Originally posted by Leyla
Technally outdated?! Buzzz wrong. Milk gets out dated- bread gets outdated-Shall I go on?
The U.S. Constitution is a historical document thats older then you and me. It is a priceless treasure and should be valued as such. We should have
higher respect for the Constitution then calling it outdated or just a piece of paper. It is the back bone of America. And as long a we tinker with it
adding more tinks to it it will soon crumble. What right do we have of calling the Constitution a piece of paper or calling it outdated? Borg please
don't listen to that nonsense.
Yes, it's outdated, and it is so for several reasons. One of those reasons is times change. The Constitution can't change with the times unless
people adapt it along the way, which is why the Founders left We the People with the 10th Amendment, which states thus:
Amendment X
The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the states, are reserved to the states respectively, or to
the people.
Courtesy of
Cornell University.
They foresaw our current plight, and built in a solution, through the form of the amendment process, to insure that we'd have a way to trump any
injustices being done to us by those that we elected to "serve" us. They also added in the clause above that effectively makes it our
duty to
do so when we deem it necessary. I've never stated that these documents were anything
BUT genius in design, but they
are outdated
because they don't adequately handle the current political ebbs and flows that are permeating every facet of our existence. Jefferson goes into a bit
of a rant on this too, which I will now give some excerpts of:
Needed Revisions
"Smaller objections [I have to the new Constitution] are [the omission of] the appeals on matters of fact as well as law, and the binding of all
persons, Legislative, Executive, and Judiciary, by oath to maintain that constitution." --Thomas Jefferson to James Madison, 1787. ME 6:390
"I apprehend... that the total abandonment of the principle of rotation in the offices of President and Senator will end in abuse." --Thomas
Jefferson to Edward Rutledge, 1788. ME 7:81
Courtesy of
the University of Virginia.
Having said this, I want to again make it clear that I never intended anyone to think that I somehow thought that there was anything
wrong with
the Constitution's premises. God forbid I ever say something like that. All that I was, and still am saying, is that there is a need to update it a
little bit. It's time to modernize it. It's what Thomas Jefferson would have done long ago. If he saw the country in the position it finds itself in
today, what do you think his reaction would be?
As always, let me know what you think.
TheBorg