Originally posted by euclid
There is a problem with your logic:
1. The images you provided would have absolutely no CONTEXT to an alien. In the first image they would see two things, obviously life forms, and what
they would probably discern to be vegetation. It would be meaningless as it is meaningless to me.
Did you get up on the wrong side of the bed? Or maybe just having a bad day? If you will reread my post you will plainly see that I made no
assumptions about what an aliens might conclude after viewing these images.
Notice the two open ended questions I asked in my post:
I asked:
Can you image their reaction when they see these two images taken only 500 miles apart?
&
What will that say about
our race?
Unlike you, I did not state definitively, as if there was any way we could know, what they would think. I left it to the readers of the post to draw
their own conclusions. I then took the liberty of stating how I personally felt.
You however seem quite comfortable in stating rather dogmatically that the images and the connection between the two would be meaningless to them.
and as you boldly claimed,
1. The images you provided would have absolutely no CONTEXT to an alien.
Would you care to share how you know this? Or are you just making an assumption based on flawed logic?
It seems quite bizarre to me that you would criticize me for assuming what aliens might think, but then you, in the same post no less, do the same
thing.
2. The second image also lacks any context as well for the same reasons as the first.
Actually a very simple google search, taking only a few moments' was all it took for me to find the link between these two images. The first image is
quite famous and there are literally thousands of links to explaining the circumstances.
The images may indeed be meaningless to an alien civilization. I grant you that. But I am sure you are exaggerating when you say that the images are
meaningless to you.
I think I made it quite clear in my post that the images were taken less than 500 miles apart. Perhaps you missed that.
Now I can completely understand that you may not agree with my views or opinions, but surely you can grasp the purpose of my posting the two images.
3. You are projecting your mores and values onto a hypothetical species that may or may not exist. This species, if it exists, will not have the same
moral or philosophical ideas that we have. They will without doubt be very different.
Rather than state emphatically that they will not have the same moral or philosophical views. I would say that they MAY not have the same moral and
philosophical views. They are after Hypothetical as you stated, so how can one know for sure how their minds would work.
They may view humans as food and think that dogs and cats are the controllers of society due to the fact that these little creatures stay home
in a well air conditioned house and we provide for their needs. I know cats would agree with me.
Quite true. Good point.
The bottom line is that if there is an alien out there they will view our images as we would view their images..... with utter confusion &
fascination.
Possible, no way of knowing for sure.
I'm not moved at all by the images you posted..... why would they be moved to any moral evaluation of them; why would they view it as any thing other
than the way things are on that "planet".
I know it may surprise you, but I did not post the images to "move" you in one way or another. I posted the images to make my point. I am glad you
are not losing any sleep over them though, that would make me feel bad.
I agree with many of the points you make and hope that you continue to post. If everyone thought alike this site wouldn't be as interesting and
stimulating as it is.
[edit on 20-12-2007 by Sparky63]