It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by LazyGuy
....... Footage like that would change the world.....
Originally posted by Sataurë
I have to agree that the palm tree's are an utterly ridiculous excuse to call this a hoax, and a poorly investigated claim as well.
Here are only a couple of the many flaws with the reasoning:
 This video is NOT compiled COMPLETELY of CGI elements. Anyone with half a brain can see that this is a contiguously filmed video (minus the debatable UFO's). *WHY* would anyone in their right mind CGI in palm trees?! Is it not a LOT less difficult to go film some and THEN dub in the UFO?
 The trees are not identical. There are numerous visible differences between the trees, and if you live in the tropics like i do, you will know that palm trees have VERY little differentiation in their shapes, unlike oaks for example.
[edit on 10-8-2007 by Sataurë]
Originally posted by dntwastetime
Why would a cgi guy do all this work just to make a totally obvious cloning mistake like this?
Originally posted by housegroove23
Labeling the thread a (possible hoax) is a good compromise, It makes everyone happy all around. I too believe that this does not deserve the official hoax title yet. Especially after promomag posted that picture of palm trees that all have the same features. Good job promomag, I was thinking of doing that myself.
I think that more of us should do more comparison with objects in real world pictures against the object in question. The following thread is a good example of doing this but sometimes I think that they over do it.