It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
From the link:
Exclusive: Iraqi army brutality
Published: 24 Jan 2007
By: Jonathan Miller
Channel 4 News has exclusive access to the brutality meted out by the largely Shi'a Iraqi army in Baghdad.
Watch the report
It is a shocking insight into the sectarian violence that is tearing Baghdad apart.
As tens of thousands of American troops prepare to "surge" into the iraqi capital - Channel 4 News has obtained exclusive evidence of the brutality being meted out by the largely Shi'a Iraqi army - as US troops stand idly by.
Two journalists - embedded with the First Cavalry division - witnessed suspected insurgents being viciously beaten and abused.
The journalists were then threatened and held under armed guard by the Americans - as troops attempted to seize their footage.
US Army commander Lieutenant Colonel Dale C Kuehl told Channel 4 News he had taken administrative action to include suspending the platoon sergeant.
He said: "The US Army does not condone detainee abuse within our formation not within ISF formations.
"The appropriate actions will be taken once the results of the investigation are final."
www.channel4.com...
Link
BUT they say we are there NOW To bring them safety, secuirty and democracy. Forgive me, but soliders activley beating up citizens is safe, secure democracy.
Originally posted by ShooterSix
It’s unfortunate you only see one side of the conflict, Western reporters embedded with some American units always trying to show the “brutality” of the coalition forces.
Seriously, three Iraqi men were carrying mortars, obviously to fire and KILL American, British, CIVILAN, or Iraqi security forces, or if they were lucky, a combo.
Iraqi security forces beat them up, I saw the video, I didn’t see anything extreme in my eyes, that report is exaggerated.
The article makes it seem like these insurgents are clinging for life as being brutally beaten, please.
I’m just so damn sick of this political correctness stance on everything American.
Want to know what I think is brutality? When these so called “freedom fighters” are sawing off heads of Innocent Iraqi men, women, and children.
Want to know what else I think is brutality? When these “freedom fighters” are cutting off genitals and desecrating bodies of innocent men, women, and children.
Please, being thrown in the back of a humvee head first for carrying weapons to kill Americans, British, and Iraqi soldiers is moot.
If you don’t want to be treated this way? You know what to do.
Originally posted by ShooterSix
BUT they say we are there NOW To bring them safety, secuirty and democracy. Forgive me, but soliders activley beating up citizens is safe, secure democracy.
They weren't citizens, they were transporting mortars.
Originally posted by Agit8dChop
They are Iraqi's defending there land against a foreign occupier.
Its as simple as that.
Originally posted by Agit8dChop
Question Xphiles
: If your country was invaded and occupied by russia, because MEXICO attacked Russia, would you resist?
Originally posted by Agit8dChop
No matter how you look at it, the US is in the wrong, and the IRAQI resistance are doing what any human would.
Originally posted by Nygdan
If we're all hyped up about leaving iraq, then why the heck should soldiers be 'intervening' with the operation of the iraqi army???
Isn't 'intervention' the very issue that is being rejected here? What does it matter if some soldiers stop a couple of guys from being beaten? Once the US leaves, thousands more will be executed.
Originally posted by Agit8dChop
Didnt we invade and occupy to rid them of violent regimes?
No wait it was WMD's..... or was it alqaeda..
so many lies who can keep up.
Your disregard for human rights because others you are against may choose to do so makes you no better, and your sense of moral high ground is lost.
Originally posted by ShooterSix
Those insurgents had it lucky, if I recall, aren’t hostile forces wearing no uniform or insignia denied the rights supplied by the Geneva convention? They should have been executed, instead they were punched… yet the United States still gets slammed. Amazing.