Originally posted by St Udio
Originally posted by ClintK
I'm a little puzzled by what several posters have said now about how they (the investors who bought the puts). don't have much to lose.
let's use an anology.........
i used to go to the horse track,
whenever a race had a 'trifecta' available
And there were 6 horses racing - - -
one could place a Trifecta box for less than $250.00
and IF the Win-Place-Show horses paid more than the $250.oo invested
then you'd Win
[edit on 26-8-2007 by St Udio]
I understand what you're saying, but for that analogy to apply, the buyer would have had to buy an equal number of calls. It's basic hedging. This
is not an uncommon strategy in a volatile market, or with a particularly volatile stock. But unlike horse races, sometimes you win both ways and
sometimes you don't win at all. The options have to exceed their strike price in order to make any money at all. If they don't reach their strike
price but come close, you might be able to recoup some of the money you paid for the contract, but you'd lose money.
On the other hand, the stock might exceed the strike price of your call a week after you bought it, in which case you'd exercise your call and make a
profit (unless you thought it would go up even more, then you'd wait). Then, a month later, after you'd already made money on the call, the stock
falls below the strike price of the put. Now you can exercise that option and make money on the falling price.
But in this case, there was not a corresponding purchase of calls, and the puts would only make money if the value of the whole index fund fell by
more than 30 percent. Even under pretty bad market conditions it's crazy to bet the market is going to rise or fall by 30 percent in four weeks.
The only time it ever did that was the crash of '29. The only other time it ever came close was Black Monday in 1987 (22 percent). But that was
attributed to computer programs that automatically sold stocks when they hit certain levels and that problem was fixed.
So the investors who bought these puts are probably going to lose everything they paid
unless they know something!
Look, would
ANY of you buy puts on an index fund (not a single stock, mind you, an entire index fund) that expire in four weeks with a strike
price more than 30 percent below what that index is at today? As near as I can see, that would be like throwing your money out the window.