It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by stumason
Dj, you and others are MISSING THE POINT. The debate has no gone so far off on a tangent I gave up.
The bottom line is (and why I personally don't believe it) is that it claims AQ was in Baghdad in 1991 conducting the same level of intimidation and tactics as it does now.
BO XIAN and others argued the toss with me over this, yet none of them could offer any credible evidence AQ was in Iraq in 1991.
But, no one listens to me anyway.........
Originally posted by djohnsto77
I don't see any reason to not believe the story, given the history of what al Qaeda has done, it doesn't seem farfetched at all.
Originally posted by neformore
Originally posted by djohnsto77
I believe he reported on a source whom he thought was credible.
Thought. Thought
Thats the key word here.
Since when has factual news reporting been about what the reporter thinks?
Isn't news reporting supposed to be about facts?
This story was presented as fact. Its no such thing. Its even turned out that the guy who reported it says it could be an urban legend for all he knows.
So what makes this story more valid than other various Urban Legends of lore?
[edit on 22/0707/07 by neformore]
Originally posted by Sunsetspawn
Still though, the bottom line here is the tremendous logical fallacy of intimidating someone into being a freedom fighter. Terrorist/freedom fighter groups are only effective when they have a passion for what they are doing, not when they've been scared into it.
He was baptized a Catholic, attended a monastery school early in life, and was a communicant and altar boy as a youth. During his years as Chancellor and then dictator of Nazi Germany, he was never excommunicated or condemned, even though the Vatican knew much of his policies and activities. The only major complaints from Rome regarded interference in Church matters. And those were largely silenced by the 1933 Concordat with the Vatican, under Pope Pius XII, which to Hitler meant that the Catholic Church recognized the Nazi state.
Adolf Hitler was brought up in his family's religion by his Roman Catholic parents. According to historian Bradley F. Smith, Hitler's father, though nominally a Catholic, was a freethinker, while his mother was a practicing Catholic.[2] In his childhood, Hitler had admired the pomp of Catholic ritual and the hierarchical organization of the clergy. Later, he drew on these elements, organizing his party along hierarchical lines and including liturgical forms into events or using phraseology taken from hymns
The staff report said that bin Laden "explored possible cooperation with Iraq" while in Sudan through 1996, but that "Iraq apparently never responded" to a bin Laden request for help in 1994. The commission cited reports of contacts between Iraq and al Qaeda after bin Laden went to Afghanistan in 1996, adding, "but they do not appear to have resulted in a collaborative relationship. Two senior bin Laden associates have adamantly denied that any ties existed between al Qaeda and Iraq. We have no credible evidence that Iraq and al Qaeda cooperated on attacks against the United States."
Osama bin Laden swore vengeance against America if Iraq was attacked, and demanded that the Muslim world stand in solidarity with the Muslim people of Iraq. In very clear words, Osama bin Laden told the people of Iraq to rise up against both American aggression and against "socialist" Saddam Hussein. If the translations that were provided were reliable, there is no ambiguity in bin Laden's words on the matter. So much, it seems, for Powell's case that Hussein and bin Laden are working together.
It is unlikely that the decidedly secular Baathist regime--which has savagely suppressed Islamists within Iraq--would be able to maintain close links with Osama bin Laden and his followers. In fact, Saudi Prince Turki bin Faisal, his country's former intelligence chief, noted that bin Laden views Saddam Hussein "as an apostate, an infidel, or someone who is not worthy of being a fellow Muslim" and that bin Laden had offered in 1990 to raise an army of thousands of mujaheddin fighters to liberate Kuwait from Iraqi occupation.
Originally posted by neformore
I'm not a Muslim. I'm not a Christian. I don't subscribe to any particular religion. I actually believe its all superstitious nonsense, and that living life based on whats written in a book is nuts. I don't see people living their lives based on Jeffrey Archer novels.
I don't "apologise" for people who do blatantly vicious and horrific things in the name of their supposed religion, be they christian or muslim.
Terrorists are terrorists. They do not represent a whole section of a particular population. If that were the case then all Christians would be terrorists because of the actions of the IRA/UDF/UVF etc, and all Muslims would be terrorists because of Al-Quaeda.
And plainly they are not.
No particular religion is more vicious than another.
If you believe that then as far as I'm concerned you live in la-la land with the fairies.
The focus may be on the muslims now, but christianity, and people of the christian faith has committed more than its fair share of atrocities over the years, . . . .
If you can't see that, or wish to try and paint those people as none-Christian, then you are in denial and trying to re-write history.
No particular religion is more vicious than another.
If you believe that then as far as I'm concerned you live in la-la land with the fairies.
but christianity, and people of the christian faith has committed more than its fair share of atrocities over the years, as I've detailed previously.
If you can't see that, or wish to try and paint those people as none-christian then you are in denial and trying to re-write history.
In essence you are judging by "standards" today, without looking at a truly historical perspective.
I'm not a journalist. I'm not in a position to write a story and send it out onto the Associated Press circuit and see if someone picks it up. I'm a person writing on a messageboard and giving my opinion. As such I don't have a responsibility - although I do try my best - to establish the facts of a situtation before I release something.
And yet, heres this guy - this Micheal Yon, he IS a journalist. And yet he released a story that he admits might be urban legend.
Originally posted by DarkStormCrow
Check this site for photos of Hitler and Nazi Germany as it relates to Christianity.
It doesnt really matter if we regard Hitler and the Nazis as Christinas what is important is that the regarded themselves that way.
I beg to differ. He's a Friend of mine and I assure you it matters to Him enormously.
Originally posted by zysin5
Lets just say this, Hilter was doing the dirty work of the church. And they loved him for it, and still do. And umm Hilter wasnt a Satanist, he was christian just like you!! Seems most you christians are satan worshippers, oh but you call Satan God, and Jesus...
Originally posted by neformore
I've just re-read all of this thread.
So far I have been told that I am the following
In Denial
Anti-christian
A Terrorist Appeaser
I'm akin to a Nazi
I'm a muslim
I need my belief system changing
I need to review how I assimilate evidence.
My aethisim is a religion (I was a muslim not long ago!)
I've been told that I hate/loathe and wish to eradicate from the planet people with a certain perspective.
My opinion on that does not fit into other peoples sense of reality, and as such that - combined with my views that the major religions are as bad as each other when it comes to blood letting, and that no individual or group is better than another - apparently makes me all of the above.
So far I have been told that I am the following
In Denial
Anti-christian
A Terrorist Appeaser
I'm akin to a Nazi
I'm a muslim
I need my belief system changing
I need to review how I assimilate evidence.
My aethisim is a religion (I was a muslim not long ago!)
I've been told that I hate/loathe and wish to eradicate from the planet people with a certain perspective.
But as for these enemies of mine, who did not want me to reign over them, bring them here and slaughter them before me. luke 19-27
When God/Jesus gives gifts, (the money) he expects something in return
(the slaying of his enemies) which would be anyone who does not acknowledge his kingship.