posted on Sep, 3 2003 @ 11:08 AM
I heard back from the RBG. Notice he doesn't even ask how I linked it to him.
ps..i dropped wired magazine a note. they busted the bob smith hoaxer earlier in august. maybe they have some interest.
On Tue, 2 Sep 2003, xxxxxx wrote:
(Thanks for the prose-praise:-)
> I am undoubtedly the first person to ask this
> considering your upshot in traffic this month. Do you
> have any relation to the 6 month saga of John Titor?
Not that I know of -- in fact your question is the first I've heard of
it. Now, of course, I've visited the urbanlegends website and read a
bit, and of course it is a hoax and joke. Coming back in a 1967 Chevy?
Gimme a break. Not to mention the "thermodynamic" argument. Recall
the
issue about life on other planets and alien space travel? If Life is
(as one might expect) common as dirt in the cosmos, and intelligent
life
pretty much inevitable given enough evolutionary time and room, and
interstellar travel is feasible, why doesn't SETI fall all over
signals,
why don't we have hot and cold running aliens visiting, where the hell
IS everybody? All of these questions apply to this sort of time travel
as well. Consider:
a) Time travel in 2036 is "cheap". Sure, he used a 1967 Chevy,
which
by 2036 post a war that killed 3x10^9 people (presumably with loud
noises that are hard on cities and cars) would be a real collectors
item. In fact, a 1967 Chevy is a bit of a collectors item today -- a
real antique. So he must be moderately well off, but still, TT is a
CONSUMER COMMODITY. Buy the apparatus, install it in any handy vehicle
(or not -- there seems to be little reason for the "vehicle" to have
tires and indeed a "shed" equipped with an air supply would work a lot
better than a car without one) and off you go.
b) Manifestly there is little restriction on its use. He has little
special training, it was cheap, anybody can do it, EVERYBODY can do it,
the government(s) can do it, the wacko fringe groups can do it, the
radical terrorist religions can do it, and there is no reason to expect
that in 2040 one suddenly can NOT do it, so there is a virtual infinity
of future times where one can do it with better and better models to do
it with.
c) There are poor people with little by way of prospects in the
future. They too can do it, and they have a really strong incentive to
come back in time armed with stock tips as they can be rich here (and
have foreknowledge of where to live to avoid the coming wars) and they
are poor in the future. They can be REALLY rich and REALLY famous.
Connecticut Yankees one and all. I mean, if I (a physicist) went back
in time a mere 50 years I could stack up Nobel Prizes to my ears. Even
YOU could probably get a few -- 3 degree blackbody microwave background
from the big bang? In my pocket. Lasers? Piece of cake. Hi T
superconductivity? Well, who DOESN'T know to look in cupric ceramics,
and knowing where to look is everything (especially with the money from
the first couple of prizes to start the search with). Transisitors,
integrated circuits, personal computers (why wait for Bill Gates and
IBM
when you can BE Bill Gates better than he ever was). A simple trip to
a
library to steal a few references (no need to worry about returning
them:-) and you're armed with "magical power".
So where IS everybody? We should be living in an absolute chaos of
time
travellers competing with each other for living space, fame space,
fortune space, promoting wacko/fanatical ideas (armed with weapons
technology from the distant future). Hell, there would be at least one
idiot who would get the clever idea of looping himself in time to build
up an "army of selves" all living in the same quiet "perfect" year from
the past. And of course one of the most precious secrets they'd carry
backwards in time would be how to build time machines -- this knowledge
would diffuse backwards in time almost as fast as the rest of physics,
biology, chemistry.
So cute idea and worth praise as a sort of "running story", but alas,
time travel per se, especially CHEAP time travel or EASY time travel,
still contains all of the usual problems. The only way it could be
consistent at all even in a many worlds interpretation (where it isn't
really "time travel", it is just jumping world lines into different
manifolds altogether that may or may not resemble time displaced
versions of your starting point) is if it is very difficult, unlikely,
expensive and hence very, very rare...
rgb
[Edited on 3-9-2003 by kukla]