It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by northwolfBut You'll have to admit Russia is Rich, with those natural resources a country can't be poor
posted by chinawhite
posted by northwolf
But You'll have to admit Russia is Rich, with all those natural resources a country can't be poor . .
Yes the RF can be termed as rich but the wealth is with the few while the majority have nothing. The information (1) below illustrates it best. What Russia needs is (2) foreign capital and government investment to re-build a country with shabby infrastructure. What China is doing is going into the (3) right direction which is why I am highlighting the big difference. Household income or consumption by percentage share:
Lowest 10%: 1.7%
Highest 10%: 38.7%
[Edited by Don W]
Dont even compare china and russia. On paper russia seems to be a urbanized country but most of the buildings are either run down or sub-standard. The only thing russia has is her hundreds of rotting missiles. All just a fascade nothing to show for anything the soviets done
posted by chinawhite
I'll reply tomorrow but I suggest you look into China’s "go west" policy launched in 2000 under the 10th five year program. This has been a priority since the 1990s. China had only begun its real growth in the 90s when Deng Xiaoping made his famous trip down south and throughout China. Anyway, the workers in do come from the interior and send money back home. Still early times for China. No where in the world has seen this type of growth [Edited by Don W]
Originally posted by chinawhite
Seems like you come from a country which also does the same thing as china
The exchange illustrated more about the state of freedom in Russia than met the eye. While Putin travels around with a contingent of reporters just as Bush does, the Kremlin press pool is a handpicked group of reporters, most of whom work for the state and the rest selected for their fidelity to the Kremlin's rules of the game. Helpful questions are often planted. Unwelcome questions are not allowed. Ananyone who gets out of line can get out of the pool.
The Kremlin press pool is like so many institutions in Russia that have the trappings of a Western-style pluralistic society but operate under a different set of understandings, part of what analyst Lilia Shevtsova of the Carnegie Moscow Center calls "the illusion of democracy." Television channels air newscasts with fancy graphics but follow scripts approved by the Kremlin. Elections are held, but candidates out of favor with the Kremlin are often knocked off the ballot. Courts conduct trials, but the state almost never loses. Parliament meets but only to rubber-stamp Kremlin legislation.
WashingtonPost
The chinese that go to russia work for chinese compaines and are normally there on contracts. The other large group are merchants which move from border to border
Let me quote some more figures
China -
population below poverty line - 10%
Russia -
population below poverty line - 17.8%
which means a lot of people in russia cannot afford electricity. Let your own people experiment with it first
4 People's Republic of China 1 2,224,811
5 United Kingdom 2,201,473
6 France 2,105,864
7 Italy 1,766,160
8 Canada 1,130,208
9 Spain 1,126,565
10 South Korea 793,070
11 Brazil 792,683
12 India 775,410
13 Mexico 768,437
14 Russia 766,180
Look which countries out perform russia in economic performace. No brainer there is no comparison between china and russia
Originally posted by donwhite
The great dilemma facing Beijing is how to spend more on the interior whilst the governing party members have been lured away from the old revolutionary zeal by the smell of US greenbacks! Apartments in Shanghai sell for as much as US$7 million. There are more construction cranes in Shanghai than in any other city on the planet. Yet China’s interior continues to see annual flooding, food shortages due to poor roads and rails. Backward schools, understaffed hospitals and so on.
posted by rogue1
posted by donwhite
The dilemma facing Beijing is how to spend more on the interior whilst the party members have been lured away from revolutionary zeal by the smell of US greenbacks! Apartments in Shanghai sell for up to US$7 million. Yet China’s interior continues to suffer . . [Edited by Don W]
This is different from what country ? Come on, you should apply the same rule to the rest of the world and you'll find no difference. The Chinese government has actually sought to increase investment in its central areas such as the West High Tech Zone in Schuan Province, where Motorola has just established a world class research center - the first of many companies. [Edited by Don W]
Terms And Conditions Of Use
1b.) Profanity: You will not use profanity in our forums, and will neither post with language or content that is obscene, sexually oriented, or sexually suggestive nor link to sites that contain such content.
Originally posted by prelude
Originally posted by HowlrunnerIV
Now that's what I call ignorance.
Aslan Maskhadov wanted a zone of Muslim Radicals? Get a grip and start reading.
This is the guy who was an artillery officer in the Red Army. Who served in the Lithuanian "campaign" in '91.
This is the guy who personally condemned the attack on Beslan and publicly called for Basayev to be tried for it.
He was also the guy who was elected President of Chechnya in the last election universally regarded as free and fair.
Do you know the person for whom your are campaining for right now Mr Basayev used to sell Chechens as slaves to the foreingn community ....at the time when Chechnia won independance(apprtox 1992 ) Chechens started selling the poor as "slaves " in the markets of Grozny.....those scenes were shown in your most favourite BBC ...So this was a president who was "Universally" free and fair?
Originally posted by donwhite
Be honest with me. How many local people will the new research center employ? “Research” implies high education levels of staff. It needs to be located in an attractive geographical area to attract outsiders. I agree, you have to start somewhere. But a few hundred jobs do not a revolution make. The interior needs levees, paved roads, rail lines, electricity generating plants, a power grid to distribute the electricity. Clean water to drink. Sewage treatment plants.
Originally posted by preludea typical western propaganda...it has nothing to do with reality ...Russia has more than 35000 private media sources its impossible for any Govt from any country to control them all
The number of newspapers in China has increased from 42--virtually all Communist Party papers--in 1968 to 382 in 1980 and more than 2,200 today. By one official estimate, there are now more than 7,000 magazines and journals in the country
Similarly, in 1965 there were 12 television and 93 radio stations in China; today there are approximately 700 conventional television stations--plus about 3,000 cable channels--and 1,000 radio stations
my comment was about internet freedom.......where you dont have anything to say against Russia
Last month, the management of a poetry website based in Russia (www.stihi.ru...) instructed authors to observe certain political censorship requirements, REN-TV reported on 26 January. Authors were forbidden to write about the war in Chechnya or the ongoing protests over the reform of social benefits. They were admonished not to criticize President Vladimir Putin, the government, members of the pro-Kremlin Unified Russia party, or the pro-Putin youth movement Moving Together. Poet Vladislav Sergeev predicted that no one would publish on the site anymore because of the restrictions.
I have been to USA ,all major parts of Europe , India , Bangladesh ,Nepal and i am presently typing from berlin as an exchange student
In Russia, on the other hand, Putin's Kremlin used a state-controlled company to take over the only independent television network, NTV. When the ousted NTV journalists took over a different channel, TV-6, the state shut it down. When they tried again with a network called TVS, Putin's press minister yanked it off the air and replaced it with a sports channel.
The general manager installed at NTV after the Kremlin takeover was later fired when his coverage of the Moscow theater siege in 2002 angered Putin. Then NTV's most independent remaining hosts, Leonid Parfyonov and Savik Shuster, were taken off the air after the government bristled at their talk shows. Shuster's show was called "Freedom of Speech."
You know well well the truth still you pretend to be ignorant most Chinese MIGRATE to Russia ILLEGALLY
BLAGOVESHCHENSK, KHABAROVSK and VLADIVOSTOK - The Chinese are coming! They are invading the Far East! If headlines in the new and free - but often sensational and irresponsible - Russian press are to be believed, a massive influx of Chinese into Siberia and the Russian Far East is turning the area "yellow" and Russia is about to lose its easternmost provinces.
But in cities such as Vladivostok, Khabarovsk and Blagoveshchensk the Chinese are not very much in evidence. They are there, but seldom seen outside their hotels and restaurants - and the region's ubiquitous casinos and Chinese markets. It is true, however, that Chinese merchants now dominate the region's trade and commerce.
There may not be more than 40,000, or perhaps 50,000, Chinese living in the Russian Far East. But that is 40,000 or 50,000 more than in 1991. And as the Russian exodus continues, the Chinese may, as one researcher put it, "move into an empty Siberia resulting in its detachment and reorientation towards Beijing".
while Russians go to China under VISA as Tourists professionals Businessmen hence their numbers are highre
Outside the market's entrance sits a different group of men who are playing cards and grousing. They are Russians working as gypsy cab drivers -- men who once had it better. There is a former engineer, a former teacher and several former military men.
Look at that Chinese with the fancy foreign car, grumbles one, who gives his name only as Sergei. "They'll take over and invade our country without weapons. Eventually, they will kill us."
Note those all important bolded passages! A left-winger blindly extrapolating the US-Mexico situation would predict that the Chinese, coming from a poorer country and streaming across the border, would be exploited by the Russians and condemned to poverty. But that's not what happened.
It doesn't matter that these Chinese were illegals, that they didn't speak the language (at first), or that they were initially exploited. Within one generation they rose to the top of the economic ladder
poverty line in a country is determined by Govts of a praticular country who have their own defns of poverty.
90 million Chinese under poverty line: minister
Despite the country's booming economic development in the past two decades, 90 million Chinese residents still live under the internationally recognized poverty line, Minister of Commerce Bo Xilai said Friday.
there cant be a universal comparison basesd on this percentage...if u do such a comparison then you will see that a Third world country like China has less poverty than USA and most countries in Western Europe
Electricity is FREE in Russia
here is another list
Rank Country GDP
per capita
Originally posted by donwhite
(2) Foreign investment is an euphemism for control by the rich.
The Coastal part where all the new economics is happening. Numbering about 300 million people.
ABOUT ATS: General ATS discussion etiquette3) Try and spell-check and get your gramma/syntax correct. Very often, your credibility will be judged by how well you present your thoughts as a well-written post.
Terms And Conditions Of Use
1b.) Profanity: You will not use profanity in our forums, and will neither post with language or content that is obscene, sexually oriented, or sexually suggestive nor link to sites that contain such content.
posted by chinawhite
posted by donwhite
(2) Foreign investment is an euphemism for control by the rich.
Foreign investment is good for both parties. Both of the sides offer services the others needs. The company brings investment and capital while the workers provide them with labor . . The government then improves the infrastucture to attract more factories and capital . . It does not really matter who makes the bigger profit because the profit will most likey be re-invested in the country, all the matters is people are being employed and their standard of living is increasing . . “
[Edited by Don W]
The bottom line is the FDI gives money for accelerated growth and provides money which the government does not have . .
I mentioned this has started and the Chinese government has poured 1 trillion RMB into the countryside and is going to invest 10 billion over 20 years or 20 billion or 10 years into the interior mega city called Chongqing which is being called the Shanghai of the west or like how I like to call it "the interior hope." But this is just early days for China