a reply to: Ahabstar
Still love Star Wars but not totally sold on d6 System.
Of course not, the resolution of d6, while like the imperial system is easily divisible by 2s and 3s, is by no means as intuitive as something metric
Okay okay, prevent thread drift. Hmm, okay:
I see no reason why a user account couldn't possess both Fighter and Ref tags. Maybe the flaw in the original system was reliance upon staff to manage
things, rather than allowing the community to self-regulate. You hand-pick maybe 20 accounts for the "Referee" tag, then require something like 5
net wins to acquire a new Ref tag. Fighter tags only require a request, could be automated. Now, any Ref can establish a bout in
the forum(create thread permission) and thereafter anyone possessing a Ref tag can adjudicate. Only Fighters listed in the OP may participate in the
thread, violation of this rule(probably a rule 1 violation) results in censure, multiple violations removal of Privileges in the Debate forum.
Appeals: A Fighter, having been defeated, may appeal defeat by submitting one public comment in the thread in question, citing specific examples of
mis-adjudicaton, to include direct links to comments and the appropriate quoted verbiage. The victor may then defend the ruling in one reply, in the
same thread, to counter the appeal. A quorum of no less than 5, and within an elapsed time from the
submission time of 24 hours, will then record their ruling in said thread. In the event of a tie, the most recent Referee vote is
edit on 18-10-2019 by Zelun because: the window of appeal is based upon the time of the final ruling.
18-10-2019 by Zelun because: really need to use that preview button
edit on 18-10-2019 by Zelun because: net wins