I figured I'd come back to this thread since it seems people feel more inclined to respond when a person has stated that they are leaving the
Originally posted by DarkSide
If I go by your logic, all the people in the U.S should move back to europe because it's native american land. the english should move back to north
germany and leave britain to celtic people. Hell even the celts should move back to the middle east because neolithic people own britain and ireland.
And If we go by your logic, we'd probably get nowhere.
Stop twisting my words.
I've stated that A) the UN had no right to take land, and B) Israel should fight for it if they wanted the land.
Historically, land has either been bought, or has been fought for.
Did the Israeli people, in the 1940's, buy this land from Palestine? No.
Did the Israeli people, in the 1940's, fight for this land, and win it from Palestine? No.
Did the Israeli people, in the 1940's, get a gift from a world government organization? Yes.
Who exactly gave the UN the right to take land? Can you find that out for me? Because if you can't, then I guess common sense would tell us that what
they did was illegal.
We can go on and on bickering and debating about who's religious right it is to that land. I don't care what the bible says.
The FACT is - the Palestinians were there at the time it was taken away.
I have no doubt Israelis were there before that at some point in history. But the FACT, once again, is they lost that land to the Palestinians as time
Again, that's how land has been gained and lost throughout history. Either through war or buy/sale.
So going back to your logic by misinterpreting my logic, no, I don't think we should go back to Europe. We fought for this land and took control over
We can debate whether or not it is moral to suggest that fighting over land and killing others gives you the rights to the land, but again, the fact
is, that is how it has been historically, and until mankind has a major shift in behavior, that's how it will be.
The change happened in the Middle East. The Israelis were displaced from that area. The Palestinians took over. Then the Holocaust happened. That
SHOULD have been end of story, because the UN had no right to violate a sovereign nation like that.
If Germany wanted to set aside some land for the Jews, then that would have been the best possible scenario for everyone. But the UN taking land from
anyone, whether it be Palestine, or if they did it to Germany, my opinion would be the same - they have and had no right to do so.