It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Shadowhawk
Eventually, even Stanton Friedman condemned many of the supposed MJ-12 documents as fraudulent. He found that some documents were "emulations of real documents" that were available to the public and that some things had been retyped, combined with other material, and then photocopied. He also noted numerous factual errors.
This sort of hoax does a great disservice to UFOlogy.
The Majestic 12 documents problem is complex and extensive. On balance it appears that the EBD, TFM and CTM are almost certainly genuine, the SOM 1.01 memo is very likely genuine (see Dr. Robert Woods paper (Ref. 18)) and the Tim Cooper Documents are emulations and fictional.
The Majestic 12 documents problem is complex and extensive. On balance it appears that the EBD, TFM and CTM are almost certainly genuine, the SOM 1.01 memo is very likely genuine (see Dr. Robert Woods paper (Ref. 18)) and the Tim Cooper Documents are emulations and fictional. It is perhaps not surprising that a documentary movie "Do you Believe in Majic?" is being prepared by Paul Kimball of Redstar films who had dug into a great deal of UFO material in preparation for the documentary "Stanton T. Friedman IS Real!" (Ref. 19) first broadcast on the Canadian Space TV channel in June 2002. Critics have been interviewed. One strange criticsm was made by Karl Pflock when he claimed twice that because Menzel was famous for doodling small cartoon Martians that the statement in the EBD that Menzel was saying the aliens were from Mars was an inside joke. I am afraid the joke is on Karl. The EBD (p. 4) says exactly the opposite:
... considerable speculation has centered around what their point of origin might be and how they get here. Mars was and remains a possibility, although some scientists, most notably Dr. Menzel, consider it more likely that we are dealing with beings from another solar system entirely.
Originally posted by alienreality
Certain top secret documents are written in a way not conforming to any military or D.o.D. standards, this is done to make it easy to refute them as a hoax.. The fact that so many officials have publically refuted them are an indicator..
They may be disinformation, but no person could have possibly authored those documents without having a vast knowledge of inside people working in secret capacity with government, in my opinion... It wasn't just some schmo, that's for certain...