Originally posted by Jazzerman
The earliest mention of the book was in a mid-17th Century letter from Georg Baresch (an Alchemist) to Athanasius Kircher (cryptographer who deciphered Heiroglyphic texts), and shortly thereafter Kircher was given the book and for about 200 years there was no further historical records of the Manuscript until around 1912 when Wilfrid Voynich bought it....
As for the Voynich Manuscript, it seems to be a quite odd coincidence that a man such as Georg Baresch, an Alchemist himself, was the first documented possessor of this script and that the illustrations are very Alchemical in nature. There is no documented proof of the existance of the Manuscript before his letters and thus anyone investigating where the Manuscript came from is left with no further information precluding his ownership. I have always had the feeling that the Manuscript was a hoax or "gag" if you will that Baresch was playing on Kircher. Kircher was one of the most notorious Cryptographers of his day (although most of his suppositions are now considered to be wrong and were usurped by Descartes shortly after his time) and a leader in the field of Egyptology. By the standards of the day he was considered to be the scientific equal of Leonardo Da Vinci, and there would be good reason for someone to try and take him down from his pedestal as the pinnacle of scientific reasoning. I will put forth the idea that Baresch created the document to try and hide the failings of his own brand of "science", by trying to make a fool of one of the leading scientists of the day: Kircher.
Not a bad speculation.
For those of you not familiar with this, the field of language studies is part of what points to it as a hoax. Languages have repeatable bits in them (nouns, verbs, etc) and they follow a certain pattern of sentence structure. You can see this even if you're not familar with the language.
It's the cryptographers and linguists who have said it's a hoax. Fake books have always been around and were a source of income for the unscrupulous ("No, seriously, Thomas. This is the diary that Jesus kept when he was in the wilderness. Would I lie to you?") This is one of the more famous historical frauds...but there have been many.


