It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Charlie Murphy
When President Truman dropped Atmoic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki he killed millions of innocent men women and children. Now at frist this may seem like soemthing terrible, but when you consider what he prevented its not that bad. He in effect stopped World War II, saving more lives than were lost. Do you see my reasoning?
Originally posted by Charlie Murphy
I was talking about assisted suicide.
Originally posted by Charlie Murphy
That should be their choice to make.
Originally posted by Charlie Murphy
Originally posted by saint4God
Rather, we're making the decision on that child's fate before giving her/him a opportunity to decide for themselves. That's where I think we're committing the error.
Well once he has the ability to reason, its illegal for him to make that desicion.
Originally posted by Charlie Murphy
Thats my point, its not being used as intended.
Originally posted by shaunybaby
i think if someone wants to be put out of their misery, and believe there not to be any worse misery ahead if this 'act' is carried out, then by all means they should have that 'choice'.
Originally posted by shaunybaby
that's really what it's all about 'choice'. problems start to arise when you have people who can no longer communicate, and can you assert 100% that this is what she/he would want. by all means life is important and we should cherish it, but i think in certain circumstances we've just got to say 'just kill me now'...'get it over with'.
Originally posted by shaunybaby
it's the same scenario as abortion, that right and wrong case. however, if we lose our 'choice' to choose if we have an abortion or not, or the choice to die when we want, then we lose the essence of our human selves. that choice should still be available, and when that choice is made some people will think it's the wrong one and some people will think it's the right one, but as long as the choice is there, i'm happy.
Originally posted by shaunybaby
Originally posted by saint4God
Rather, we're making the decision on that child's fate before giving her/him a opportunity to decide for themselves. That's where I think we're committing the error.
i believe this to be a very, very strange comment to make. when in fact would a child be capable of saying 'yeah, i wish i'd never been born'. that's a phrase used, as we all do sometimes in moments of anger or frustration, but we never 'mean' it. however, if a child 'really' did mean it, and perhaps thought to himself, 'it would have been better if my mum got an abortion'...exactly what age is a child ready to make a decision like that.
Originally posted by shaunybaby
this then goes back to previous statements i've made about 'children' in church, the children of christian parents, who are taken to church before they can make any sort of rational decision about their future.
Originally posted by shaunybaby
the lies we are told as children...santa, tooth fairy, don't watch too much tv or your eyes will go square, and many more. most lies adults tell us when we are young are to provide an 'illusion'. when you find out santa isn't real, most of the fun of christmas is gone, you no longer sneak downstairs and wait. or perhaps looking at the tags on christmas presents on christmas eve and seeing ones from santa already there...you just put two and two together. the same with the tooth fairy, don't tell you parents you lost a tooth, and your tooth will be eaten by tiny bacteria before you get 50p. so as a child, when you're being told all these little lies, why then would you take your christian parent's word for it, that christianity is true?
Originally posted by junglejake
Christ is no easter bunny, and He's no Santa Claus[e ], He's a historical figure, according to many archelogical and historical records.
Originally posted by saint4God
Anyone would be correct in saying that I would make a lousy military commander. Still, the job is there and it is necessary to fill it, isn't it? Or is it? Have you ever seen the movie Hero?
Originally posted by saint4God
I am incapable of loving and killing another person.
Originally posted by saint4God
Over a decade ago, I contemplated suicide. If there was even one person who encouraged that I should, then most likely I would've. In retrospect, that would've been a huge mistake.
Originally posted by saint4God
You're absolutely correct. The question is though, does a person who commits suicide concerned about what is 'illegal'? S/he has no charges to answer for. Abortion means the child has no opportunity to make that decision on their own.
Originally posted by saint4God
JJ, thanks for picking up the question of translation on the last page. Well said!
Originally posted by junglejake
As a result, I came from a different perspective growing up. I was raised to be a skeptic. To question everything until you knew it to be false. I've said this several times on this site, but I'll say it again because it's pertenant. This is why I almost scramble to questions on ATS that I don't have the answer to in regards to something I believe. I am looking for that evidence that will prove my belief false. Hey, if I am wrong about Christianity, I want to know, because I'll be wasting my life otherwise. Thing is, I haven't found any proofs that I'm wrong. Sure, there's theory and conjecture, but let's face it. When you're presented with a theory against your own with little or no evidence, which side are you going to fall in? Especially if you've tested your theory time and time again and found it to not be lacking? If you think this is BS, I ask you to check out several evolution threads.
If you read through the whole thread that I link to in my signature, you will see how this principle was applied to my discovery of Christianity. Christ is no easter bunny, and He's no Santa Claus[e ], He's a historical figure, according to many archelogical and historical records. At that point you have to explore more yourself. What you find may shock you and rattle your beliefs to their core.
Originally posted by Charlie Murphy
Jake-
I know what your saying but there wasn't just a Bible that said-The Original Copy. I was under the impression the contents of the Bible was collected from scrolls and such and combined into one. The Bible itself doesn't necessarily have to be translated for its contents to have been translated.
Darkness himself, Charlie Murphy
Originally posted by Charlie Murphy
No, I havent seen it but my friend told me it was a good movie.
Originally posted by Charlie Murphy
I can understand a need for police, but the only reason for a military, is because of our enemies military. Maybe my view is a little biased because I dont live in a third world country, I just dont understand how countries could still be fighting each other in the year 2005.
Originally posted by Charlie Murphy
What if your wife/child, or anyone you loved was in pain and asked you to put them out of their misery? I dont mean to put you on the spot with an uncomfortable question, but this is the situation that the doctors were in.
Originally posted by Charlie Murphy
I think everyone's thought about it at one time or another. Not necessarily killing themselves, but the what would happen if they did. When I was depressed awhile ago I thought about it. I knew it would create more sadness then it would stop. The funny thing is, nowadays I couldnt care less about what I was so worried about before.
Originally posted by Charlie Murphy
Well of course suicide doesnt have any consequences, but attempted suicide does.
Originally posted by Charlie Murphy
I still think abortion should still be legal, but not as lax as it is now. All necessary precautions should be taken, and it should be a last resort. To make it illegal though is to take away a person's freedom.
Originally posted by Charlie Murphy
Darkness himself, Charlie Murphy
Originally posted by junglejake
You make a good point. The scrolls, however, were originally written in Greek. There are actually thousands of old transcripts of the gospels and epistles from way back in the day still in existence today. In about 250 BC the old testament, aka Torah, was translated from Hebrew to Greek. 200 years before that it had been translated from Hebrew into Aramaic. Both times were to account for the prevalent languages spoken and read by the Jews. At the time Christ came, Greek was the standard "learned" language, used for most writing at the time in the area of Israel.
We also have, of course, the authenticity. How well can these manuscripts be trusted? There are, as I said, over 5,600 ancient manuscripts of the various books of the New Testament. In comparison, the general source of Roman history, Tacitus' Annals of Imperial Rome, which is dated about 116 A.D., has only one remaining copy, yet is held as true.
The Gospel of John also claims to be written by a disciple. That's important, because the followers of Christianity were referred to as apostles except the 12 who traveled with Christ. Recent archeological evidence has confirmed both the existence of the Pool of Bethesda and that it had 5 porticoes, as mentioned in John 5:2. It seems unimportant, but this incidental information leads to believing that the author knew of the pool, and had seen it. Since the Pool of Bethesda was destroyed along with the rest of Jerusalem in 70 A.D., it would lead one to believe the book must have been written before.
Originally posted by topsecretombomb
this thread name itself doesnt even claim any significance. there is absolutely no power in christianity but power in the god they believe in. people need to learn how to accuse the right way.
Originally posted by topsecretombomb
this thread name itself doesnt even claim any significance. there is absolutely no power in christianity but power in the god they believe in. people need to learn how to accuse the right way.
church= the people
god= where the real power actually dwells
you can have a life of never attending one church, but this doesnt mean that you cant get through heavens gates. it all boils down to your relationship with the devine of course.
-tombomb
or they had some sort of godly experience and thus became religious.
Originally posted by junglejake
Hehe you give yourself far too much credit I enjoy these conversations with you because they get me to go deeper into my faith and beliefs. Now how could darkness its self do that?
Originally posted by saint4God
I highly recommend it. I cannot say how it pertains to what we're talking about without giving the movie away.
Originally posted by saint4God
Is the result of an attempted suicide a punishment though or an attempt to help? What I thought was most astounding is when my spouse had attempted, the psychologist said "go home, live your life". Though grateful, wondered if 'society' really cared. Didn't look like it to me.
Originally posted by saint4God
What is a last resort?
Originally posted by saint4God
Hello darkness, it's me again. Remember last time? My you're awfully subtle these days, are you feeling well?
Originally posted by Charlie Murphy
Originally posted by saint4God
Originally posted by saint4God
Is the result of an attempted suicide a punishment though or an attempt to help? What I thought was most astounding is when my spouse had attempted, the psychologist said "go home, live your life". Though grateful, wondered if 'society' really cared. Didn't look like it to me.
Who am I to tell your spouse if it is better to kill herself(correct?) or not? If she has a problem of course we should care, but if she doesnt I feel its not my business. If anyone I knew (closely) committed suicide, I would miss them terribly, but I would respect that it is there choice to make.
While I agree with you that a lost loved one would be missed terribly, how is it their choice to make? What are humans that we have any right to choose what to do with the life God has given us?
Originally posted by equilibrium
What are humans that we have any right to choose what to do with the life God has given us?
Originally posted by Charlie Murphy
Ill have to borrow it from him sometime.
Originally posted by Charlie Murphy
Who am I to tell your spouse if it is better to kill herself(correct?) or not?
Originally posted by Charlie Murphy
If she has a problem of course we should care, but if she doesnt I feel its not my business. If anyone I knew (closely) committed suicide, I would miss them terribly, but I would respect that it is there choice to make.
Originally posted by Charlie Murphy
When you dont care anymore about the things I mentioned earilier.
Originally posted by Charlie Murphy
Again, you'll have to view My True Hollywood Stories.
Originally posted by saint4God
Yes indeed! Unless historical legend isn't your thing. Still a great story though.
Originally posted by saint4God
A compassionate human being to say not to. My spouse is also grateful to be alive after that day.
Originally posted by saint4God
I understand where you're coming from, but unless you are certain something better awaits on the other side (faith), I don't know how you can feel this way.
Originally posted by saint4God
I can't see "not caring" at a single point in time as being a last resort. In that case, all people who have a momentary lapse of depression should off themselves? Does that feel right to you?
Originally posted by saint4God
Oh a difference 'darkness'. Nice to meet you Dave.