Debunk This Video, page 2
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 36 times


reply posted on 22-6-2007 @ 03:58 AM by redmage
Hello rdubb4, and welcome to ATS

Originally posted by rdubb4
I am not trying to say that I accept the official story, but this is NOT the film I would show to someone that was on the fence about the subject, and there is not much to debunk besides a guys inferences.


Apparently the “entertainment value” of the film wasn’t to your taste. It certainly is a film that works on two levels. On the first level you have a guy “losing himself” (in a Fight Club’esque manner) as his research takes him deeper, and deeper; and on the second, you have the plethora of research & information itself. It’s in that second level that there’s much information for people to attempt to disprove/debunk (if they’re up to the challenge).

Originally posted by rdubb4
Its almost patronizing the way they yell at the viewer.


Might I suggest for you to not take the film so personally. He’s not “yelling at the viewer”; he’s arguing with different facets of his own psyche. Through the creative use of those facets, as individual characters, he makes the film much more interesting than if he were to just have a narrator constantly voiceover all of his inner dialogue.

Originally posted by rdubb4
It is fairly interesting, but with nothing to back these assumptions up, there is not much to debunk.
I just cant believe instead of showing 5 versions of the same guy, the person who made this film couldn't show some of his sources to the viewers.


There’s plenty of information to back up his conclusions, and he does cite various sources throughout the film (such as interviews, experts, the 9/11 Commission report, etc.), but if he were to stop and cite a source every 15-30 seconds; it would kill any/all of the entertainment value in the film. I believe it was the filmmaker’s intention to raise questions that may inspire viewers to do some research on their own. I’d suggest jotting down any pieces that you found interesting, and then doing a bit of research on your own. You may be surprised at what you'll find. Such as…

Originally posted by rdubb4
EDIT: I just saw the laptop nerd claim "There is evidence that Mohammed Atta had flight training at Maxwell Airforce base"... then where the hell is it?


It was all over during the days/weeks following 9/11.

First there was the MSM's earliest hints.


Then, there were numerous articles citing statements by Air Force spokesman Col. Ken McClellan.
www.summeroftruth.org..." target="_blank" class="postlink">Source
Air Force spokesman Col. Ken McClellan said a man named Mohamed Atta -- which the FBI has identified as one of the five hijackers of American Airlines Flight 11 -- had once attended the International Officer's School at Maxwell/Gunter Air Force Base in Montgomery, Ala.


There was talk that the clerical records had some discrepancies regarding biographical data (such as a non-matching D.O.B. between the “graduate” and the “hijacker”); however, I’ve also read fellow student's claims that the “hijacker” is the person that they recognize from their days at the school, and no alternate (59 year old "Atta") has ever been brought to light.

[edit on 6/22/07 by redmage]


reply posted on 25-6-2007 @ 03:12 PM by 11Bravo
Originally posted by Fowl Play
With respect, i think you should be careful in your assumptions, unless of course you can back your allegations up with evidence, but as of yet, i have seen absolutely no evidence to suggest " The Government" did it, i very much dispute that, and it is a dangerous accusation to make.
Correct me if i am wrong.


You are WRONG on so many levels I dont know where to begin.
Im with John Lear on this one as well.
Who are you? Telling me that speaking truth is dangerous? Asking questions of the people that work for me is dangerous?

The truth may be painful, but lies are deadly. Remember that.

I was telling an old co-workor that 9-11 was an inside job, and low and behold if another co-worker didnt jump right up and shout "YOU HAVE NO RIGHT TO SAY THAT! YOU DONT KNOW THAT!"
I promptly turned to him and gave him my best steely gaze.
"When did my right to free speach get removed and how long have you been a communist?" I asked him.
He stuttered and stimied and shuffled away.

WKJO is and excellent flick, a little more on the eclectic side IMO, but good none the less.
Well put together and researched, and just artsy enough to be entertaining.
Dude is a good actor, and to be quite honest with you there are a few scenes in there that reminded me of myself when I was waking up to the entire charade, chain smoking, paperwork spread out on the floor, not sleeping or eating for a few days at a time.
Those were the early days, and I would imagine that many of us went through that phase.
Now the shock has worn off and its just a matter of talking to everybody we can, at every opportunity.
We dont have to convince anybody of anything, all we have to do is get them to ask some basic questions.



reply posted on 26-6-2007 @ 01:34 PM by ADVISOR
Twitchy

Just as the
History of Terrorism, al Qaeda connection to CIA thread had no counters, my money is on the fact none will stand here as well. More info supporting what has been presented, will be found, than any thing contrary to.

That much is obvious, just by reading over the original thread on the video.


reply posted on 26-6-2007 @ 07:53 PM by ADVISOR
Maybe, but at least your getting replies. I have posted quite a few threads that for sure were great topics. In my opinion at least, but never even goten a reply. Come to think of it, the majority of my threads, seen to be "ignored" at least it seems.

Perhaps the subject/s are too indepth or out of most peoples interests. But when I do get that occasional one which generates a handful of replies, I feel it was worth the effort of all the failed posts.

Then there are the threads which generate two pages, if only by a couple posts. Those give me the impression I found a subject of interest, only to see it stop in its tracks. Perhaps it is due to attention spans, or maybe just loss of interest. Then again, it could be the fact most of my threads may deter replies because they are government topics or fields, most are not familar with. Or even nervous about posting to.

When it comes down to it, UFOs and SciFi wins out over fact or reality 90% any ways. Seems the majority is more interested in aliens than what the governments are trying to hide. We can point out government indecency until our voices and fingers are sore, it falls mostly on deaf ears and blind eyes.

No one feels the can do any thing to change the government, but bring EBEs into the fray and suddenly, nothing is stopping anyone, besides the fact there is no solid proof. Present proof of a government act, and it isn't even beleived, or it is simply ignored...

Go figure.


Civilizations have risen and fallen, because of the people changeing their government/s. History proved as much, and history repeats, just like the seasons. To learn from the past, one can better prepare for the future.

Ok, I'm done, that was one heck of a tangent even for me.

LoL

[edit on 26-6-2007 by ADVISOR]


reply posted on 14-7-2007 @ 11:50 AM by ThomasT
I just dunno whazzamatta with you guys, How can u not believe the guvermen`They told us clearly time and again. An Arab, dying of kidney failure in a ME hospital, shuts down the half trillon dollar US air defenses with his laptop from a cave in Afghan. He sends incompetants to board planes without boarding passes, tickets or being on any pax list. They dont appear on the boarding cctv, but in the cockpits, they overpower burley US flight crew with boxcutters. Knowing they will not be intercepted they find the secret corridor between US and Canada where there is NO NORAD nor FAA radar cover. They fly like supertopguns, though one couldnt solo a Cessna 172 with 600 hours in his logbook, and fly 180 ton jets at full speed and hit buildings precisely. The planes vapourise at 3000 plus degrees, but our brave Govt did find and test all the on-board DNA at the penta crash. DNA is normally deaded at 100deg C. The dastardly terrs are not all deaded, however, as BBC reports half still alive after the antics. Buidings fall naturally from jet fuel, niot from the stupid conspiracy theory of min nukes and thermirte from odd ball nutty professors of Phsics. The few hundred anomalies mentioned by conspiracy theorists are all proven in Popular Mechanics to be maguc. Trust our Govt. They now have to fight the psychic, immortal, terrs for ever and ever. So u see, I am for the guvermen, and nobody need threaten me.

[edit on 14-7-2007 by ThomasT]

[edit on 14-7-2007 by ThomasT]
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5  >>    ^^TOP^^



ALL ATS`ers are terrorists
  Posted 3 days ago with 9 member flags
CNN Endorsing Terrorism
  Posted 6 days ago with 7 member flags
Obama\'s terror Drones.
  Posted 4 days ago with 6 member flags
Pair Detained in Twitter Homeland Threat Mix-Up
  Posted 11 days ago with 5 member flags

Newest topics getting replies, in real-time:

Stop Bashing Us Military Folks.
  Rant, Posted 16 hours ago, 188 replies
Anonymous hacks CIA
  Breaking Alternative News, Posted 11 hours ago, 105 replies
Free Psychic Readings
  General Chit Chat, Posted 7 hours ago, 75 replies