Europe, China and the Arms Embargo:The Implications of European-Chinese Partnership, page 3


Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5    6  >>
ATS Members have flagged this thread 0 times


reply posted on 13-3-2005 @ 05:55 PM by stumason

I agree but that is not a leftist comment, it is hard for me to believe you accept that as truth and necessity.


Remember Ed, in the UK, we are not as partisan as you chaps over the Pond, and hover either centre-left/right, and have interchangeable ideals.

One person could have right wing views on Immigration for example, yet still believe wholehartedly in Social Healthcare. Two diametric ideas together. Believe me, I am one of those.

To paint everyone with the Liberla/Conservative brush is too black and white, and as you have berated poor Devilwasp on his "utopian" ideals, and his age I might add, then you must also realise that the US view of everything in Black and White also does not convey the reality of the modern world.

Onto topic.

Why is it that selling weapons to China is bad? Is it because you, as a (extreme) right wing conservative in the US fears a strong(er) China?

You forget a few things about China:

1) They have nearly always been a dominant world power. It has only been recently in the past century and a half or so, after European meddling in their affairs that they became weak. They are merely re-ascerting their position at the top of the food chain, where they always have been.

2) They seek neither territorial conquest, or war with anyone. All the calls for war have come from you guys, not them. And you wonder why they want better weapons?

3) they are one of your largest trading partners, AND creditors, so war with you would be folly anyway. Why are you so afraid?

4) You accuse the Europeans of having either an attitude of appeasement, little experience in Foreign affairs or being more interested in trade. Is trade not better than war? Do you not think that Europe (and the UK in particular) has plenty of experience in dealings with foreigners?

5) We stand to make a nice mint out of weapons sales to China (The UK being one of the worlds leading weapons manufacturers). And on the heel of weapons sales comes other things, such as civilian Aerospace and other High-Tech goods. Its called trading, they make crappy little things en masse, and we, in return, trade them high value, high tech goods.

Why all the anti China rhetoric Ed? They may not have the same idelogy than you, but then, they never have!

They are a different culture entirely. This is one world, with many voices, not just that of the US and its corporate lackeys!

Not everyone wishes to listen Britney sodding Spears and eat McFattys.

Although, the Chinese admittedly seem to like to eat a few Big Macs a day, look at their rising obesity problem. But then, this has risen due to the increasing influence of western ideals on their culture.

[edit on 13/3/05 by stumason]


reply posted on 13-3-2005 @ 07:22 PM by stumason
And restraint is what you will most likely get. We are not about to arm them with Chally 2's, Eurofighters (at least not just yet) or Vanguard subs, but more than likely 2nd rate (by Western Standards) APC's, helo's and maybe some older generation fighters, along side base technologies, but none that will compromise our own national security or advantage.

This, like I have said, is to open the door for other High-tech Euro products, which always follow on from big arms deals.

The communist China of now, is much different even from ten years ago. There has been a good series in the last week on BBC News about China, and for its (continuing) problems, it has advanced much across the board.

It is not strictly communist, and even if you classify it as such, it still is not the same as the Soviets were.

Taiwan, they have a legitimate claim. As Spain (thinks ) it does on Gibraltar, and Argentina (thinks ) it does on the Falklands. This is no different. The problem here, is that the US has managed to get itself treaty bound to protect Taiwan. This is quite amusing, as it wasn't until recently (last decade or so) that Taiwan became truly democratic itself.

The Taiwanese Government is the remains of the former Chinese Nationalist movement, fascists for want of a better word. So thank your lucky stars (thirtenn isn't there Ed?) the commies won! Imagine a fascist China! Then you would have reason to be scared!

Lastly, I cannot believe that Ed and myself seem to have at least reached some middle ground.... (well, I was already there, just trying to get Ed to dip his toe in!)

EDIT: Here is a link for the BBC on China. Its a start, worth a read. The BBC is a fair and balanced news source Ed, worth looking at it every now and then:

BBC on China


Have fun!


Edit again for crap spelling

[edit on 13/3/05 by stumason]
Pages: <<  1    2    3    4    5    6  >>    ^^TOP^^



UN Proposes Tax On Americans for 3rd world countries
  Posted 18 days ago with 28 member flags
Armed bystander stops stabbing outside school
  Posted 12 days ago with 27 member flags
" Climate Change Is Not A Hoax", says Obama!!??
  Posted 4 days ago with 21 member flags
Former Arizona Sheriff Mack, ‘Gun Control Against the Law’
  Posted 13 days ago with 12 member flags
Limiting Freedom & It\'s Effects On Society
  Posted 17 days ago with 11 member flags