It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by LA_Maximus
Don't forget who protected her during the cold war. I still have frost bite on my fingers and toes from patrolling the Eastern Border of Germany, but you go ahead and ridicule my 4 years of service Cargo, it seems to be a national sport in ATS to spit on American soldiers.
I would expect a knife in the back like this from the French, but I dared hoped Germans would be different. I hoped they would look back and say:
-America helped rebuild much of our country after WW II and they stood and protected us from aggression, maybe it would not be a honerable to sell weapons to China.
Originally posted by American Mad Man
WOW, where to begin...
EU arms sales
I think that the EU should not be selling arms to China. Is there a significant chance that China and the US duke it out in the near future? No, I don't think so. None the less, there IS the chance - and I think that should be enough for them to not do this. We ARE still supposed to be allies, and we SHOULD try to look out for each others intrests.
I think it is very dangerous to think that a war between two powers such as China and the US would never happen. Further more, I think it is plain stupid to think that Europe would not get dragged into it (if they didn't start it like the last 2 world wars). Personally, I don't see why this is such an unreasonable request. China has said they would go to war with us over Taiwan - so why help them, even if it is only a chance?
I have also read a lot of posts saying that this is all about money, and that justifies it. Fine - I can deal with that. BUT, and this is a HUGE but - don't go bitch and complain when the US does the same. Remember, it's all about money, every man for themselves. If this is the mentality, then don't get mad when the US has it's way with who ever it wants for economic reasons. Don't complain when the US government decides to sell weapons to your enemies. Don't complain when the US government decides to back Boeing more so then the French can back Airbus and make them go under. Don't complain when we corner the oil market.
On the debt owed to the US by Europe...
The US was the second most important country on the side of the Allies, with Russia being the first. There is no arguing this, there is no debating it. The US was also probably the only reason Germany did not win. Without US backing, Western Europe falls to the Nazi's and Hitler only has to fight a one front war.
I'd also like to take this opertunity to point out how much CHINA owes the US. We almost single handedly freed them from Japan - their mortal enemy. If it weren't for the US, they would be a Japanese colony.
Then there is the cold war. Western Europe owes a great deal to the US. We banded together and took on the USSR side by side, but lets get real - without the US, western Europe is run over by the Russian Bear. This lasted what - 45 years? Without the US you most likely would be under the rule of Nazi Germany or the USSR. Show a bit of gratitude. There is no shame in it. I am greatfull that the UK, Australia, Poland, Italy, and everyone else that helped us out in Iraq. I am greatfull that the better part of the world decided to help in Afghanistan.
The US has been pretty faithfull to our allies in Europe, your economies do not depend on the sale of arms to China, so if we ask you not to do it to help our national security - why after almost 60 years of helping your national security - would you want to give us a collective up yours?
@ LA's post regarding his kid...
I think some of you are taking his words a bit differently then he intended. What I got from it is that he feels that the Europe and to a lesser extent the US has gotten soft, and he does not believe his son to be one of them. I tend to agree with that. I think the Western world in general has gotten soft. Looking back at WWII (to use the current example), the problem snow balled because no one had the backbone to stand up to Hitler before it was too late.
I think that RADICAL Islam is the same scale of threat, even if it does not take the same form of an identifiable nation. I also believe that taking out terrorist cells AND THE NATIONS THEY MIGHT SPONSER THEM now is a key to prevention in the future.
I can also see how China presents the greatest threat from another nation to the US. They have an economy that at the present rate of growth will be able to compete with our own in this century, they have 4 times the population, and they have a potential conflict with us (Taiwan). If you Europeans can't see why we would be upset over arms sales to them, I question your ability to reason.
I'd also like to take this opertunity to point out how much CHINA owes the US. We almost single handedly freed them from Japan - their mortal enemy. If it weren't for the US, they would be a Japanese colony.
The Washington Times
It is yet to dawn on U.S. gatekeepers that 6.7 percent of Chinese defense imports come from the United States and only 2.7 percent from Europe.
Issue 1 - EU arms sales
I see your point however, why should the US continue to trade with China when the EU should not? I can guarantee you that were they allowed Boeing/Lockheed etc would sell their military wares to China, as they have with their civil.
Issue 2 - On the debt owed to the US by Europe
I can say that I will always thank those young men who came to these shores 60 years ago to remove the tyranny of facism.
What is not going to happen is for Europe to bow to the US for all eternity.
What is not acceptable is to expect everyone to jump on the "lets finish ma daddy's work" bandwagon.
To equate the two is to gravely dishonour those of your countrymen who did fight in WW2
I can guarantee you that were the US to be attacked and require troops to defend its borders or to repel invaders, then you would get them from every country in Europe.
Issue 3 - LA's post regarding his kid
I think you will find that in time of need the young people of today are just as opposed to evil as those 60 years ago.
What they are now though is much smarter. They know what is real and what is propaganda.
The sign of this is the voting levels of those under 30 both in the US and Europe.
as posted by Odium
Also, France and Germany owe you nothing. You owe them nothing. No Country owes another Nation anything. Otherwise, America can be held responsible for a lot of deaths and maybe they should pay up for that?
Native Americans maybe? I'm part of the Kanienkehaka by blood, I was born into that. Maybe if Germany owe you something because you served there, you owe us something? Ever think of that?
300years, between 80 and 300million people, now less than 2million. But you know what, I don't care.
Also America did a lot of harm to China...
...during the Korean War they actually dehumanized the Chinese, published documents calling them animals making out they were inferior. Also the fact you've taken the role as "World Police" and you decide what is Right or Wrong. I'm sorry but we have the U.N. to do that for us and they make enough mistakes as it is.
Also, maybe if America would not place so many bases near to China they'd not feel the need to protect themselves?
Originally posted by American Mad Man
Frankly, I doubt that the liberal minded people in this country could be counted on for it, and the youth is mostly liberal.
Originally posted by Odium
China have the right to build whatever military they want, they'll get it from either an E.U. Country, Russia, the Middle East or America. One way or the other.
Also, maybe if America would not place so many bases near to China they'd not feel the need to protect themselves?
Maybe if America did not back Japan over China, they'd not have such problems with you?
After all, the American Administration do not admit the Nanjing Massacre happened, so as not to upset the Japanese. I'm sorry, but how would America liked it if people started denying the fact Pearl Harbour happened?
Also America did a lot of harm to China, during the Korean War they actually dehumanized the Chinese, published documents calling them animals making out they were inferior.
Also the fact you've taken the role as "World Police" and you decide what is Right or Wrong. I'm sorry but we have the U.N. to do that for us and they make enough mistakes as it is.
China will not "invade" America, that will never happen and as long as America stops defending Japan (which lies), South Korea (which does the same) stops teaching false History (such as why China joined the Korean War), stop the "One Rule for Us and One Rule for You" (Israel selling weapons not being frowned upon as much as the E.U.) but also if America is leading in technology, etc, what do they have to fear that Europe can offer them? It's not like the E.U. could offer technology a head of the American Governments own, now is it?
Also, France and Germany owe you nothing. You owe them nothing. No Country owes another Nation anything. Otherwise, America can be held responsible for a lot of deaths and maybe they should pay up for that?
Native Americans maybe? I'm part of the Kanienkehaka by blood, I was born into that. Maybe if Germany owe you something because you served there, you owe us something? Ever think of that?
300years, between 80 and 300million people, now less than 2million. But you know what, I don't care. I ask for nothing back from you. I ask for nothing back from any America. I've made my own life, as has my family and moved on - maybe you could too? After all, less then 60years ago my family were still being treated like scum for having a different colour to their skin.
It sickens me that you think anyone owes America anything. Every Nation does harm, will do harm, nobody can stop it until we stop this aggressive attitude. I've been to China, they don't hate every westerner. Most of them like us. They don't stop free speech. All of your views are out dated. All they want to do is have America leave them alone and take care of its own Country and fix its own problems instead of dictating to the World what we should be doing.
Originally posted by cargo
Originally posted by American Mad Man
Frankly, I doubt that the liberal minded people in this country could be counted on for it, and the youth is mostly liberal.
I'd say the above is a fair and accurate statement. You'll find that those progressive thinking and intelligent young men and women in America today won't blindly run into a recruitent centre based on what the TV showed them pictures of the night before. You'll also find they won't be swayed by nationalistic propaganda or corny patriotism.