I have to say as a Australian it is sad that someone from here has lost thier lives in this mess. My heart goes out to his family.

He's a soldier fighting in a war of aggression, I feel sorry for his family but this is not tragic. Would people care if an Aussie dual-national fought and died for Hezbollah?

Honestly i would feel the same if their was a dual-citizen who had fought and died for hezzbollah, but i do agree with your point. Most australians because of the media twist on situations would not feel the same.

If your compassion is unconditional Wang then thats great

My lack of sympathy for this Israeli soldier would be exactly the same for any Aussie dual national Hezbollah soldier who might die. Soldiers and those who willfully take part in fighting a war and die are not tragedies. Tragedies are those who die and have nothing to with fighting wars i.e. civilians.

If this Aussie was there on holiday it would be very, very sad. But he was there fighting for Israel's armed forces.

[edit on 27/7/06 by subz]

I do totaly agree that he was in the IDF and it he was their fighting a war. I do feel much more sympathy for the innocents who just want to live happy lives, but any lose of life on either side is sad.

Originally posted by subz
He's a soldier fighting in a war of aggression, I feel sorry for his family but this is not tragic. Would people care if an Aussie dual-national fought and died for Hezbollah?

Alot of my freinds are dual-nationals from Lebanon and Syria, So the answer is YES all death is tragic. Daily i get SMS messages from the front lines by mates in Lebanon, now with horrific tales of unknown weapons being used on innocent families .

A life cut short is always sad my heart goes out to his family

helium3:

>Its REALLY sad to see Ozzie's dragged into this BS.

We aren't being dragged into it.

He joined the IDF on a voluntary basis quite some time back.

He only had one month to go before he finished his stint apparently.

Cheers

JS