Student Arrested, Tasered at Kerry Event, page 2


Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 84 times


reply posted on 17-9-2007 @ 10:33 PM by C0le
reply to post by DontTreadOnMe


Id have struggled and resisted to, they had no rights to put their hands on him he committed no crimes....

He asked a question, they assaulted him...


"not directed at you"


How much more of this crap is it gonna take before people wake up and see the road we are headed down...




[edit on 17-9-2007 by C0le]


reply posted on 17-9-2007 @ 10:41 PM by section8citizen
Originally posted by MasterRegal
WRONG! He was tasered because he was violently resisting the officers. They even warned him and did not comply. Don't spread bull.


The only thing WRONG here is your response to this video. If you do not know your right, please go learn them If you saw anything in this video that justifies the treatment of this collage student, then clearly you do not know your rights as a citizen or you do know them in word but not in practice.

#1. This kid is asking a question in a forum in which he is encouraged to do so. When did this become a crime? Even if his question was not popular, when did unpopular speech become a crime? This is also known as the Larry Flynt defense. His case was based on "unpopular" speech and went all the way to the US Supreme Court and Flynt won.

#2. For asking a question these "Officers" walked right up to him and assaulted him. They did not ask that he step outside, they did not ask him anything. They march up to him and begin to manhandle him toward the door. In the USA that is NOT how we are supposed to do things.

#3. What you call resisting I call defending. If someone (police or not) walks up to me and begins to grab on me, you will be lucky to walk away with all your teeth intact in your head. However, we did not see that in this video. The kid was not being aggressive. All he really was doing was preventing these officers from handcuffing him. I would have done the same thing especially since they did not tell me WHY and because I was simply asking questions which in this country is NOT ILLEGAL. You have the right to ask ANYONE, ANYTHING you want. The government does not decide what you can ask and should you ask a question they dislike, you get arrested for it. It does not work like that in the USA. Or at least it shouldn't.

#4. Kerry himself seemed surprised. You can hear him saying, "No I want to answer his questions" so in essence the kid was arrested and tased for asking questions to someone who was willing to answer them? Explain this to me like I am a 5 year old...where is the crime? Since when is mutual conversation against the law? Please show me this law which would enable police to use force against me while I conversate with another person. I would love to see it. In the real world we like to call this "abuse of power".

#5. Have you EVER heard of "reasonable force"? This kid is pinned down to the ground. You are telling me at the point in which he was tased he was a threat to someone? If anything he was a pain in the a** for these cops, but not a threat. If it was a matter of not allowing himself to be cuffed, can you really sit here and tell me that not one of the 15 cops standing on him or above him could have simply pulled his arm out? It was absolutely necessary to tase him? From where I sit, the kid was threatened with tasing. Then you hear him begging not to tase him. AT that point it is safe to assume that he will let you cuff him because he is scared of being hit with a taser. So why tase him anyway? This is what we in the real world who know our rights call "excessive force".


reply posted on 17-9-2007 @ 11:23 PM by section8citizen
reply to post by TheAvenger



IMO he was tazed for the amusement of the cops and to be taught a lesson that next time he will just do as he is told.

Keep in mind, In your quote I was responding to what was said by another. The first part of what you quoted was not my quote.


reply posted on 17-9-2007 @ 11:33 PM by section8citizen
reply to post by cbianchi513



I disagree, the kid is clearly resisting arrest. The real issue here is weather or not he should have resisted. IMO the kid was right. I would have resisted arrest also. It is not illegal to ask questions, especially in a forum where that is encouraged. So why is he under arrest? If the reasons for his "arrest" are bogus, is he really resisting?

The other issue here is that the cops assaulted this kid. The second they reached out and began manhandling him that was assault. If he was under arrest, he should have been told so and given the option to comply. He was never given an option. This situation was esculated by the officers. The kid does himself no favors, but I can't blame him. I would have acted very similar if not worse if I was being arrested for asking questions during a Q&A session.


reply posted on 17-9-2007 @ 11:37 PM by Black_Fox
reply to post by UM_Gazz



Thanks for finding that article.
Thanks for your help.

Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5  >>    ^^TOP^^