake... Pretty much sums it up doesn't it? But since American are so "eeeevil," this video "must be real."


TRUTH HURTS



[edit on 4-3-2008 by SpeakerofTruth]

OMG. an obvious fake.

For one thing, the 'puppy' when thrown goes end over end.

This is like what?

A stuffed animal, not a real animal.

A real animal would try to spiral their hind quarters and right themselves.

It's not even a dead dog, it's a stuffed dog, substituted for the puppy, which is probably just fine.

C'mon ATS, use your skepti-goggles.

This is just horrifying.. Just plain disgusting.. I hope these people are brought to justice.. like.. being thrown from a helicopter screaming.. or locked in a portable toilet and set on fire with the rest of the turds.. And he shrugs.. and no one tries to stop him..

I got an idea.. big brave soldier boy.. Why don't you come try that on me.

Ahh you wouldn't, you spineless little bimbo.. These are the "hero's" defending our country by raping and murdering innocent men, women and children. Killing innocent animals.. ugh.. I despise the military.

ooohhh

so because this youtube link says "FAKE," that means that all the other references to this video over the past few days are also fake? Thanks for clearing that one up for all of us here on the internet.

Originally posted by scientist
ooohhh

so because this youtube link says "FAKE," that means that all the other references to this video over the past few days are also fake? Thanks for clearing that one up for all of us here on the internet.

I am sure if it were a video of something that you don't want to believe,claiming that it was a fake, you'd be all over it as virtual proof that it was fake though, eh...

PROVE to me it's a fake.. Let's take it to trial, Without a reasonable doubt, prove to me that it's a fake and I shall retract all previous comments.

I'm waiting.

How many dogs have you actually seen thrown? I have seen my share. I can tell you this, they don't go end over end like that... By the way, prove to me that anything is fake without question.. YOU CAN'T

Originally posted by Ox
PROVE to me it's a fake.. Let's take it to trial, Without a reasonable doubt, prove to me that it's a fake and I shall retract all previous comments.

I'm waiting.

Why rely on others to do the work for you? Why don't you just prove it's real?

I don't know if it's real or not. I do know that people seemed to be more outraged over one puppy dieing than the thousands of humans that have been suffering horrible deaths. And that's just wierd.

Oh please, So you're telling me that because it's an American "hero" Soldier.. they wouldn't do things like that right? Oh yeah? Tell that to the prisoners of Abu Ghraib.

Here's a physics experiment for you, Get one of your dolls... Hold it by its neck, and throw it in the same fashion as the spineless POS in the video.. and tell me it doesn't tumble end over end.. Then you can come back and tell me I was right, I'll be here.. It's ok.. take you're time.

This is OBVIOUS animal cruelty. Obvious disregard for life, and OBVIOUSLY the American military getting away with MURDER again and again!.. It's a travesty and these bastards need to pay for their crimes.

i cant help but laugh when reading your explanation of why it was a fake.

you seem to be using physics as some sort of argument, is this correct? that since the dog went "end over end," it was fake? Is there some type of mathematical formula used when calculating the pitch and yaw of a dog being thrown over a cliff?

How do you factor in the aerodynamics of the size of the dog, and its fur?

Aces, that's the stupidity we live in today.Go to youtube. There are people who get offended over a freaking snake or chicken being killed. Here are the comments you see at youtube "I hope that bitch gets her throat cut just like she cut that chicken's." Really? A chicken's life is on the same par as a human's? I guess to some people it is...

Originally posted by Ox

Here's a physics experiment for you, Get one of your dolls... Hold it by its neck, and throw it in the same fashion as the spineless POS in the video.. and tell me it doesn't tumble end over end.. Then you can come back and tell me I was right, I'll be here.. It's ok.. take you're time.

.

Yeah, a DOLL does!!! You just proved my point.. A sentient, breathing creature does not!!By the way, I don't have dolls, a bit too old for that.

[edit on 4-3-2008 by SpeakerofTruth]

Whether this video is fake or not there are still numerous other videos of our "brave men in uniform" doing even more disgusting things to human beings. My dad was in the military so was my uncle and many of their friends also were, and I can tell you they were all demented they are seriously messed up in the head. I don't know how you could lower yourself to kill another human being for such an unjust cause.

If the people refused to fight for their corrupt leaders there would be no wars. All soldiers are just puppets for an evil cause.

Ox, I strongly suggest you quit being condescending and level out your tone. Get my drift? Go hug a rattlesnake.

[edit on 4-3-2008 by SpeakerofTruth]