It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by rdube02
Grasshopper,
I do understand where you're coming from. It's hard to know who or what to believe, especially with all of the hoaxters. However, if we get into our minds that EVERYTHING could be a lie and, and any person could either be a government spy, or wannabe spy.... then there is no way for us to find the truth because everything could be a lie. It's almost a paranoid scitzophrenic mind set where everyone is out to get you and everyone is spying on you...
grasshopper replies: you haven't walked in my shoes. It has taken me a long time to come to the conclusions that I have come to. I don't jump to conclusions. I am not just paranoid. Be thankful that you haven't walked in my shoes. Better to be someone who knows too little than to know too much. There are people who will go to great lengths to find out what you know. We have a government that would export you out of the country if they could just to get you into the hands of foreign governments who can use torture to get info out of you. Let me tell you, there are many other methods that have not been talked about that you are completely unaware of that they will use to try to get info. You only hear about eavesdropping scandals, etc. when it happens to a government official or to somebody with the means to fight back. I can tell you that just about every body you hear on the radio that is currently pointing their finger at the Bush administration and is making this big deal about eavesdropping is a hypocrit. I can tell you that the talking heads in the media as well as all your reporters, etc. are deeply into eavedropping. Unless someone important like a Newt Gingrich catches somebody in the act and gets a law passed to protect himself, nothing is done about it at all. We are worse than Nazi Germany. It just isn't talked about in the press. It is kept a secret.
Could the aliens really have let Betty Hill know where they're from? Why not? It's not like she has the ability to get there. We still have a hard time getting to our own moon, let alone an alien planet light years away. She asked them where they were from and they showed her. I can think of very few reasons why they would lie to her.
grasshopper replies:
I can think of reasons why they would lie to her. When you hear these stories about people being hypnotised and they ask their abducters where they come from there is a long pause, they may ever talk it over for awhile, then they come back and tell them where they are from. They may be talking it over to see how much they can tell them or how they are going to lie to them. I'm not saying they are being deceptive because they are evil but because it really isn't wise to give out that kind of info.
As far as the government - who knows what in the world they are up to - I beleive you there. Just reading about all of the counterintelligence they used during the cold war - leads one to distrust all information coming from the government. I agree with you 100% there. I read the news every day and whenever I read "a highly place administration offical stated...." and the rest of the sentence to me can not be taken at face value. It's either a lie or a half-lie to meet some agenda.
Some great points there...my question is, how do we know what to believe and what not to believe then? And who to believe....there has to be some criteria of determining who is lying and who isn't...
-rdube02
Does this make a believer out of me? Not 100% - but it does make one wonder how in the world this woman, who has always been an upstanding respectable honest individual, could draw up a star map that wouldn't be discovered for years....
Originally posted by Gazrok
Something many debunkers fail to point out, is that not only does the configuration fit, but the connected stars have one other thing in common, which was stated by Betty, before this was known to astronomers... Those stars are yellow, just like our sun.... Simply incredible really....
Something many debunkers fail to point out, is that not only does the configuration fit, but the connected stars have one other thing in common, which was stated by Betty, before this was known to astronomers... Those stars are yellow, just like our sun.... Simply incredible really....
Originally posted by grasshopper
It goes against wisdom for aliens to go around telling people where they are from or how you can find them just in case you are a bigot and want to come after them or have come to the conclusion that they are abducting people and need to be dealt with. It's just not logical.
Originally posted by rdube02[/
IMO - I picture the aliens as studying us...like we are a species of animal. If you were studying ants, and actually had a way to communicate with the ants...and you picked up a single ant to study and that ant asked you "where are you from?" Out of pure amusement - maybe you would tell that ant. Would you really care either way? Heck - tell the ant - are you really worried about that ant going back to the entire colony and convincing the colony to invade your house?
I believe that if they are real, and if they are studying us, then they view us as far inferior to them. Whatever treaty they have with our government is solely for the purpose of keeping our government out of the way.
The only question I haven't really built any kind of opinion about yet is why on earth they would care enough about an inferior species to study us... Or maybe they don't care - maybe we are just a small part of their scientific studies. Maybe they have "Earth Humanoid Studies 101" in their schools...?
-rdube02