Even with the pirates in the news rather frequently these days, the worlds attention seems to be lacking. Pirates are a very serous issue that must be
dealt with.
Today
the US Navy engaged the criminals with small arms fire. Is this enough to deter them?
Personally, I would like to have a carrier battle group in the area, I am sure the problem would fix itself, but the resources are usually needed
elseware. What kind of military assets would be required to confront this issue?
mod edit to fix link
[edit on 19-3-2006 by DontTreadOnMe]
|
A simple mounting of linked Browning M2 HMGs on a swiveling turret would certainly turn any pirate vessel into swiss cheese in minuets. Compared to
what you stand to lose from a pirate attack (Lives, valuables, alot of decreased sea travel in the area), this is fairly inexpensive. However, oucould
also simply supply the guards with better arms then the pirates have. Something in the AK-47 or FNp90 range would be good.
|
One of the main problems is that as we've become ever more 'civilised', we've grown increasingly far away from merchants carrying weapons to defen
themselves. This is not a problem, and even a good thing, provided local navies are powerfull enough to prevent any real piracy problems. The
downside is, what do you do when there is no local navy? (or said local navy IS the pirates) Then you wind up in a position where commerce in the
region is relying on a foriegn power to police the area.
As for what is needed to defeat pirates in an area, a well disciplined navy with plenty of surface combatants and VBSS (Visit, Board, Search and
Seizure) capability. Mines cannot tell a pirate ship from anyone else, and a Carrier battle Group just can't get a close enough look to tell if
anyone's a Pirate or not. The only way is to stop a suspicious vessel at sea, send a team over to check them out, and make the determination there.
Or catch them in the act, but even that's not terribly easy.
|
Um... make 'em walk the plank?
I don't know what sort of regulations there are regarding ships in open water and weapons allowed on board... but I think if they are allowed to arm
themselves, crews should. Just like law abiding citizens should arm themselves for protection against criminals since the police will not always be
there when you need them.
And if that doesn't work, kick 'em in the booty, then make them walk the plank!
Hardy har harrrrrrrr!
|
Pirates in the ocean....do they do more damage that the internet pirates....in terms of money....hmmm.
But to stop seaborne piracy....let's go back to giving the sailors swords...or guns....either or. Fight fire with fire.
|
merchants arming themselves to repel pirates
I looked into this issue one time, and I gotta say it's complicated.
For one thing in open water (aka no country claims that area) How an armed ship is dealt with is entirelly dependent on whose navy pulls you over and
asks for license and registration.
For another in territorial waters you generally have to have a permit from the country who's waters you are in to have armed personnel.
|
