It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by sv_gravity 800
What’s important to note here, if in fact this story holds true.
A. They are telling the truth (amazing, this is a message of concern)
B. They are lying, AMAZING..
Originally posted by sv_gravity 800
62 Children would have had to pass a message or all gather and discuss how they all equaly agree “Humanity is destroying itself” smart kids. Even smarter kids if they all collectively, or one individual who some how influenced all the other kids, created this story to get this message of warning? Out. “Humanity is destroying itself” 62 kids huh… in a school where you can’t lye… damn this is amazing either way.
Originally posted by Matrix Rising
For instance, you and others say mass hysteria could be the answer. This makes no sense. There's no evidence to support mass hysteria.
Originally posted by Matrix Rising
This is just the pseudoskeptics throwing out any and every possibility because the evidence doesn't matter.
Originally posted by pogliaghi
I have not read all 10 pages so sorry if this info is a repeat. The main investigator on this case was the late Cynthia Hind. I lived in Rhodesia/Zimbabwe...There should be a follow-up and these kids tracked down and reinterviewed. It would be extremely interesting to find out what they think. It would also be interesting to see if any have had any unusual experiences since.
Come on, that's lame. Don't try to pull the racist card on me. Your Will Smith comment is out of order and you know that's not what I was implying. Not all black people are tribal but a high proportion of african tribes are black.
Did you notice the discrepancy where one child said the eyes came to a point on the inside and another child said the eyes came to a point on the outside?
In fact they dont look very "cut off" from the rest of society at all. Plus this is a PRIVATE school so their parents are most probably quite well off so most probably have access to "media" and also what you have to think about is the fact that as it is a private school they most probably dont live that locally so could be driven every day from a more built up area where the alien perception is widely known.
if it had been in the middle of nowhere and the school was very basic with the children and the headmaster all living in very basic conditions and all being indigenous then it would be more believable
[edit on 31/3/10 by Smiler74]
On that same thought, we have to remember here that we are looking at this through an information embargo. We do not have all the facts and data, but only what Cynthia Hind and John Mack have allowed us to see. And it is worth noting their intention was not to give a full accounting of the case but rather present their viewpoint of it and convice of it's veracity.
We may not necessarily have gotten the full picture.
Why didn't the pseudoskeptics go down there and investigate these things for themselves?
Sadly, most pseudoskeptics are not interested in the truth because to them the evidence doesn't matter. They want to make a general argument that no matter what the evidence says, it couldn't of happened in a way that doesn't agree with their pre-existing belief.
Good post and good case.
John Mack was a Harvard Professor and a Psychiatrist who investigated the case and he didn't mention mass hysteria.
Why should I believe or give any weight to your wild speculation on a message board years after the fact over Harvard Professor John Mack's investigation?
The main investigator on this case was the late Cynthia Hind.
Originally posted by wayaboveitall
Then what are you implying by 'tribal'? More prone than the white kid to beleive in ufo's? How is the kids color relevant?
Originally posted by wayaboveitall
why not the beleivers?
Same could said of them equally.
Originally posted by wayaboveitall
Why should anyone beleive John Mack over their own conclusions?
Therefore, what I have said was not anything to do with being racist, as you seem to be keen on labelling me, but an attempt to get to the bottom of the story. As I said, something didn't seem right with the original story and has since been shown that it wasn't right.
[edit on 1-4-2010 by Frakkerface]
Originally posted by DoomsdayRex
reply to post by Matrix Rising
I already presented the evidence earlier in the thread. However, you have continued to dismissed it and ignored it.