Someone give me facts !, page


Pages:
ATS Members have flagged this thread 0 times


reply posted on 1-5-2006 @ 03:13 PM by Enkidu
Originally posted by automek
What makes fact FACT then?

Ah, there's the rub.

Everything we sense and think we understand is a distortion. It's distorted by our own limited senses. Even "existence" is only felt by us seconds after it really happens, because it takes time for our senses and our brains to process the information we receive. On a sub-atomic level, the things we think are solid and real are made more of nothing than actual "stuff," and because of the Uncertainty Principle, we can only guess about where that stuff even is.

If you've ever been unconscious, or on drugs, or really sick, you know that our senses can be easily fooled and messed up. So if we can't trust our own senses, then we really can't trust anything anybody tells us they saw or experienced, can we? What makes their perceptions better than our own? Nothing.

As for our "beliefs," we usually learn them from others we trust when we are children. But all they are are subjective opinions transmitted to us by people who don't know any better, themselves, sometimes passed off as "fact," but with little or nothing to support them. And just because they're written down in a Bible or something doesn't make them any more factual.

Fact is a social agreement. A construct of reality we agree on by consensus. We generally label FACTS as things that: 1) other people see/understand and describe that roughly match what we see/understand, and 2) things that repeat in roughly the same way so we can sort of predict what might happen when we encounter them at different times. That's about it. If something doesn't meet those two simple requirements, we can't really call them "facts."

Majority doesn't always necessarily rule on this stuff. Most people think atoms look like little solar systems with a sun and planets in orbit. They're wrong. Most people believe in some kind of afterlife or survival of the spirit after death, or they believe in angels and demons and ghosts. They're wrong.

We can try to prove facts by using evidence and logic, but that can also be so paradoxical and horribly flawed that it's essentially useless.

The FACT is that we -- as in YOU and ME and EVERYBODY ELSE -- don't know jack squat about anything, whether it's comets or Jesus or who shot JFK or whether or not fluoride is killing us all, or ANYTHING! It's all just a lot of poor observations and misunderstandings, patched together and based on incomplete information and lousy reasoning.

Does that make you feel better?


[edit on 1-5-2006 by Enkidu]



reply posted on 10-5-2006 @ 08:24 AM by Astyanax
I agree with everything Enkidu says about the unreliability of perception and the even greater unreliability of secondhand report. These days, even Descartes' cogito, ergo sum doesn't cut any ice, now that consciousness and free will are commonly treated as illusive side-effects of autonomous organic function. So, yes indeed, there is no such thing as an unambiguously verifiable fact.

In spite of this, we continue to behave as if certain 'facts' are true. From these facts, we've built a roughly consensual picture of reality and lo, it works. Within this construct, matter, energy and spacetime behave in predictable, reproducible ways. For example, (distilled) water can be relied upon to boil at 212 degrees Fahrenheit (at sea level on planet Earth). People, oddly enough, seem to behave in predictable ways too, though they are such complex systems that prediction can be quite difficult at times, though not impossible.

It would seem that there are some facts we can rely on, after all. You may not be able to put your finger on that pesky electron without deflecting it, yet things play out as we expect them to nevertheless; predictable effects follow from specific causes. True, our perceptions are flawed or skewed and others' accounts of reality are worse, yet we make constant and productive use of both. Something -- however erroneous, however illusory -- is evidently working.

So automek (isn't that from one of Dan Simmons' books?), we can't give you any facts, but perhaps someone can offer you an insight into the truth.

Which is that things are pretty much as they seem to be, give or take a bit of wiggle room. However much of a dupe you think it makes you, it's best to begin with that premise and stick with it until you've got near-overwhelming evidence to the contrary. Thoughts of conspiracy should be forced on you by circumstances, not actively cultivated. Otherwise you may as well get y'self measured for the tin hat right away.


reply posted on 11-5-2006 @ 07:01 AM by wellwhatnow
I am on this site because I can't sleep, but I doubt that is what you meant.
As for the tin hat, I wear a size 9 3/4 (that's 3 feet of reynolds wrap for those of you who might not know) but I refuse to wear it any more. I am hoping that the beings from other planets really do access my brain, but that is for another thread.

As for fact, Ego cogito ergo sum. I think, so I know that I exist. It is a fact that my mind is here. We know that we are at least the res cogitans, the thinking things. That is, I presume, the reason why we are here at this site. To add to the thoughts we have, some new and possibly enlightening other thoughts. Whether or not they too prove to be facts we can only tell for ourselves by thinking them through - all the while asking, "Could this be anything other than what it appears?" If there exists any possibility that an object or idea could be other than what it seems, it cannot be relied upon as absolute fact. Fact must be able to endure questioning thought. You must think.

I don't believe that anyone can do this for you. Certainly no one can do it for me. I can be guided, but unless I think I will be misled. Either every silliness will appear as fact, or no information will appear factual.

My opinion is, therefore, that fact is something that I can hold in my mind that stands up in the face of doubt, withstands all questions, and no matter how I think of it, I cannot think of it as being other than what it is.

In short, almost everything on this site (and all others for that matter) is not fact.
Nevermind, maybe I should go back to wearing my tin hat.
Pages:     ^^TOP^^



Are You Offended??? SO WHAT!!!
  Posted 9 days ago with 97 member flags
The Image of Baphomet: Upsetting Folks Since 1855.
  Posted 9 days ago with 39 member flags
New Scientific Report Destroys Global Warming!
  Posted 7 days ago with 32 member flags
Al Azif: Is The Necronomicon Real?
  Posted 8 days ago with 25 member flags
What The Hell Is This?
  Posted 5 days ago with 9 member flags
How copyright enforcement robots killed the Hugo Awards
  Posted 7 days ago with 4 member flags