It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
What is taqiyyah, and who are the people who practise it? In fatwa no. 101272, you said that it is a term that is particular to the Shi‘ah, and that they are the only ones who practise it. But I discussed with some people who said that Ahl as-Sunnah also practise it. Is this true?
Praise be to Allah
Firstly:
Taqiyyah, in the usual and well-known sense, is one of the basic principles of the Ithna-Ash‘ari Raafidis; Ahl as-Sunnah wa’l-Jamaa‘ah differ from them concerning it and it is something that takes them beyond the boundaries of the straight path of Allah.
Taqiyyah in their religion means presenting outwardly something that is different from what one believes inwardly, as an act of religious devotion. Thus they attributed lying and deceit to the religion of Allah, wrongfully and out of enmity.
This corrupt belief has nothing to do with the beliefs (‘aqeedah) of Ahl as-Sunnah. According to Ahl as-Sunnah, lying is one of the attributes of the hypocrites. A person may keep on lying and persist in lying until he is recorded with Allah as a liar. These people tell lies and persist in lying in all things, then they regard that as part of their beliefs and religion.
The way of Ahl as-Sunnah wa’l-Jamaa‘ah is based on truthfulness and justice; lying is not part of their religion, praise be to Allah.
Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyah (may Allah have mercy on him) said: The Raafidis are the most ignorant and mendacious of sects, and the furthest removed from any knowledge of the texts or rational evidence. They regard taqiyyah as one of the basic principles of their religion, and they tell lies about Ahl al-Bayt (the Prophet’s family), the extent of which is known only to Allah. They even narrated from Ja‘far as-Saadiq that he said: “Taqiyyah is my religion and the religion of my forefathers.” But taqiyyah is one of the signs of hypocrisy; in fact in their case, they say verbally that which is not in their hearts, and this is the essence of hypocrisy.
End quote from Majmoo‘ al-Fataawa, 13/263
He also said:
As for the Raafidis, the basis of their innovation is heresy and the deliberate lying that is widespread among them. They affirmed that when they said: Our religion is taqiyyah. This means that one of them says verbally something other than what is in his heart, and this is lying and hypocrisy. Yet despite that they claim that they are the (true) believers, to the exclusion of other Muslims, and they describe the earliest believers as apostates and hypocrites, when they are the ones who deserve this description. There are no people among those who outwardly profess to be Muslims who are closer to hypocrisy and apostasy than them, and there is no greater number of apostates and hypocrites in any other group than in theirs.
End quote from Minhaaj as-Sunnah an-Nabawiyyah, 1/30
It says in al-Mawsoo‘ah al-Muyassarah (1/54), which discusses the basic beliefs of the Shi‘ah:
Taqiyyah: They – meaning the Imami Shi‘ah – regard it as one of the basic principles of their religion, and they regard the one who does not practise it as being the same as one who does not pray. It is obligatory and it is not permissible to refrain from it until the hidden imam appears. Whoever refrains from it before he appears has gone beyond the pale of the religion of Allah, may He be exalted, and the religion of the Imamis.
End quote.
Dr. Naasir ibn ‘Abdullah al-Qafaari said:
Al-Mufeed defined taqiyyah for them as follows: Taqiyyah means concealing the truth, concealing belief in it, concealing one’s true beliefs from those who differ from one and not showing openly that which may lead to negative consequences in religious or worldly terms.
Thus al-Mufeed defined taqiyyah as concealing beliefs for fear of harm from those who disagree with them – namely Ahl as-Sunnah, as is usually the case when they use this term. In other words, it means making an outward display of following the madhhab of Ahl as-Sunnah (which they regard as false), and concealing the Raafidi madhhab, which they believe is true. Hence some Sunnis think that those who adhere to this belief are worse than the hypocrites, because the hypocrites believe that what they are concealing of disbelief is falsehood, and they make an outward display of being Muslims out of fear. But in the case of these people, they think that what they are concealing is truth, and that their path is the way of the Messengers and Imams.
End quote from Usool Madhhab ash-Shi‘ah al-Imaamiyyah, 2/805
Secondly:
Taqiyyah – as an idea or concession to be used in extreme circumstances, on a temporary basis – is known to Ahl as-Sunnah, but it is different from the taqiyyah practised by the Raafidis in both general and specific terms. According to Ahl as-Sunnah, it is something to be resorted to when one has no other choice, and it is an extraordinary measure to be used only in times of extreme necessity. eThe view of the majority of Sunni scholars is that the basic principle concerning taqiyyah is that it is disallowed; it is only permissible in the case of necessity, and is permitted only to the extent that is necessary. Al-Qurtubi said: The basic principle concerning taqiyyah is that it is not permissible unless there is the fear of death, severing of a limb or extreme harm, and there is no report to the contrary as far as we know, except that which was reported from Mu‘aadh ibn Jabal among the Sahaabah and from Mujaahid among the Taabi‘een. End quote.
According to Ahl as-Sunnah, in order for taqiyyah to be permissible, there should be fear of harm and the individual should not have any other means of avoiding harm except by resorting to taqiyyah. It is also stipulated that the harm that is feared should be of a type that is extremely hard to bear. The one who resorts to taqiyyah should also note that if he has any other option that does not involve committing a haraam action(sinful), then he must choose it. He should also note that he should not indulge in the concession to such an extent that it goes beyond the limits of taqiyyah to the level of negligence by committing haraam actions after achieving what is necessary. The basic principle concerning that is what Allah, may He be exalted, said concerning the one who is forced by necessity
originally posted by: starwarsisreal
a reply to: Kapusta
I confess I'm one of the few non Muslim ATS member that sympathize with Islam though I am not a fan of the current version of Islam which has been corrupted by various groups such as the Wahhabis and the Islamic theocrats in Iran.
In fact, I see the current brand of Islam as a dangerous destabilizing force that threatens a lot of countries from Western nations to Japan.
A takfiri (Arabic: تكفيري takfīrī) is a Muslim who accuses another Muslim (or an adherent of another Abrahamic faith) of apostasy. The accusation itself is called takfir, derived from the word kafir (unbeliever), and is described as when "one who is, or claims to be, a Muslim is declared impure."
originally posted by: Kapusta
originally posted by: starwarsisreal
a reply to: Kapusta
I confess I'm one of the few non Muslim ATS member that sympathize with Islam though I am not a fan of the current version of Islam which has been corrupted by various groups such as the Wahhabis and the Islamic theocrats in Iran.
In fact, I see the current brand of Islam as a dangerous destabilizing force that threatens a lot of countries from Western nations to Japan.
With all due respect the term "wahabi" is also misunderstood. Extemsit have adopted that term and also the term salfi . thus its now associated with extremism. Meh.. Long story to ,much to type.but the rulings i posted are from scholars who are from the same schools of thought of abdule bin wahab.
originally posted by: and14263
We're in a world where there are 1.6billion Muslims - that figure is 6 years old. Of this 1.6billion how many do you think 'mis interpret' Islam and advocate death to homosexuals, chopping off a limb for stealing, public stonings for adultery, female genital mutilation, suppressing women, controlling women, 'owning' a woman....
Studies show between 15-25% of 1.6 billion Muslims advocate these barbaric view points.
If it were only 5% that would still be 80million animals. If it is as high as 25% that's 400million.
That's a lot of people 'mid understanding' a religion.
Figures are correct as of 2010 and can be researched in multiple places, Pew Research being one.
I'm not saying statistics don't lie.
But I am saying there's something here which clearly needs addressing. Without cries of racism or prejudice.
originally posted by: PhoenixDescending
a reply to: Kapusta
Seriously, tried to read it all but couldn't. Made me incredibly frustrated. I understand you are trying to clarify / invalidate claims made in another thread, but I don't even see what this has to do with religion. So it is ok to lie, if you are under threat. Fine, I think most people would agree to that.
originally posted by: syrinx high priest
you guys ready to kill some muslims yet or do we need more propaganda?
what would help, cartoons? catchy slogans?
I'm sure you will volunteer to serve, right?
originally posted by: Joneselius
Go fault Christ. When you can't come back then. Hopefully you'll open your eyes. I'm sick.of pandering to this barbaric belief. The perpetually offended are always around to troll.....