Baseball: new choices

mccovey or stargell, sisler or brett, kaat or orosco

lol. Well I'd definatly take Kaat, and you know me, I'd have to go with Stargell over McCovey, allthough McCovey was probably better. Actually except in home runs Stargell is better, and he has a 12 point batting average advantage. Lastly I'd take Sisler over George Brett, even though I don't know why you would make a comparison between a third basemen and a first basemen?

i was going to put (no biased votes) and i was also comparing them as hitters as most intelligent people would be able to decipher

Well first of all, you put two first basemen, and then two pitchers, so why would a person think that they shouldn't be the same position. After all, why would you randomly compare Brett with Sisler? Simply because both of their first names happen to be George? I find it outragous!