Hillary vs Amanda.

Ok we've got these two new girl on the block, Hillary Duff and Amanda Bynes, yes, I have pre pubecent girls. I'm looking at these two and I see something interesting. HD is being packaged and pushed hard on the young girls. Movies, music, etc. My contention is that Hillary will have a successful sophmore career, damn they're putting enough money into her BUT Amanda has skills. She will have the opportunity to compete for Acadamy awards. The kid can act.

What do you think?

[edit on 04/11/05 by Grey Fox]

I think they're both horrible....


I hate them...


but if I had to choose, Amanda would do better....cause Hillary just annoys many people...

Hillary Duff is basically a good girl package designed and marketed to the Mary Kate and Ashley Olsen crowd (now that they are too old to serve such a market). Amanda is pretty much the same, but isn't as marketted (or overexposed). Eventually, it's inevitable that Hillary will go either super skank (ala Britney Spears) or tortured sweetheart (i.e. Jessica Simpson), and then most will be done with her... Amanda has the chops to make the bridge to adult acting, but of course, has to survive the hazing such a transition causes....

erm i may have been out of the internet thing for a while i now hiliary but who is amanda?


Big sis edit- Please stop with the txt speak, i have fixed it for you...

[edit on 6-5-2005 by asala]

Ok, ina HD vs AB, I'd go with AB, she seems to have more stamina then HD and after the first few minutes of a fight HD will get to tired. Also, isn't HD like Disney? Hate that channel, so many shows for kids, and watch them.(Brace Face, Lilo and Stitch, Kim Possible, why, IDK) They use to have good shows like So Weird, but I think that girl(original, the red head) became a porn star which is why the show changed main star.

still noboady has answered my question...Hillary i know but who is Amanda? the only Amanda is the girl from the Amanda show? (most probally the wrong person).
people can you answer so i can join the conversation! lol
cheers
xx oni xx


(use google and search the name)

[edit on 8-5-2005 by asala]

heres a pic if found in google of Amanda Bynes






btw Hilary Duff is a joke.

Originally posted by balon0
heres a pic if found in google of Amanda Bynes

*picture of cutie here*

btw Hilary Duff is a joke.

You found it on Google? Yeah right! Amanda Bynes Fan alarm....whoop whoop

I have to agree with Gazrock. Amanda Bynes has more staying star power. She'll make it in the long run.

now i know!! i prefer amanda because she has the same name as me!!
lol no i pefer amanda because she just seems down to earh and her movie was alot better than hillary's
x x oni x x

Hilary Duff annoys the hell out of me. My daughter and I went to see A Cinderella Story last summer and she just sucks.

Amanda Bynes was in that movie with Colin Firth, where she goes to England to find her dad. I forget the name of it, but comparing her acting in that, to Hilary Duffs acting... she's a hell of a lot better!

the movie wid amanda in is 'what a girl wants'
its was alot more funny and real, hillarys was very child like!
but maybe they are trying to reach differenrt age groups.
but in my opinion is amanda is alot better, it thin she will
go far in the celb lifestyle.
x x oni x x