It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
The Bush administration issued a sharp, public rebuke Tuesday to
Prime Minister Paul Martin for dragging the Canada-U.S. relationship into federal electoral politics.
Ambassador David Wilkins' unprecedented, mid-campaign sortie drew an immediate, flag-waving riposte from Martin, who came to office in 2003 promising a more mature relationship with Washington. "I will defend the Canadian position and I will defend our values and I will defend our interests against anybody," the prime minister said on the campaign trail in Surrey, B.C.
"It may be smart election-year politics to thump your chest and criticize your friend and your No. 1 trading partner constantly," Wilkins said in a speech to the Canadian Club at the historic Chateau Laurier Hotel, next door to Parliament Hill.
"What if one of your best friends criticized you directly and indirectly almost relentlessly?" asked Wilkins.
"What if that friend demanded respect, but offered little in return?"
The United States may be an easy target for "political expediency," he said.
"But the last time I looked, the United States was not on the ballot for the Jan. 23 election," Wilkins added to scattered applause.
Less than a week after Martin raised hackles in Washington by specifically citing the United States for lacking a global conscience on climate change, Wilkins threw the words back at the prime minister.
He pointed out that the U.S. record is far superior to Canada's on curbing greenhouse gas emissions.
"I would respectfully submit to you that when it comes to a 'global conscience,' the United States is walking the walk," said the ambassador.
Wilkins also mentioned the softwood dispute, noting that the U.S.
Commerce Department cut the contentious tariffs on Canadian lumber in half last week.
He defended the continuing American occupation of Iraq, saying "freedom is on the march."
And on looming passport requirements for Canada-U.S. travellers, Wilkins said the two countries can work together to mitigate the impact but that Canadians have to appreciate the new American mentality.
"Canada should understand that 9-11 forever changed my country," Wilkins said of the September 2001 terrorist attacks.
His blunt message got a muted reception.
Wilkins' 20-minute speech was mostly greeted with silence.
A North American Free Trade Agreement panel has rejected a North Dakota Wheat Commission appeal over Canadian spring wheat imports, clearing the way for the U.S. government to lift tariffs on grain from north of the border.
The Canadian Wheat Board described the decision this week as the last hurdle to Canadian grain freely crossing the border again.
"But it is a slippery slope, and all of us should hope that it doesn't have a long-term impact on the relationship."
"Just think about this. What if one of our best friends criticized you directly and incorrectly almost relentlessly? What if that friend's agenda was to highlight your perceived flaws while avoiding mentioning your successes? What if that friend demanded respect but offered little in return?"
"I have not made the United States a target in this campaign," he said, explaining that his disputed positions on softwood lumber and climate change were adopted "long before any election was contemplated."
"Let me simply say to anyone who wants to question what I have been saying, beginning with (Conservative Leader) Stephen Harper, that I am the prime minister of this country, that our position on climate change will be determined by the government of Canada, that the fact is that we do expect our partners to honour their agreements -- and I will defend Canada. Period."
Paul Martin shrugs off White House rebuke
The United States made an unprecedented foray into Canada's election campaign on Tuesday, warning politicians not to bash Washington in their bid to win the January 23 election.
But an unapologetic Liberal
Prime Minister Paul Martin
responded immediately by saying "c'est la vie" -- that's life -- if the United States did not like his remarks, and he would not accept anyone telling him he cannot defend his country.
"That our friends do not like what we say -- well, c'est la vie. I'm going to defend Canada and I'm right on softwood lumber and I'm right on climate change and I won't let anybody tell me that I should not defend my country,"
"I have not made the United States or any country a target in this campaign," he said, noting that he had outlined Canada's stand on softwood lumber and climate change long before the election was called.
Canada generally tilts more to the left than the United States and opinion polls show most Canadians dislike U.S. President George W. Bush.
Wilkins didn't specify whom his remarks referred to, though they appear aimed at Liberal
Prime Minister Paul Martin, who has regularly attacked the United States over a bilateral dispute over softwood lumber exports.
Canada generally tilts more to the left than the United States and opinion polls show most Canadians dislike U.S. President George W. Bush.
The relationship has been damaged in recent years by a series of personal attacks by leading Canadians against President George W Bush.
A spokesman for Mr Martin's predecessor, Jean Chretien, was overheard telling reporters that Mr Bush was a moron and an MP from the ruling Liberal party once said: "Damn Americans, I hate the b*****ds."
The relationship has been damaged in recent years by a series of personal attacks by leading Canadians against President George W Bush.
An unrepentant Paul Martin said Wednesday he "will not be dictated to" by the United States as he stood his ground in an increasingly testy exchange with American officials.
"I am not going to be dictated to as to the subjects that I should raise," Martin said in Richmond, B.C., as he visited a sawmill. "I will make sure that Canada speaks with an independent voice now, tomorrow and always, and you should demand nothing less from your prime minister."
Martin's remarks were in response to questions, but there was no mistaking his determination to make his case to voters on Canada-U.S. relations.
He underscored his refusal to take dictation from Washington three times during his encounter with reporters.
Originally posted by rizla
The US Republicans are trying to influence the elections in the Conservatives favour. I recall about a year ago that when Bush visited Ottawa he unexpectedly criticised the Liberal stance on star wars. At the time I felt it was the same type of thing.
Originally posted by Dulcimer
I wonder what the United States thinks about Stephen Harper though.
The US ambassador meanwhile stressed that he had not been seeking to interfere in Canada's election.
"What I said yesterday was not in any way intended to affect an election. That's obviously Canada's business and Canadians will make that decision in January," Wilkins said.
Relations between the two neighbors chilled after Canada declined to support the 2003 US-led invasion of
Iraq. A November poll here found 38 percent of respondents thought US
President George W. Bush was the world's most dangerous figure.
However, other issues have tarnished US-Canadian relations, including a spat over Canadian softwood lumber exports and differences over environmental policies.
Martin is campaigning for re-election after his scandal-tainted Liberal Party minority government was ousted in a no-confidence vote.