Originally posted by AGENT_T
Cold resistance will be tested if I get the chance to take it up Ben Nevis in Jabruary

Better still would be to test your equipment's handling abilities with cold hands...so maybe you could experiment by holding your hands in a bowl of iced water until the shiver-response kicks in and then see if you can successfully start a fire with your gear with hypothermic-limited dexterity

As well as that, it may also be useful to test fire-lighting equipment after it has been thrown in the deep-freeze for an hour or two?

Knowing how your hands will or wont work with intricate methods, or how your fire-starting gear will respond to damp/cold may just make the difference between life-saving fire and death from hypothermia

Originally posted by PaddyInf
The zippo will work with any flamable liquid and is really reliable

One thing you should bear in mind with Zippos is their tendancy to leak as they are not fully sealed units...I stopped carrying one to light my cigs for this reason when a friend noted that I had a 'faint whiff of petrol' about me.

If do pack one, keep it secured in a small zip-loc bag to prevent fuel evaporation and tainting of clothes/food

was experminting this weekend with a magnesuim fire stick . i found that if you put your shavings on a dryer sheet that it lights up right quick and makes a good fire.

My daughter and I spent part of last weekend working with fire.

We tried a couple of different methods of fire starting, beginning with the steel wool and nine volt batteries. Great success with that, very easy.
We tried 0000 steel wool (the softest), medium, and coarse. The medium and coarse kept snagging on the terminals of the battery and didn't catch but the soft stuff caught even when just resting against the battery without any motion at all.
The downside to steel wool is that it must be kept absolutely dry or it rusts and rots.

We also practiced with the magnesium block, shaving it with a utility knife. I made a small disk (dryer lint the size of a nickel or quarter) to shave onto and that kept the shavings from moving in a slight breeze.
It's important to aim the striking sparks right onto the pile of shavings.

Thirdly we made a coffee can stove just like the one Semper posted, it was so easy and kept a very hot fire in it with minimal effort.
I bought a pack of nuts and bolts and fastened four cans together and made a four burner stove out of it. We made coffee, hot soup, dishwashing water, and bathing water all at the same time. A must for family situations with kids.

My daughter wasn't very interested at first but by the time we were done and dousing the fire with sand from the sandbox she was requesting her own pocket knife and magnesium bar.

[edit on 10/16/07 by julesmac8]

[edit on 10/16/07 by julesmac8]

I need to make a correction regarding my original post. At the time of writing it I was under the mistaken impression that the only thing that you could start an ember from flint and steel with was charred cloth (or at least some type of char). I've since learned that many things will catch a spark from flint and steel.

One of these things is cattail fluff. I guess much experimentation is in order. Can any of you share your experiences about what has worked for you?

I don't know how I went so long without learning that as that knowledge opens up a whole new world of fire starting possibilities. I guess it just goes to show that no matter how much we think we know about a subject, there's still more to learn.

I am interested in learning some survival techniques later on, yet my ambitions are rather extreme, though i think well justified.
if something major happens, causing the total decimation of the civilized world, or a significant portion of it, i think it would be good to know how to light fires, among doing other things too, using nothing but natural stuff. flint and a hard rock, granite basalt for example, or some other non sedimentry rock you may come across would be the best solution. they would be easy to carry (something a bit smaller than a billiards ball would do, though flatter especially for the stone that is struck upon) as they are ready to be used at any time and are rather east to carry in a pack of some kind.

the bow technique is good, with practice, though may be tedious to set up in a hurry.

in my opinion, lighters, matches or any artificial implement is unreliable, as it can break or ware out and getting a new one may be a pain. to be able to strike a fire using nothing but nature would be a pleasant advantage to anyone stuck in a nasty situation. it may take more practice but definatly worth it.

Very good thread .
I could build a fire without to many difficulties many problem would starting the fire without matches. The steel wool and batteries method appeals because I have plenty of batteries lying around.
For the steel wool could I tear up a kitchen cloth that is made out of that material and use it in part to light a fire ?

was burnin off over weekend...learnt heaps about FIRE...it's ways/personnality......here is a Medicine Mans teaching on FIRE..... FIRE

Fire has its own Life. Fire has NEVER ment to harm. AnyONE or AnyTHING. EVER! When released it just gos WILD in JOY! In BEING! In EXSPEARENCEING LIFE! In truth, Fire is the MOST LIKE GODCreator Ive ment...for the sheer PLEASURE of BEING! One can MEET this Being by setting all nite b4 it. Watching. Others' must feed it. YOU juse set and WATCH. U must never doze off if you truely care to meet it. IT KNOWS YOU ARE THERE. Totoly AWARE of YOU. If you presist in wathing and exspearencing IT....eventualy it will RESPOND. YOU WILL MEET ITS' BEING. Its HEARTBEING. You will Actualy SEE IT THERE INSIDE ITS GREAT JOY FLICKER! Then.....THEN....you will KNOW ; FIRE!
it TOO can converse. IF you r OPEN TO THIS. This takes ADMERATION and AWE and GREAT LOVE FOR IT! IT in turn APPREACEATES! IT wants 2 Leggeds to KNOW it has done nother but LOVE. IT loves to HEAT. Loves to help COOK. Loves to give LIGHT. Loves to give SECURITY. And too, to Be FREE!
It is in this FREEDOM JOY it causes harm. HARM NOT INTENDED or even CONSITERD Doing.
Like all things, it ENJOYS LIFE and dos not WANT to Die. Thus it reaches out....SPREADING, to CONTINUE LIVEING! All it EVER WANTS TO DO is LOVE ITS' LIFE. That, to ITS Fullness. As IT dies, IT feels CONTRITE OF HEART. SAD if IT has dong HARM and / or WRONG DOING. IT feels so SORRY and HOPES All will understand ITS' "Reason". That they will understand and FORGIVE! IT then passes away. Out. Dead. HO

KNOW THIS : IT has no IDIA How and When ITS nxt. Life exspearence will be. IT HAS no CHOICE of ITS "Begining". It simple Accepts IT ONCE AGAIN HAS LIFE! Be it by Accident, Naurel, Weapondry, Arsinest. Its BEGINGING...its BIRTHING IT has no CHOICE or PICK OF.
FIRE is GOOD if USED FOR GOOD, by GOOD PEOPLE.
NEVER "Play" WITH FIRE. NEVER ABUSE IT! NEVER MISS-USE IT! EVER

GB

Originally posted by Siren

in my opinion, lighters, matches or any artificial implement is unreliable

I will take the easiest route and still include these items in my "go bag". The less stress the better. It does not hurt to have them and learn the other ways in addition.

Yes, of cause they are stress free and easy to use, but given a large scale, long term situation X I think that it would be a huge benefit to be able to use other means. If you lost your lighter, your matches ran out or your magnesium stick became useless, then you wouldn't be able to light a fire, which would become a problem.

IMO, if I were to have to use natural methods, then I would use them over the artificial ones, just because I can. there are methods of lighting fires in a hurry naturally too, you can keep a fire burning in a piece of bark with some moss stuffed inside which once blown on and some kindling is added, can create an instant fire.

I think that the only disadvantage to natural methods is work needed, and therefore the requirement of time. Though in a situation where you lived off in the woods somewhere, time wouldn't be an issue. Unfortunetly our society has caused us to desire time and to live our lives by its awesome scheduling power, something which you must learn to rid yourself of.

In a real survival situation you will have no idea where your next resources will be coming from. Any capabilities for quick and easy fire building will be depleted at some point. It's a finite resource and should be treated as such and conserved. For those times when you're cold and wet or starving or hurt or whatever the reason you can't improvise, your life may well depend on a quick and easy fire. Therefore it would be prudent to always improvise if possible and save those resources until you're in dire need of them. We're not talking about a weekend camping trip. Survival is serious business and there's little room for poor decisions or wasted resources.