It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Daedalus3
I think you're nuts if you think that Iran has a better manufacturing base than India. The pure availability of infrastructure, knowledge resource and funding is exponentially more in India.
Originally posted by Daedalus3
Iran though does have a reputation of siphening tech from other countries and implementing the same. Its nuclear power capability purely rests on data leaked from Pakistan's nuclear projects and data supplied by Russia.
Originally posted by Daedalus3
The missiles that Iran manufactures are pure re-labelling of russian and chinese counterparts.
Originally posted by Daedalus3
India has a purely indgneous capability of inserting payloads into geosynch orbit (30000km) amongst other highlights.
Originally posted by Daedalus3
Anyways this is a very interesting(though preposterous) comparision you have made between India and Iran.
I look forward to looking into it more later because I will do a indepth study of your claims and respond in due time.
Originally posted by Daedalus3May turn out to be unpleasant but hey.. the truth's what we're looking for.
Originally posted by iqonx
There are some aircraft out there that are as good or better then the F-18 in Russia and the Russians will have no problem selling Iran components or parts which could be used inside this aircraft allowing it to be on the level of an F-18.
Originally posted by iqonx
But this aircraft certainly does have enough capacity inside to house some powerful equipment.
Originally posted by iqonx
India does have more funding but it hasen't helped India much. India still doesn't have much to show for all it's spending.
India still had to get help from Russia for It's "brahmos" missiles. And we all know that is basically 100% designed by Russia and the only thing India contributed to it was money.
And India designed it's nuclear technology by itself
Oh please India gets all it's tech from Russia as well.
Why do Indians always act as if they don't.
They know perfectly well where there tech comes from so you're really in no position to say anything about Iranian equipment when you're own stuff comes from the same source.
India has had a two decade head start in nuclear technology over Iran in having control over a complete nuclear cycle. So it's obvious that India should have some self-reliance in the field. But you guys still don't have much to show for it becuase you guys are now trying to get tech of America.
When Iran has a few reactors and has years of experiance like other countries then maybe they can also start designing and building there own powerplants but they aren't going to start from scratch when they can just but them in the begining.
Originally posted by Daedalus3
The missiles that Iran manufactures are pure re-labelling of russian and chinese counterparts.
And Indians missiles are what exactly?
The Brahmos is what exactly?
India does exactly the same.
Even you're guns are copies of Russian guns, You guys use Russian aircrafts, and you guys use russian missiles and also manufacture there parts so why complain when other people do the same things.
And also if you take a look at some of the Iranian stuff they have actually made an effort to modify designs while India doesn't even bother becuase it doesn't have the knowlage or experiance to do so.
Originally posted by Daedalus3
India has a purely indigneous capability of inserting payloads into geosynch orbit (30000km) amongst other highlights.
Yes and im sure Russia has nothing to do with it
If you want to do that then start another thread about it and don;t do it in this one.
Originally posted by Daedalus3
hey.. the truth's what we're looking for.
Not unpleasant for me. I'm not Iranian so it doesn't make a difference to me.
I'm just stating facts. More aircraft/fighters/helicopters and there parts come out of Iranian factories then do out of Indian factories.
Thats a fact.
I know nationalism is high in India but you shouldn't let it blind you.
You're country has been working on a making an aircraft for over a few decades and still hasen't produced anything worthwhile with all your "availability of infrastructure, knowledge resource and funding" which as you say is "exponentially more in India.".
Yet Iran still knocked out a workable aircraft and you're country hasen't.
Those facts speak for themselves on capability of these 2 countries. When India starts making anything worthwhile that can fly by itself then start talking about it and until then Iran still is much more advanced in this field then India.
Sorry the truth hurts.
[edit on 8-9-2006 by iqonx]
Originally posted by kojac
While reading a report on the Iranian Nuke issue i stumbled across this...
In a separate development, Iran has announced that it has developed a new aircraft named Saegheh (Thunder), which it described as close to the American F-18 fighter jet. General Attollah Salehi, the commander of the Iranian army, was quoted by the state news agency IRNA as saying the fighter jet is similar to the F-18, but more capable. It was manufactured domestically.
source
I'm no military expert, but if this is true this has to be a massive step forward for the Iranian military..
Thoughts? I'm going to see if i can find any more info about this mystery plane..
[edit on 12/06/2005 by kojac]
Originally posted by ch1466
ARGUMENT:
The Iranians have basically shown that they can make a cosmetically different F-5E to offset attrition in their only ubiquitous fighter airframe at 'own not leased or least' cost.
You want 'impressive'? You start looking at the Iranian UAV line. Half the good-after-bad cash burn on replicative R&D. Twice the 'cheap enough to lose' viability of baseline design sufficient to justify further evolutionary branching.