posted on Oct, 25 2005 @ 02:11 AM
It's a start, but you should open a companion thread titled something like, "Why the worst umps are in the post season." This is my 47th post season
as a rabid fan (yup, I began with the Chisox in the 1959 Series, which is a longshot). Denkinger still holds the record for the most catastrophic
Series call, although if Herzog had been awake and had put Pete LaCock (or ANYONE) at 1B in place of Dick Stuart's iron-glove rival, Jack Clark,
Balboni's foul pop would've been caught and Denkinger might've been saved....
Anyway, this is by far the worst post-season umpiring I've ever seen, and it's ruined my favorite sporting event of the year for me. I don't really
care now if Oswalt throws a shutout in Game 3 and the umps make 10 atrocious calls in Houston's favor to even it in Game 4.
The whole thing's been a farce. And Joe West, the worst umpire I personally have ever seen (including Eric Gregg), would be the home plate ump for
Game 7, if there is one. How apt.
Baseball History Nut