posted on May, 21 2020 @ 04:02 PM
DISCLAIMER: As someone who currently has 1,756 hours on this game, I believe I have enough knowledge to give an adequate mini-review. This post will
not be the six-sentence norm of ATS.
Well prepare yourselves for probably one of the worst map generators I have ever seen. "Oh, you picked the Vikings? Coastal or lake start bias...
we're gonna spawn you in the middle of the mountains with one lake tile, nerfing every bonus your civ give you." Fun.
And the game is a straight cheater in terms of barbarian spawning. It will work 10 turns in advance of you to pile spawn on top of spawn in one area
to 100% checkmate a piece and murder it. It is somewhat realistic as barbarians, historically, show up at the worst time in the worst place and keep
coming.
But this game can take it too far, to the point of being ridiculous. You have to strategize against grossly anti-user world AI, instead of
strategizing in a more realistic manner. It feels like your always playing on higher difficulty because of world AI, but the Civ AI's themselves act
like their mentally retarded. Makes lower difficulties almost unplayable.
BUT if you can get past these issues, the game is great. The Civs, for the most part, are well constructed and portrays the real thing quite well. To
the point where I had to stop being Sumeria and Aztec because I'd become so militarily powerful that I'd have to shut it off because nothing can stop
me by 1,800 bc. Never mind the Mongols...
The combat is EXCELLENT! I always play marathon as that mode make military far more important. On higher difficulty the AI isn't so ball-bustingly
stupid at strategy. If you roll in with no plan this game will crush you, NO MERCY. You can no longer be one-dimensional in your tactics. Unless
you're the Mongols.
Very realistic, as you can REALLY get a feel for how devastating the Mongols were when their Keshigs just roll past your defensive line and cruise up
to your capital unopposed with Seige Towers in tow. If you spawn near Qaraqorum, either destroy them RIGHT AWAY, or get a new map. If they get
horsemen up, that's your ass.
I got thousands of hours experience on this game, though I only play by myself. Playing against people gets unrealistic, very fast. Endless beelining.
Takes all historical strategy from the game. No one had horsemen in 2,600 BC, except half the people you'll be playing against. Rome shouldn't have
Legions at 2,350 BC, but they will if you play them online. No balance!