Originally posted by benign
psychiatry is a pseudo science
They just try as many chemicals / treatments as they can imagine on people until they get a decent result, then they go with it.
Prescribng amphetamines to children and sedatives to curb depression, in my opinion its borderline criminal.
Wow, way to overgeneralise!
Psychiatry also treats schizophrenia and bipolar disorder; both of these conditions genuinely
do require chemical intervention - therapy alone
simply doesn't work for either, and we can absolutely quantify the differences between a non-medicated schizophrenic patient and one who is taking
the right meds. The differences are huge, and they're also heart-breaking.
As for depression - this is generally treated with both methods : with medication,
and with psychotherapy. The meds aren't meant to cure the
depression - they simply help you deal with the symptoms while you're going through the psychotherapy (which
is meant to cure, for the most
part). Again, psychotherapy alone doesn't work for every patient (and medication alone doesn't work for every patient, either). That's why a
dual-model approach is necessary.
Neither psychiatry nor psychology are perfect sciences; however neither are pseudo-sciences, ...we do know quite a bit about the brain's chemistry
(re psychiatry), as well as how the brain works in an emotional capacity (re psychology). There's still a lot to be learned in both areas.
Though it's true that Ritalin (one example) is grossly overprescribed, we might also need to ask parents why they're taking their normal,
rambunctious 6 year old to a psychiatrist, instead of realising that he's just a normal, rambunctious 6 year old.
I'm just loathe to lump all psychiatry, or all psychology, under such umbrella terms, you know?