It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by sebatwerk
Originally posted by pignut
So the rituals are private, freemasons may reveal as much as they whish. Other constitutions no doubt have different guidelines for there members, but in England and Wales the position is as stated.
However you are right the matter is a trivial one, I really should not allow my self to be bated in this way.
Regardless, our rituals are NOBODY'S business but our own. I believe that THAT is why we should keep them private. For that simple reason. If someone reallly wants to know about Freemasonry's ritual, they can go ahead and look on the internet or whatever, but I sure as heck am not going to help them.
Originally posted by pignut
[
The secrets of Freemasonry are concerned with its traditional modes of recognition. It is not a secret society, since all members are free to acknowledge their membership and will do so in response to enquiries for respectable reasons. Its constitutions and rules are available to the public. There is no secret about any of its aims and principles. Like many other societies, it regards some of its internal affairs as private matters for its members.
So the rituals are private, freemasons may reveal as much as they whish. Other constitutions no doubt have different guidelines for there members, but in England and Wales the position is as stated.
Originally posted by pignut
I understand your frustration ‘sebatwerk’ after all the reason for joining the freemasons is to learn things that you didn’t know before, hence the privacy. This in turn functions as a bonding mechanism for members, if the rituals were known before hand this process would be less effective. As ‘Trinityman’ has pointed out foreknowledge of the ritual would tend to reduce the enjoyment of the experience for the candidate, so detailed discussion is discouraged. I hold that these are the reasons for keeping the rituals ‘private’ not an oath forbidding you from revealing them. In this way the rituals may be discussed but only with discretion, bearing in mind the reasons for keeping them private.
Anyway, I did not mean to offend with any of my posts, I only wanted to express my view of freemasonry. It apperes that American masons are less open than UK masons.
Originally posted by benevolent tyrant
I'm am so tired of Jack the Ripper and the mystique that has arisen around this otherwise uninteresting character. He was nothing more than a nineteenth century serial killer who preyed on prostitutes. It's amazing how this figure has acquired a sort of cult status when he did nothing more than what serial killers have always done....kill. Jack is not an icon. He is only a run of the mill murderer who managed to elude the technologically challenged police of his day. Incidentally, serial killers are not a phenomenon of the twentieth century. Jack probably would have disappeared into the fog of history if it had not been for the sensationalization that he gained in the British papers of the day. As far as being a Mason, how do we know this? We don't even know who Jack was! And as far as the murderers that he committed being "ritualistic" well that is certainly going a bit far. Aside from preying on prostitutes, hardly virgins, and crudely mutilating their bodies, I hardly can see ho this could be called ritualistic. No, this was just another run of the mill nutbar whose only real distinction was that of being the first serial killer to have reached the yellow journalistic pages of the day.
Originally posted by mrfixit
UK Masons must take a different oath than what I took over here or when you promise and swear something in the UK it may not have the same meaning. I dunno what it is but the differences are quite amazing.
Originally posted by benevolent tyrant
I'm am so tired of Jack the Ripper and the mystique that has arisen around this otherwise uninteresting character. He was nothing more than a nineteenth century serial killer who preyed on prostitutes. It's amazing how this figure has acquired a sort of cult status when he did nothing more than what serial killers have always done....kill. Jack is not an icon. He is only a run of the mill murderer who managed to elude the technologically challenged police of his day. Incidentally, serial killers are not a phenomenon of the twentieth century. Jack probably would have disappeared into the fog of history if it had not been for the sensationalization that he gained in the British papers of the day. As far as being a Mason, how do we know this? We don't even know who Jack was! And as far as the murderers that he committed being "ritualistic" well that is certainly going a bit far. Aside from preying on prostitutes, hardly virgins, and crudely mutilating their bodies, I hardly can see ho this could be called ritualistic. No, this was just another run of the mill nutbar whose only real distinction was that of being the first serial killer to have reached the yellow journalistic pages of the day.
Originally posted by mrfixit
UK Masons must take a different oath than what I took over here or when you promise and swear something in the UK it may not have the same meaning. I dunno what it is but the differences are quite amazing.
From the UGLE website
The much publicised 'traditional penalties' for failure to observe these undertakings were removed from the promises in 1986. They were always symbolic not literal and refer only to the pain any decent man should feel at the thought of violating his word.
Originally posted by pignut
I am only going on what the UGLE says in the ‘All about Freemasonry’ section on its website. From what they have put on their website it appears that they don’t think that the rituals are secret but they don’t what people to pry into them too much, for the reasons that I have given in previous posts.
Check out the UGLE website if you don't beleve me.
www.grandlodge-england.org...
from what yoy say the UGLE is lying about what they consider to be a secret and their website is just a scam, foolishly I believed it. If they are lying about their rituals being secret what else are they lying about? I thought that Freemasonry was based on humanistic values and that Masons were men of some integrity. But this all came from UGLE propaganda which according to you I cannot trust.
Originally posted by Trinityman
pignut
Some of your questions regarding ritual have overflowed across two threads, and I have hopefully answered some of your questions over there.
Originally posted by mystiqEdwards realised that all the women were killed within a 500-yard radius and that, by joining the sites together, it was possible to create the Vesica Piscis, a fish-like symbol worshipped by the early Christians. By murdering his victims and leaving their bodies in that way, the killer intended a tribute to Satan..