Why 9/11, page 1
Pages:
ATS Members have flagged this thread 1 times


reply posted on 15-2-2007 @ 05:15 PM by Quicksilver
Originally posted by MonteloDiablo
there are any number of reasons
1. the USA securing their control over one of the last sources of oil before it all runs out and they're FORCED to use renewable energy sources
2. the CIA clearing up the debris left over from their secret wars in the middle east during the cold war
3. the CIA keeping a tight grip on their drug interests in the middle east
4. creating a reason to go after some of americas most potent enemies before they can get their hands on the bomb
5. almost criminalizing a large part of the population (muslims) to help usher in the police state
6. exposing the flaws and uselessness of the UN and thereby asserting the USAs dominance as THE world superpower


Again i challenge youto prove this couldnt have been taken care of without killing 3000 people.

1. I believe it would be more profitable to create a renewable energy source then suck up the dirty oil. Why do we need to secure the middle east. We have decent gas pricesand they are pretty good to us. If it gets too bad we have the reserves and also Alaska to uncork. I can only see this if we were in desperate need of teh oil and the AMerican people would not budge.

2 & 3. I have more faith in the CIA to clean up this mess without causeing huge collaterral damage. I mean just a bombing of the WTC inkey placescould have destroyed all the evidence. Also we didnt need a false flag to go in Iraq we went in under the pretenses of WMDs.

4. The creating of a nuclear weapon would be enough to warrent an invasion.

5. I dont totally disagree with you there.

6. I agree with you here also but i dont think that 9/11 was needed if this was the only reason.

I dont mean to be critical I am just tryin to grasp this and maybe find out some reason why. I think we need to look at the big picture not the short term.

Maybe what key figures died in WTC that are irreplaceable, who got more power, who lost power, what laws came into effect, who is benefiting the most from 9/11????



reply posted on 15-2-2007 @ 05:47 PM by Essedarius
Good thread.

While I think that there is obvious evidence that there was more to 9/11 than meets the eye, the reasoning behind the conspiracy doesn't add up for me at all.

I'll use MonteloDiablo's points because I think they are pretty comprehensive in detailing the reasons most people give for the execution of 9/11.

Originally posted by MonteloDiablo
there are any number of reasons
1. the USA securing their control over one of the last sources of oil before it all runs out and they're FORCED to use renewable energy sources


The middle east hardly represents one of the last sources of oil. Its value geographically as a military installation is more valuable than its value as an oil resource. I may be wrong, but I think I remember hearing that there are several countries in South America that boast larger oil resources than Iraq.

2. the CIA clearing up the debris left over from their secret wars in the middle east during the cold war


If you are having a SECRET war and you want to clean it up, you simply turn your back on it and pretend it never existed. You certainly don't stage an elaborate attack on your own country to "cover up" something that 99.9% of the world doesn't know about anyway.

3. the CIA keeping a tight grip on their drug interests in the middle east


If you are saying that the CIA wouldn't have had the funding or might to continue efforts like this, I would have to disagree. Drugs are one of the few interests in this world that has ABSOLUTELY no problem funding itself. Too much money is made here to claim that this arena needed help financially...especially not a dire enough need to stage such an extravagant "fund raiser" as 9/11.

4. creating a reason to go after some of americas most potent enemies before they can get their hands on the bomb


As was stated above...the bomb is its own reason. Besides, when has George W. Bush ever needed a REASON to do ANYTHING! Here is a guy that has been operating against the will of the American people, without apology, for several years now. Where is another terrorist attack? Bottom line: he doesn't need one. He never really did.

5. almost criminalizing a large part of the population (muslims) to help usher in the police state


For a police state to take hold in the U.S. it would have to be put in place quickly enough to rule out the opportunity for the next election. That is a massive and completely unlikely operation that has already (in my opinion) missed its window of opportunity. (Again, in MY OPINION, the whole police state, NWO angle on 9/11 is totally unrealistic and damaging to the 9/11 truth movement. IF that was the reasoning behind 9/11 then it would have been instituted (probably SUCCESSFULLY) in October of 2001.)

6. exposing the flaws and uselessness of the UN and thereby asserting the USAs dominance as THE world superpower


I just can't believe that showing up a clearly toothless organization was, in fact, the purpose behind what would be an absolutely decadent display of treachery.

The fact is that there is no reward that could have been attained by the President or Silverstein or any of them that would outweigh the MASSIVE MASSIVE RISK of staging such an outlandishly overt PWNing of the American people.

You're talking about risking EVERYTHING for gains that could be made in other ways.
Pages:     ^^TOP^^



9-11 lecture at Basel University, Switzerland.
  Posted 15 days ago with 14 member flags
9/11 Actors re-visited
  Posted 8 days ago with 13 member flags
Building Collapses in Rio
  Posted 15 days ago with 6 member flags
new film "Human the film (2012)" covers all the bases and more!
  Posted 10 days ago with 6 member flags
Remains of 9/11 victim identified
  Posted 1 days ago with 5 member flags
you must try this youre self ????
  Posted 15 days ago with 4 member flags