Originally posted by Elhardt
Here are some names other cultures located on both sides of the Atlantic used to refer to Atlantis (the great eastern island, or the great western island, depending on what side of the Alantic they were from): Atlan, Aztlan, Attala, Atalaya, Atlaintika, Atarantes, Antilha, Atlantion, etc. As you can see, there's a similarity between names. And since those cultures living in the Americas referred to Atlantis as the great eastern island, that would also seem to indicate that America itself was not Atlantis.
How far should I go with this? Nobody ever called anything "Atlan" as far as I know and as far as I can find out. Aztlan (maybe Atlan is another spelling of this word) was the ancestral home of the nahuatl speaking peoples of the Valley of Mexico (Aztecs, among others,) not some ancient flooded continent, but an area of dry ground surrounded by a marshy lake toward the west.
West from Mexico is hardly the Atlantic.
Since both these so-called names for Atlantis are bogus, and you stated them as if they were true, I'd be wasting my time to go any further, wouldn't I?
The Aztecs left no myth behind about a sunken continent or even a sunken island of Aztlan (or Atlan.)
Even worse, the only references to Aztlan in existence were written after the Spanish conquered the Aztecs:
The primary sources for Aztlán are the Boturini Codex, the Codex Telleriano-Remensis, and the Aubin Codex. Aztlán is also mentioned in the History of Tlaxcala (by Diego Muñoz Camargo, a Tlaxcalan mestizo from the 17th century), as well as Historia Tolteca-Chichimeca. It should be noted that all the documents mentioned above were written (in Spanish) after the Spanish conquest of Mexico.
Source: Wiki
Originally posted by IvanZana
Actually your wrong. There is hundreds of stories that speak of a continent that suffered a great flood/tsunami it so happens that it was plato that called it ATLANTIS for it sat in the ATLANTIc.
The Anicent Meso american indian all share the story of a massive flood which flooded their whole continent destroying great city of lights. America.
No, they don't. And, no, there are not hundreds of such stories.
There are a lot of flood stories, but, hey, there are also a lot of floods.
And, all you guys that want to support some silly Atlantis theory by basing it on the similarity of names should try and comprehend this, the Atlantic was named the Atlantic because of Plato's story. It was called "The Western Ocean" when Plato was around.
Harte




