It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Koka
So God just IS, which about sums it up for most religious types.
No debate I have seen on ATS has ever managed to convince a believer in God, that he may not exist, in fact I have yet to see a believer even question Gods existence.
Normally, it takes a profound experience to either turn someone toward or away from the bossom of God.
So for those with an open mind:
In all the universe are we the only planet he granted life to, if so do they have their own version of the Bible?
Apart from a few potato chips or pretzels looking like the Virgin Mary, he seems to be running a little short on miracles, was he just going through a phase when he was dishing them out a couple of thousand years ago?
As a believer in Evolution and things as yet unfound, I have no reason to question why I am here.
For what reason did God create you?
Originally posted by Jakko
Time does not exist?
Time does exist, the only problem is that we are in time, and that God is not in time.
No matter how hard you try to get your little "infinite mind" around concepts like infinity and the defenition of time, you will not succeed.
To me this is knowledge.
Knowing that some things can not be fully grasped by a human mind, not because we are not intelligent enough, but because fully understanding such concepts requires us to have seen/experienced certain things that humans have never experiened or seen.
You seem so desperate to find answers to these unanswerable questions that you hysterically start creating your own reality in the process, thinking that you're smart and "more limitless" over the rest of us.
You seem to assume certain things that are not result of knowledge but of your own fantasy.
Reality is just too complex for that.
Could you maybe explain why time would not exist?
Cause I really wonder how you got to that stage.
Originally posted by Jakko
He's not running short on miracles, you just don't go to places where that kind of stuff happens.
Originally posted by Jakko
1. You do not know what infinite is. You may know that it's something that has no limits/no end but you do not fully understand what that word means.
Claiming that you do is not only arrogant, but it is also blocking your thoughts from actually ending up somewhere interesting.
This exactly what I mean when I say that sometimes realizing you can't grasp something will actually lead to more knowledge, but you are not in this stage yet.
The only way for God to see and hear all, is by being all.
Another hysterical mind-jump, performed by someone unable to fully realize what he is talking about.
And that's not a bad thing, cause no human being can understand how God can hear and see us, while not being part of time. Not understanding this is not a bad thing, because we are not yet in a stage where we can understand it.
People who still attempt to try to understand it all like yourself end up in discussions that make no sense whatsoever.
People do not like discussing with you (maybe you've allready noticed ;+)
This is not because you are unkind or disrespectfull because you're not. This is also not because you are dumb, because you are probably not dumb at all.
It's the quick assuming when we're talking about the most complex things that annoys others.
Your opinions, ideas, and theories are result of what you have seen and experienced in your (short) life.
Yet you talk as if you have seen it all, and as if you are the one human being that does understand things that "we normal people" don't.
This is of course ape#.
You do not know it all, and you never will.
Your desire to know it all is too strong for you to gain the knowledge that some things are not for humans to understand, so your version of truth will probably be a very interesting -but not valid- one.
Could you maybe, next time you repeat your "wisdom" also explain how you got to all those quick assumptions?
Originally posted by Jakko
A little experiment.
What if you could create a computerprogram that has "objects" in it that think like humans.
Objects that are as complex as humans with an AI and thinking that's just as complex as humans.
Now you would also program the world around them, everything they see hear and feel would be part of your program. The interval at which a new "frame" is made for the entire world would be set to 0.1 second.
The "humans" in your program would live and die in this timeframe of a new "moment" every 0.1 second.
Not only would they not even notice their world is "advancing" pretty slowly, they would not even be able to ever find out about it without a reference to "an outside clock".
Because that reference would not exist, they would wonder how it all works, where they are coming from and what's happening.
The creator of this program (you) would be able to pause the program, without the objects in it ever noticing the world in which they live is paused. The creator of this program would be able to see and hear everything at all times, but He would not be part of his creation once.
He would see these "objects" trying to get their mind around concepts like infinity and time, and he would have a good laugh noticing the talk about the creator being everything in their world because the creator can see everything as well.
In the end it does not matter wether he would set the "speed" to 1 frame every 0.1 seconds, or 1 frame every 500 seconds. Nothing would change for the objects living in this world.
Of course this little story is not the exact situation we are in, but I think when I read stuff in the bible like "for God 1 second is like 1000 years and the other way around", a similar situation could be truth.
When you look at it like this, you also realize how pointless it is to try to understand things we can not see or understand without a direct reference to the place where God is.
Originally posted by Raye
If there is no God and Atheists firmly believe that why are they always arguing a point that is a clear attempt to steal anothers faith when they have nothing better to sell or anything to gain for that matter. Why not just be silent unless to ponder the fact that maybe it shouldn't all be in our ability to understand of course unless we are a clear cut narcicist and know all. If you are not God and clearly believe as you stated that nothing could create nothing then your good. However, for those of us that have seen things that defy your naturalistic realm, gravity and such...let's just say I'm a little more knowledgeable than you. But you too can have the knowlegde that you so vehemently seek. Your mind is closed because its already made up. If only you search and ask the right questions to the right God the truth will be disclosed to you.
Originally posted by quiksilver
I'm gonna get flamed :s.
God probably doesn't exist, BUT why does it matter if he doesn't exist or not? I feel safer knowing that there is a god and knowing that there is someone there to aid me, so i CHOOSE to believe in god because it makes me FEEL better not because he IS there and powerful and whatever.
Originally posted by Seapeople
The same molecules, the same minerals. The same Atoms comprise everything. We are made up of the same elements as everything else on earth. There are molecules in our body that are the exact same as molecules outside of our body...in rocks for instance.
Now, what makes them different than molecules in our body. Why is the "Construction" of molecules in a rock not alive while the "construction" of molecules in our body is alive?
As far as infinity goes. The word was invented by a person. It was invented to describe a concept he could not understand.
Just knowing the word does not indicate a full comprehension of it. For instance. You can know what the word indoctrinate means. Fully understanding that word does not mean you understand the indoctrination.
Originally posted by lilblam
Originally posted by Seapeople
The same molecules, the same minerals. The same Atoms comprise everything. We are made up of the same elements as everything else on earth. There are molecules in our body that are the exact same as molecules outside of our body...in rocks for instance.
Now, what makes them different than molecules in our body. Why is the "Construction" of molecules in a rock not alive while the "construction" of molecules in our body is alive?
Human definition of "alive" is very limited. Everything is alive, including any and all matter. Just different levels of awareness. Alive is a very VERY limited concept from human standards, because if I use nanotechnology and construct a robot, he would be considered ALIVE by humans. Why? Because I will use molecules and construct little genetically-capable structures that you can call cells, and out of this a self-reproducing etc cybergenetic being. This is because what you call biology is simply high technology, well higher technology than we possess anyway. Once we possess the technology to construct biological entities, our definition of "alive" will drastically change. Consciousness exists in all.
As far as infinity goes. The word was invented by a person. It was invented to describe a concept he could not understand.
It was invented to describe a concept, that he COULD understand. The concept: No limitation, no end, no termination. In order to describe this concept, he invented the word infinity. It's that simple.
Just knowing the word does not indicate a full comprehension of it. For instance. You can know what the word indoctrinate means. Fully understanding that word does not mean you understand the indoctrination.
But by understanding that word as much as I do, is enough to utilize it in speech and writing, and enough to understand it when reading. I don't HAVE to be indoctrinated to understand it, I don't have to know every single little part of indoctrination to know what it means.
I don't have to know every part of infinity to know infinity, because the ONLY way to know every part of infinity is to BE infinity. The thing is, just by saying "no limit" or "all possibilities exist" I express a conceptual understanding of infinity. That is all that's required to talk about what I was talking about, otherwise I wouldn't say it.
I only tell you what I KNOW, not what I assume.
Originally posted by Jakko
Originally posted by quiksilver
I'm gonna get flamed :s.
God probably doesn't exist, BUT why does it matter if he doesn't exist or not? I feel safer knowing that there is a god and knowing that there is someone there to aid me, so i CHOOSE to believe in god because it makes me FEEL better not because he IS there and powerful and whatever.
Noone gets flamed. ;+)
First of all, God does exist. I don't expect you to trust me on that, but after what I have seen in my life I can't be like "it's fine that you think he does not exist".
Cause it's not fine really.
It would be like "it's fine that you think 1+1=3, I respect your ignorance".
I don't respect your ignorance, but I respect you and I hope you will somehow find out about God, cause it makes your life have a lot more sense.
Of course like you said, some choose to believe in God because they want to. That's how it starts in a lot of cases. But at a certain age a lot of christians (including me) come to a point where they start wondering wether what they believe in is real.
I found out it is real, but not on the way I once wanted to find out.
I asked God for hard proof so many times, but it seemed as if my question did not make sense, I was not sure why.
Later on I realized that any "hard proof" God can give in a moment, is weak compared to the way He can show himself through a period of time.(a life for example)
It all has to do with how humans work. If God's existance would be proven through a miracle today, it would make me believe today. But as more time passes, more doubts about the "hard proof" would rise and in the end I will wonder wether it was not just my imagination, asking God for new proof.
The amount of miracles performed by Jesus and by all christians over time was never the main reason people started to believe. Even today miracles happen. Praying is not without effect, and even though in theory, one prayer leading to a miracle would be enough to convince the world of God's existance, the world is not convinced no matter how much proof they get.
That's why superfacial miracles "just to proof Gods existance" almost never happen. Most miracles today have something to do with people being freed from diseases or evil entities.
These miracles serve a purpose other then to prove Gods existance.
The best example of this is right on these forums.
If I would tell you what I have seen in my life that made me know for sure God exists, you would say things like:
- cool story, but I wasn't there
- that could have been coincidence
- you probably misunderstood the situation
- you were hallucinating
After a while of me trying to share my story, getting these responses I would start to doubt it myself.
Did I really see what I think I saw? Couldn't it have been coincidence?
And there goes Gods proof, and my faith based on that one moment.
God understands us better then we understand ourselves and he knows what proof you need for a lasting impact, and this is not often proof that lasts just one moment.
Originally posted by Seapeople
You do not understand infinity. You lie to yourself if you think you do. Thats interesting.
The claim that everything on earth is alive is a far stretch. So what level of awareness does a rock have?
Don't try to fool people on this board who do not know any better. You are no more intelligent than the next person. You claim that your opinions are fact. When in reality, it is just your own view which may be wrong.
Challenge. Imagine something infinite in your head. The describe it to all of us on the board.
Challenge. Provide scientific evidence that everything is alive that has matter or mass.
No problem with someone as smart as you I am sure!
Originally posted by Enlightened
Faceless, that is too funny. Yeah, I bet you are reeeeeeeeeeeeeeaaaaal smart... Ha Ha....
Koka, Miracles happen everyday.. If you are not smart enough to see that then open up your shut eyes.....
[Edited on 26-4-2004 by Enlightened]
Originally posted by Enlightened
All people believe in GOD.... They just have had some emotional trauma which has caused them to question what they can not deny in their soul actually exsists. It is certainly too obvious. Paul states it in Romans Ch.1. All people are without excuse to admit that God exsists. I seriously doubt that any of us on this board are more intellectual than Paul was and he wrote most of the new test. If God is good enough for him to believe in then count me in too.....
Originally posted by Enlightened
Faceless, that is too funny. Yeah, I bet you are reeeeeeeeeeeeeeaaaaal smart... Ha Ha....
[Edited on 26-4-2004 by Enlightened]
Originally posted by Jakko
Idiots see miracles in everything they don't understand?
Lol.
Seriously now, here's what I think so far:
1. You don't know what time or infinity means. ("you are confusing experience with knowledge blabla" will not help you here, the way you are molding these concepts to suit your little "enlightened" theory requires you to come with something better than that.)
2. You don't know who God is. You said you used to believe in God, but clearly not in the right one because your idea of God seems to be some sort of illusion, for us to explain things we don't understand.
The existance of God actually raises a lot of questions, maybe even more then what it answers.
3. Your way of discussing is annoying to read.
THis may have to do with your quick assumptions. You're acting as if you're going too fast for others, when
in fact you're going too fast for yourself.
At some point it stops making sense, and if your "time" topic is somewhat like the stuff that you posted in here I am not even going to bother reading it, cause it's all the same; hysteric assumptions that lead to foolish theories, making a fool out of yourself by acting as if you understand infinity and time as concepts.
"I can't help it if you don't understand" lol!
That's what the town idiot says when everyone tells him he makes no sense.
To me it is clear that some concepts can not be understood by us, my IQ is very high, I am not on drugs, and I am surely not the onlyone who thinks this.
Be proud! You're the first man in history who not only fully realizes the concepts time and infinity, but who can mold those concepts into the shortest theories that explain everything!
Yea right.
So when are the aliens going to come and eat us then?
[Edited on 26-4-2004 by Jakko]