It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by David_Reale
Is it really necessary for an underground base like Dulce to have giant air vents? Can't they produce their own air down there if they have to, instead of putting out air vent shafts that can be spotted by anyone who cares to stop by? Seems a little stupid to me to reveal the presence of a base like that.
Originally posted by johnlear
I would like to get something clear here. You say that Paul Bennewitz swallowed everything hook, line and sinker. Could you please direct me to exactly what he said or wrote that would have you believe that he swallowed everything hook, line and sinker.
Originally posted by johnlear
my policy is "trust but VERIFY"
Originally posted by johnlear
I would like to get something clear here. You say that Paul Bennewitz swallowed everything hook, line and sinker. Could you please direct me to exactly what he said or wrote that would have you believe that he swallowed everything hook, line and sinker.
There is much information in the public domain that points towards Bennewitz believing the information and disinformation he was fed.
Originally posted by Tattoo1377
Originally posted by whaaa
The vents are in clear view from highway 537 on the Rez.
If they are clearly visible, then how about a photo or two, eh?
Not trying to be difficult or challenging to you in particular...
No disrespect intended towards any testimonials, but pictures of vents would be a strong contribution at this point, and reinforce the whole story IMO...
Cheers!
Originally posted by johnlear
Torsion if its not too much trouble could you please reread my post above yours and answer it. Thank you very much.
Originally posted by Whaaa
Sorry no pictures. The reason I didn't take any was because I assumed that the vents and bigass fans [12' dia] were part of the natural gas/oil production that is a huge deal for the Jicarilla's.
If you are asking me for a written statement by Bennewitz himself saying "I swallowed everything hook, line and sinker!" then I don't have one.
Originally posted by whaaa
Originally posted by Tattoo1377
Originally posted by whaaa
The vents are in clear view from highway 537 on the Rez.
If they are clearly visible, then how about a photo or two, eh?
Not trying to be difficult or challenging to you in particular...
No disrespect intended towards any testimonials, but pictures of vents would be a strong contribution at this point, and reinforce the whole story IMO...
Cheers!
Sorry no pictures. The reason I didn't take any was because I assumed that the vents and bigass fans [12' dia] were part of the natural gas/oil production that is a huge deal for the Jicarilla's. They are not secret and are clearly visible with trucks coming and going all the time at these installations.
Originally posted by David_Reale
Yo, ppl.
I'm trying to write a novel or book or something about Dulce (partly involving the supposed base there), and I've got some questions. I know nothing is proven fact, but I'm not arrogant enough either to believe that MY opinion is necessarily the true one, so what I'm asking for here is your opinion about what the case is.
:
Originally posted by johnlear
Paul Bennewitz happened to stumble onto the existence of dulce like I did, but through completely different channels. Your statement was making it sound like you had evidence that Dulce was hoax which it is not. And that has always been my opinion and the opinion of many others.
I think it is better to state that Bennewitz and yourself stumbled onto the story of Dulce rather than the existence as there is no evidence to show that it does exist - and thus, it is only a story.
Bennewitz only thought is was there, like he though the radio transmissions he was receiving were from outer space and not the military base.
You say you were given information about Dulce by a Mr X (I fail to see why you can't reveal his name - unless you were never given it!),
but it was all circulating around the same time and as far as I can see it all derives from Myrna Hansen's dubious tale as related to Bennewitz and Sprinkle while under hypnosis.
Originally posted by johnlear
You can't see the underground city at DIA either, but it's there. Neither can you see SMU's, but they're there. Relax torsion, nobody is going to ever prove anything about any of this. At least not in our lifetime.
In fact, I think all you have is Bill Moore's or Doty's word. You continue to state your opinions as fact which I find interesting. Its as if you are trying to convince yourself of your opinions.
Mr. X showed me the general area where he hid the box south of Boulder dam but I never saw the box itself.
Please explain what would be the point of him doing this? And why, if they existed, would the boxes need to be hidden?
Originally posted by johnlear
You are going to have to research a little of the Dulce story so that you don't ask questions such as the above which has been asked and answered several billion times..
I can lead you to water but I can't make you drink. But I still enjoy your posts as they bring a smile to my face.
Maybe you need to rest that typing wrist and go smoke a cigar
IThese waters that you lead people to seem to be very muddy and polluted - entertaining and amusing, for sure, but not suitable for drinking!
Originally posted by torsion
I recommend that you read Project Beta by Greg Bishop. It's the definitive study of Paul Bennewitz who is responsible for starting the story of the underground base at Dulce. In order to keep him away from the nearby military base he was encouraged to believe that there really was an alien base and provided with false information by the military.