AboveTopSecret.com is a Government COINTELPRO Disinformation Operation, page 4
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5    6    7  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 37 times


reply posted on 12-1-2006 @ 06:01 PM by horusthechorus
I don't post much here but I read, research and write a lot about 'conspiracy theories' and the alternative media/truth movement.

One thing which strikes me about this site is the lack of support it offers to others within the alt media/truth movement, unless it is directly connected to and benefits this site. A red flag.

Another thing is the level of censorship imposed on its members, and I'm not talking about swearing/abuse/insults. Another red flag.

If we stand back and analyze the site for what it is, we see a business. Great. Nothing wrong with that. Business is business. Does it care about the movement, apart from making money from it? I doubt it.

Maybe ATS isn't in touch with the rest of the movement(s), hence the lack of action/support they offer. Maybe those who run this site have become arrogant.

Granted there is a lot of valuable information here, but remember mixing fact and fiction is a fantastic tactic many shills use.

For what it's worth, it seems many of the major players and groups (real activists) within the alt media movement actually avoid ATS. Again, a red flag.

For ATS to bring this to our attention seems.. pointless. Why focus on this self-indulgent exercise while there are much, much more important issues you should/could be bringing to peoples attention?

Who else in the alt media movement do you see crying about being called names? None of the respected members/groups - because there is a job to do which is far more important than ego or making money.



reply posted on 12-1-2006 @ 06:43 PM by Majic
Red Flag Waiver

Originally posted by horusthechorus
For what it's worth, it seems many of the major players and groups (real activists) within the alt media movement actually avoid ATS. Again, a red flag.

Speaking of red flags, calling for orthodoxy in a “movement” and making vague, unsubstantiated claims are also Big Red Flags.

The credibility of ATS is being challenged. In the same post you hand-wave about ATS “censorship” then go on to criticize ATS for not “censoring” this very discussion.

How does that make sense?

Your post is at least appropriately titled, because it is indeed fishy.

If you are willing to back up your sweeping generalizations with some facts that can be examined, I'm interested. I'm sure others would be too.

I've also started a podthread for those who want to sound off on this issue vocally in any manner they please:
ATS.C: Class In Session. You can even cuss if you want to if you make a podcast and use the “explicit” tag. Written posts to that thread are also welcome.

As a member of ATS you are free to express any opinion you want and present any facts you want within the reasonable limitations of the T&C. You are free to criticize those too, but bear in mind that you've agreed to them by being here.

I know for a fact that many of our fellow members are keenly interested in reasonable criticism of ATS. The staff ain't perfect, the members ain't perfect and the site ain't perfect.

But the key word there is reasonable criticism. That means it has to make sense and have a basis in reality.

Please share your reasons. Cite facts. Show us the truth.

I'm waiting, and I'm listening.

Don't be shy.





OPSECSTAT: OMSoM to STN-9D. CR: King in yellow, queen in red.


reply posted on 12-1-2006 @ 07:01 PM by Jedi_Master
Originally posted by SkepticOverlord
AboveTopSecret.com is a professional
"COINTELPRO" operation using secret black-operations funding to publish and promote disinformation as part of the U.S. Government's agenda to deflect and discredit conspiracy theorists.


At least, that seems to be the popular rumor that has circulated about us for some time, and has gained some recent traction.


What...what..what ?

I knew it...you guys are just here to just confuse us and to spread disinfo ...

But anyway this accusation is a hoot , I mean I've been here a while and I've seen the Admin's and Mods' post conspiracies against the US gov before...

My first impression of this site when I joined was no...not agents, but people just wanting to get at the truth, but it has somewhat changed since then, from getting at the truth to promoting an agenda...

But alas...to some people the truth actually does hurt and they resort to name calling and insults...

Looks like the ire is in the debunking of the no plane/missile hits the pentagon, hence the name calling of the COINTELPRO ...


But anyway thanks SO I truely got a good belly laugh out of this one
...

Oh and BTW you disinfo agents that are not getting paid for your services, consult a good lawer, remember the lawsuit against Walmart, you could get some $$$ ?

[edit on 12-1-2006 by Jedi_Master]


reply posted on 12-1-2006 @ 07:21 PM by Majic
Gray Zone

Originally posted by SkepticOverlord
Simon Gray is just a guy who made a cool website about military tech and secret projects because of a personal interest back in 2001.

Ahh, but wasn't ATS originally founded in 1997? What accounts for those missing four years? And how do we know his real name isn't “Chris”?

Overlord Skeptic

Originally posted by SkepticOverlord
SkepticOverlord is a long time online community advocate since 1986 with a keen interest in unusual topics... and some experience with programming.

Oh really, and how do we we know this is true, Mr. SkepticOverlord – if that's your real name!

And just who exactly watches over the Overlord?

Silent Springer

Originally posted by SkepticOverlord
Springer is a money-grubbing lunatic with delusions of grandeur who would like nothing more than for ATS to line his pockets with gold.

Ha! An obvious cover story.

Everyone knows that Springer is a modest, church-going teetotaler who gives the pittance he makes shining shoes away to feed starving nuns and orphans.

Tight Slacks

Originally posted by SkepticOverlord
And none of us have any desire to be, nor have we been, nor will be be, nor are we now connected in any way shape or form either directly, remotely, indirectly, or through osmosis any organized program by groups within any government to shape opinion, disseminate disinformation, cause confusion, or engage in COINTELPRO of any kind, anytime, anywhere.

Nice weasel words. You could drive a Mack truck through the loopholes in that statement.







(Um yes, this could be considered satire, or perhaps even a derivative work, But hey, somebody's gotta do it.)

(Also, I don't offer my questions as substitutes (or “red herrings”) for other, less frivolous questions. And I really am always curious about the early days of ATS.)



reply posted on 12-1-2006 @ 07:31 PM by Implosion
Originally posted by SkepticOverlord
AboveTopSecret.com is a professional
"COINTELPRO" operation using secret black-operations funding to publish and promote disinformation as part of the U.S. Government's agenda to deflect and discredit conspiracy theorists.


NO it isn't.



...heh, that'll fix 'em


reply posted on 12-1-2006 @ 07:42 PM by SkepticOverlord
Originally posted by horusthechorus
One thing which strikes me about this site is the lack of support it offers to others within the alt media/truth movement,

Uh... please elaborate. I can't find any reference to that usnet group.


Another thing is the level of censorship imposed on its members

There is no censorship on ideas, but we do moderate attitude. If you present your ideas with a belligerent attitude, we will take action against that attitude. Some less mature members often confuse that with censorship.


Does it care about the movement, apart from making money from it?

Where's my check? If you review the history of this site, there is a verifiable pattern of continued proactive investment in the services and support needed to encourage and maintain growth. At some point in the future, our efforts may result in some profit that matters, but for now, it isn't (and we have give profits to charity).


Maybe ATS isn't in touch with the rest of the movement(s), hence the lack of action/support they offer.

Help me understand the "movement" you're referring to. Overall, we've always made it clear that we will rarely, if ever, take an official stand of any type. We desire to facilitate an objective environment where an exchange of all ideas are encouraged. Supporting causes and movements would breakdown that objective environment.


For what it's worth, it seems many of the major players and groups (real activists) within the alt media movement actually avoid ATS. [color=Red]Again, a red flag

I'm not sure if this is a good or bad thing yet. There are roughly 1.5 million people per month that to find us and learn more here. If our "kinder gentler" environment helps people to transition from unawares to questioning what is going on around them, how could that be bad. Not every community is for everyone, and I'm sure alt.media.truth is service the members of theirs.


reply posted on 12-1-2006 @ 07:53 PM by EastCoastKid
Originally posted by SkepticOverlord
Those envious who would criticize us, conveniently avoid some of our most stellar contributions to the collective knowledge base on our topics:

A focus on the foreign share-holder aspects of our financial building blocks and the role they play in our stability
Who Really Owns the USA?


SkepticOverlord,
It's an honor to have a thread of mine on that list. I guess that means I'm in on it, eh?

Since I've been accused by some around here of pushing an agenda, I'll just come straight out and say it: My agenda here is to find the truth - wherever it leads.

There's nothing more important than that.


Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5    6    7  >>    ^^TOP^^



Main Stream Media Taking It To Far!!
  Posted 19 days ago with 22 member flags
Iranian Aircraft Carriers in the Gulf of Mexico
  Posted 13 days ago with 10 member flags
A few questions for those of you who hate the Confederate flag
  Posted 15 days ago with 9 member flags
Why Do You Insist On Doing This?
  Posted 6 days ago with 9 member flags
The System Doesn\'t Own You: Exit Strategies (w/ video)
  Posted 7 days ago with 9 member flags
Getting off of oil.
  Posted 15 days ago with 7 member flags