Canada's Identity, page 1
Pages: <<  1    2    3  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 0 times


reply posted on 8-2-2004 @ 01:46 AM by insite
Originally posted by THENEO
But on the other hand I can understand why Cherry hates the French.


Me too, but it seems as though Cherry is not only belittling the French with this. I don't see anything from that article suggesting Cherry is anti-francophone. Sure he obviously called the franc's weak, but that is his MO. So he's a highly paid commentator, Canada sure as hell has it's own identity, ask any American. The fact that the nation is bilingual is testament to this. Cherry is begin blasted in his own nation for what?? For his opinin on francophones? I can name about 100 Albertans that could find something wrong with Franc's. Leave this guy alone, he's being paid by the CBC for a reason. He states his opinion and you're damn right in thinking Canada has it's own identity, no one can argue againts that. What exactly is this post a-boat?

Sorry if this post is a little hard to follow. I'm wasted off some Canadian blended whiskey, its da best! Let him go, Canada has it's identity, francs are NOT Canadian. Kick em out, send the aircraft manufacturing to Manitoba!!

*EDIT: I HATE East Canada. Ya'll need to learn your roll. You're taking advantage of the West and don't think it goes unnoticed you bastards. May the West secceed from your horrible, selfish nation and become the most powerful region on Earth. ALBERTA, O Canada takes you for granted. Stand up! Fight the oppressors of the East and reclaim your place amongst the nations of power and envy!

[Edited on 2-8-2004 by insite]



reply posted on 8-2-2004 @ 02:01 AM by THENEO
Originally posted by insite
Originally posted by THENEO
But on the other hand I can understand why Cherry hates the French.


Me too, but it seems as though Cherry is not only belittling the French with this. I don't see anything from that article suggesting Cherry is anti-francophone. Sure he obviously called the franc's weak, but that is his MO. So he's a highly paid commentator, Canada sure as hell has it's own identity, ask any American. The fact that the nation is bilingual is testament to this. Cherry is begin blasted in his own nation for what?? For his opinin on francophones? I can name about 100 Albertans that could find something wrong with Franc's. Leave this guy alone, he's being paid by the CBC for a reason. He states his opinion and you're damn right in thinking Canada has it's own identity, no one can argue againts that. What exactly is this post a-boat?

Sorry if this post is a little hard to follow. I'm wasted off some Canadian blended whiskey, its da best! Let him go, Canada has it's identity, francs are NOT Canadian. Kick em out, send the aircraft manufacturing to Manitoba!!


You made a good point probably without being aware of it. See in Canada there is really two main ideas, that of the right and the left (I'll generalize here a bit). The left want to cling to Quebec because that is our identity which makes us different from the US and thus allows Canada to exist as a separate country from the US. Of course since those people at the ones that feed at the trough of the government system most, they have obvious self interest in all this despite their protestations to the contrary.

The other group of people are more like westerners these days, they do not fear the US and they want Canada to exist (if at all), on its own two feet by its own merits and not by some cultural abnormality. These people do not necessarily hate Quebec but they seem them as being one of serveral children in the family rather than the most important child. These people also tend to not be connected into the system the same way and more independent economically and thus more secure in their view of the world.


reply posted on 9-2-2004 @ 06:24 PM by THENEO
Originally posted by intrepid
Well, I'd like to respond to all of you. 1st the uproar about Cherry is due to the fact that the CBC is government operated. So that makes it SEEM that his statement might have some government authenticity. I personally agree with most of what he says. Now you westerners, I know exactly how you feel about the east I lived in BC for six years. I also know about your ignorance. According to the average westerner you've got Ontario, Quebec, and anything east of that is Newfoundland. I'm from Nova Scotia, heard of that, and as far as the east sucking the wests teat, you should know that our fishery was sold away for the rest of the country. The offshore natural gas that is being shipped out is making little money for NS. Wished we got as sweet a deal as Alberta. The economy is so bad that we had to move to Ontario just to survive. So westerers, quit your whining it's the furthest east that the rest of the country has been screwing.


Sorry I didn't respond to this sooner. There is truth to your comments but it is not as simple as presented here. Many years ago eastern Canada was the best part of Canada much like the northeast was the same for the US. As you know the Canadian Constitution was signed in Charlottetown PEI and not Montreal or even Toronto (where or what was Ottawa then?). But alas as development and peoples spread west it was decided to use the large populations and plentiful land of central Canada as the industrial heartland of Canada. Unfortunately, many down east have not recovered from this state of affairs ever since. I think that your governments down there signed away control of resources because they wanted guaranteed transfers from Ottawa rather than risk the vagarities of the resource trade and international competitiveness which east coasters would have to have faced on their own.

Can the east coast avoid this problem in future of not having sufficient control over its future? I don't know for it isn't anything I can do about it.

Regarding Quebec, it is a rather dynamic place and many Quebecers have done well in the world, but overall it still remains a drain on the Canadian economy due to its penchant for European style social services which are the world's most expensive. I think the real sink hole in Canada has been and still is Quebec.
Pages: <<  1    2    3  >>    ^^TOP^^



Alaska: Samantha Koenig Kidnapped last week.
  Posted 3 days ago with 111 member flags
Blue Spheres Fall from the Sky in the UK
  Posted 16 days ago with 81 member flags
The Chinese have seen the dragon in the sky !!
  Posted 3 days ago with 69 member flags
Strange Sounds in Sky Explained by Scientists
  Posted 12 days ago with 60 member flags
She Dialed 911. The Cop Who Came to Help Raped Her.
  Posted 6 days ago with 49 member flags
Anonymous: Revealing The Arcane Legal Trick Behind ACTA
  Posted 13 days ago with 42 member flags
Anonymous reveals Haditha massacre emails | RT
  Posted 8 days ago with 33 member flags