posted by ProfEmeritus
Good points. I don't think Lieberman is a turncoat either. That was the quote from the original article that I cited. In fact, it was the Democratic
party in CT that did the turn coating . . First of all, I'm not sure if McCain didn't run turncoat in Vietnam. Not only did the Vietnamese
ambassador, who was his captor state that McCain was never tortured, but there are former POW's that just this week swear that McCain was given
special treatment while a captive.
There are some very serious anomalies about the Vietnam War I have never heard discussed. We know about the US airmen who were kept in the prison in
Hanoi we called “Hanoi Hilton.” I believe when the War ended there were about 635-650 US personnel released from Hanoi. As I have posted
elsewhere, I also believe 5-10 of the prisoners died in prison. The Vietnamese say they died due to wounds or injuries received PRIOR to their
incarceration at Hanoi. I believe them.
At one time the US had 550,000 men in South Vietnam. It would come as no surprise to learn that 10,000 to 25,000 had been captured in action. After
all, we lost 59,000 KIA and about 150,000 wounded. But I never hear about any prisoners of ours taken on the ground. We had about 30,000 POWs in the
Korean War. How could we have NONE in Vietnam? It makes no sense to me. What it does do is make me think we had a TAKE NO PRISONERS POLICY which the
NVA would have reciprocated on us.
I do not for one minute mean to imply those US airmen taken prisoner “had it made.” I was in the USAF in Korea in 1953-54. I was a ground crewman
and was never in any danger of being captured by the enemy. OTOH, the pictures show the release of the prisoners from Hanoi of our men in good
condition, waving, smiling, considering how anyone would come out of five or six years living in a 6 X 9 cell. Those ex-POWs who have been in the
public eye seem to be OK as far as I can tell. Picturers seem to indicate they all have their own teeth, a very crucial indicator of the diet and care
given and received.
As for McCain and special treatment as a POW. Yes, I believe he had special treatment. No, I do not believe he “turned coat” to get that. His
father was a Navy admiral. That made McCain a high value prisoner. It was in the best interest of the NVA to keep him in especially good condition in
case he was to be exchanged for a NVA prisoner. My point in the other post was that HERO status was more deserved by Marine Corps privates who laid
in muddy rice paddies day in and day out. Full of leaches, mosquitoes and other vermin I care not to mention. Those guys gave all they had to a failed
cause. Being a successful prisoner of war means following orders, keeping quiet and minding your own business.
Many American airmen were killed or injured severely when they parachuted into an area where the local people could get to them before the NVA army
could. But that was another story.
[edit on 2/8/2008 by donwhite]