It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Liberal1984
Oh there is another great reason why some people are against war. Some people are doing it just for the hell of being anti establishment, egoist freaks.
First Gulf war killed 250,000 civilians but this war we don't respect the Iraqis we kill enough to count them. However given that this war has been going on for so long many people are wondering if it might just be higher.
Originally posted by Liberal1984
All you seem to be thinking about is how many people we have lost. That is your only looking at things from your point of interest first.
Here are just some of the reasons why "so many people" think the war in Iraq has been a failure...
1. First Gulf war killed 250,000 civilians but this war we don't respect the Iraqis we kill enough to count them. However given that this war has been going on for so long many people are wondering if it might just be higher.
These figures are completely wrong
2. According to Pentagon website Saddam killed between 250,000 and 350,000 people over 30 years of been in power. (So if we carry on much longer then even by our high end estimates we would have killed more).
Saddam killed over 100,000 Kurds alone, this doesn't include all the mass graves in and around Bagdad that we found. He left the Kurds dead in the streets.
This does not include the people who died because of his decisions like the Iran Iraq war which America openly supported him and i still think is right. It merely includes those "thought" to have died through oppression.
3. Despite Saddam's death toll he did bring Iraq stability. When Saddam took power Iraq was in more or less exactly the same kind of mess it is today.
At what point does stability become oppression? I hope I don't hear you correctly and you are justifying his actions?
4. Our removal of Saddam has created a "power vacuum" that has unleashed long term anarchy. This will be a long term source of death thanks to our military actions even after we leave Iraq.
Really it is more of a "power struggle" than a vacuum as the vacuum has already been filled. The fact the armed struggle is getting worse not better at this point in time shows how long it may continue.
Long term anarchy huh, I guess you can see into the future with a crystal ball. Give the Iraqi people some credit, they haven't even finalized a constitution yet.
5. Iraq's Sunnis are being massacred both by the population they used to control, and the Americans who are fighting the insurgency. The Sunnis although a minority are educated people, and follow a secular Muslim faith. They accepted and tolerated other faiths, this is opposed to the majority population (Muslim fundamentalists) our democracy has put in power (the Shiite group who make about 60% of a population).
As a Christian i feel for the Sunni Secular Muslims, and dislike the Fundamentalists Muslims who are Iraq's majority but also often dislike all other faiths (including different versions of their own).
This statement is where I quit reading you're factless opinions. The Sunni are the ones causing the terror, you are backwards in your statement.
6. Thanks to the insurgency Iraq is producing little more oil than it did under Saddam. Had we made peace with Saddam we would be getting a lot more oil.
Oil production in Iraq is higher than under Saddams rule, and it would be higher if terrorists quit their sabatoge.
7. Saddam was a good leader in the sense that he spent more of his countries wealth on his own people than any other Arab leader. Though UN Sanctions reduced much of Iraq’s populous from near Western style living standards before the Gulf War, to third world poverty by the start of the invasion, Saddam didn’t build nor even finish a palace half way through construction before the Gulf War. But yes he did live in them.
Clue? Saddam is the sole reason Iraq was inpoverished in the first place, Sanctions were offset by oil for food in which Saddam spent on his family and the weatlhy Sunni minority.
8. a: The western media is full of propaganda in the sense it "forgets" to tell you things. Little things like Kuwait had been part of Iraq for over 5200 years before 1921 when it was created by the British who ruled Iraq as part of the empire. That the only reason why Kuwait has so much oil is because we deliberately included Iraq’s oil within its borders through the Summer Protocol of 1921. That we did this to prevent Iraq being too powerful in the (then) future.
In this ignorant line of thinking, Russia should just take over 1/2 of the Balkans and sub - states that were formed in the Communist split, maybe you prefer China to take back Taiwan and I guess you also would prefer Israel to own half the Middle East again also. You have no concept of freedom. Maybe we should give Germany back Europe again also.
b: That the Kurds where accepting bribes from Iran to steer up in trouble inside Iraq. That Saddam had tried to negotiate with both the Iranians and the Kurds before he apparently gassed the Kurds, and invaded Iran because they had continued to bribe the Kurdish tribal leaders in spite of the Iran Iraq border deal, before the Iran Iraq war.
c: Our media is owned by few people who can and do deals with our politicians without braking the law. Be it taking questions in advance, or favouring on party over the other; their is no law against “not reporting the truth”. The only law Westerners have to give them faith in the media are ones which ban fabricating the truth. Many people know that is not enough, but know that we are a minority to have done our research and in a democracy only a majority rule.
English?
When just this war (never mind Kuwait) has killed more people than Saddam's 34 years of brutality (it might have already; if only we could count!!!) it is then I want George Bush to go on trial. Since there is no justice in this life, let’s hope he (and people like him) will get it in the next!!!
Oh there is another great reason why some people are against war. Some people are doing it just for the hell of being anti establishment, egoist freaks. It’s sad but true with any left wing cause.
But on the other hand I think it’s a lot better than being in right wing group; where so many people are there because they think the State is almost a version of Jesus Christ.
Originally posted by Agit8dChop
rstrik, i think its pretty immatuer to say somethign like that. consider the time that ww2 happened, the morals and values of people in that day and age.. they were defending america against an attack on pear lharbour...
America was hit by Osama ' supposidly ' yet they hit Iraq? this is a completely different matter.
The war in iraq isnt COMPLETE yet, so to call it a failure is like counting your chickens.
To call it unjust? illegial? Stupid? arrogant? hot headed.. .well dang best call it an American war then!
The war on TERROR is a failure.. why? because the SUPPOSID master mind of the terror attack goes free, while america destorys mames and murders IRAQIS who did NOTHING WRONG!
This war is a failure of American respect and principles! why? because your commander in cheif, who LIED and decieved the world, still stands in front of his camera, with that stupid smirk on his face, reading PREPARED speaches saying that even tho there were no WMDS, iraq WASNT a threat and had NOTHING to do with sept11, that we have waltzed in, murders thousands of innocent people, destroyed endless amounts of historical buildings and artifacts but its all ok people... This was the RIGHT THING TO DO! those DAM iraqi's... they never wanted peace, they were EVIL SOB's and the might of American power destroyed there puny, pathetic ancient army...
God BLESS AMERICA!
you patriotic fools that still defend this criminal need to look in the mirror and make a serious assement.
How can anydefend what is happening in Iraq?,... democracy? bringing freedom?.. how about you ask the people on the ground in baghdad how FREE they feel?.. how DEMOCRATIC they are?
america created a hell hole on Earth, and they are prepared to throw in as MANY of its own Sons and Daughters as it needs to, to ensure that precious black gold that lines Chenney and Co's pockets keeps coming in.
this war isnt a failure, its a Joke.
A joke that is going to destroy this world as we know it.
The problem is america has created such a sh1t storm in Iraq that it is impossible to bring the troops home.
the point of no return was reached years ago, and Americas sons and daughters are going to pay for Bush's mistake with there blood.
for all you defending this war I ask if your son or daughter is there spilling there blood!.... defneding the troops is one thing, but defending the president who sent them there over BULLCR@P is another.
Thankyou America..
[edit on 26-9-2005 by Agit8dChop]
[edit on 26-9-2005 by Agit8dChop]
[edit on 26-9-2005 by Agit8dChop]
if iraqis are willing to kill thousands of their own such as saddam hussien did, what makes you think they wont attack america such as osama did. its like a chess game, take out your threats before they attack you.
Originally posted by Ponderosa
if iraqis are willing to kill thousands of their own such as saddam hussien did, what makes you think they wont attack america such as osama did. its like a chess game, take out your threats before they attack you.
Where was the invasion when the Iraqi people were getting gassed, or after Iraq invaded Kuwait? Did Iraq not pose a threat then? Oh, well in post 9/11 world it's different. It's not, the only difference is that people are aware of the threat, it was always there it's just a majority of the public couldn't see it.
Why do people think that the war in Iraq has been a failure?
Of the 19 provinces in Iraq, 16 are calm, quiet, and orderly, with life going on so much better than 3 years ago. Electricity is available in more areas than ever, even in places that NEVER had power before. Same with clean/fresh water (two villes that were out in front of us, had a community canal that was used for everything you can imagine: washing, swimming, fishing, drinking, cooking, urinating and defecating). The Engineers with us, built a pipeline from the Tigris river to the villes, providing clean filtered water for the first time in about a thousand years...literally. Sadly, our LSA still used the canal water----heavily filtered of course---for our showers and toilet water.