It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by supercheetah
Purgatory isn't really a place. More like a state or process of the soul. Essentially, the Catholic Church believes that no one can enter heaven unless they're pure. That's what purgatory does, it purifies. It is not hell. All who enter purgatory eventually enter heaven.
This is one of the reasons I'm an ex-Catholic. It's not that purgatory isn't a nice idea (it lets the Church say that certain non-Christians can get into heaven), but it doesn't really make sense. Then there's non-Catholic Christianity that pretty much says that all non-Christians go to hell, which seems rather heartless to me. Sorry, I can't fathom the idea of a god that would send Gandhi to hell.
Originally posted by shmick25
Originally posted by supercheetah
Purgatory isn't really a place. More like a state or process of the soul. Essentially, the Catholic Church believes that no one can enter heaven unless they're pure. That's what purgatory does, it purifies. It is not hell. All who enter purgatory eventually enter heaven.
But if God has the capicity to forgive sin, would that mean that you are pure? The Bible says that by his grace we are saved..
So, how does purgatory purify a soul?
Originally posted by shmick25
Originally posted by supercheetah
Purgatory isn't really a place. More like a state or process of the soul. Essentially, the Catholic Church believes that no one can enter heaven unless they're pure. That's what purgatory does, it purifies. It is not hell. All who enter purgatory eventually enter heaven.
But if God has the capicity to forgive sin, would that mean that you are pure? The Bible says that by his grace we are saved..
So, how does purgatory purify a soul?
But if God has the capacity to forgive sin, would that mean that you are pure? The Bible says that by his grace we are saved..
Originally posted by supercheetah
That guy, Bob, across the street, can be an intercessor. The only difference between him and Mary is that Bob is still alive, and very much real.
Originally posted by mOjOm
Originally posted by shmick25
Perhaps I should clarify when using the words Esoteric and Gnostic in that I'm not talking about Herecy or Gnostic Peoples themselves. I'm using it in the basic meaning which would be Esoteric (knowledge which is unknown except by a small group of people) & Gnostic (possessing spiritual knowledge). So from my perspective and I think most people would agree, that Christianity as well as all other Religious Knowledge is very Esoteric Gnosis (Largely Unknown or Misunderstood Spiritual Knowledge). If that wasn't true then there wouldn't be so many conflicting versions which divide the majority of people on this planet. You see what I'm saying???
Yeah, Bob's not really a virgin. He is a pre-op transexual, though. He plans to change his name to Roberta.
Originally posted by djohnsto77
Originally posted by supercheetah
That guy, Bob, across the street, can be an intercessor. The only difference between him and Mary is that Bob is still alive, and very much real.
Well another thing is you wouldn't call your neighbor Bob any of these things:
Originally posted by southern_cross3
Here's how I know what is and isn't false:
If it agrees with the Bible, it's true.
If it does not, it's false.
And if one decides to not believe certain parts of the Bible, they might as well dismiss it all, in which case they have no faith in God, nor any belief thereof.
Originally posted by shmick25
I guess we will have to disagree on this point. The Catechism of the Catholic Church spells out what we believe as Catholics.
by shmick25: I will attempt to answer as best as I can. In regards to the Catechism of the Catholic Church, this is pretty much documents of Church Dogma. I know that Catholics hold the authority of these up with the Bible, however they are not.
This is Truth. We also believe this.
by shmick25: The Bible is the inspired word of God. The end of revelation clearly indicates that no one should add or remove content from the Bible. So the Bible, being the word of God is infalable and should not be altered.
The Catechism is the interpretation of scripture and tradition at various councils of the Church by inspired men. It does point the way to God through Christ and does not contradict what the Bible claims.
by shmick25: The Catholic Catechism is the word of man attempting to override the word of God. I am not saying that works of Man outside the Bible can not be inspired by God, (as the Bible after all was written by man). What I am saying is that any words inspired by God will:
1) Point the way to God through Christ
2) Substaintiante and NOT contradict what the Bible already claims.
Why do we have prayers for the dead, as in funerals?
by shmick25: Unfortunately what you have quoted from the catechism can not be found in the Bible. A simple well known verse that would seemingly contradict the necissity for purgatory would be: "The wages of sin is death, BUT the gift of God is eternal life".
Yes, we believe all of this.
by shmick25: Grace is unmerited favor. It is God's free action for the benefit of His people. It is different than Justice and Mercy. Justice is getting what we deserve. Mercy is not getting what we deserve. Grace is getting what we do not deserve. In grace we get eternal life, something that, quite obviously, we do not deserve. But because of God's love and kindness manifested in Jesus on the Cross, we receive the great blessing of redemption. Grace is God's Riches At Christ's Expense. Grace rules out all human merit. It is the product of God that is given by God, because of who He is not because of who we are. It is the means of our salvation.
It seems that there is a fundamental difference here. Or maybe I am misunderstanding. Are you saying that there is no hell? That everyone who dies goes immediately to heaven? Where does "free choice" come in here. Does not one have the ability to believe or not to believe in God. Does it make any difference?
by shmick25: So I have the question: Where is grace in the concept of purgatory?
I guess you are saying that there is no hell.
by shmick25:Onto a related subject, I would like to talk about the state of the dead and the logical need for purgatory and hell.
There is a thread that I posted ages ago titled 'hell is bogus'
I understand this to mean that no one went to heaven before Christ came. These people were the ones waiting in limbo for Christ to come before they could go to heaven.
by shmick25: Firstly, let me start with the story about the local resurrection after the death of Christ:
Matthew 27:51 "51 And behold, the curtain of the temple was torn in two, from top to bottom; and the earth shook, and the rocks were split; 52 the tombs also were opened, and many bodies of the saints who had fallen asleep were raised, 53 and coming out of the tombs after his resurrection they went into the holy city and appeared to many."
So, if when you die, you go straight to heaven, purgatory or hell, how do you explain the resurrection of these people? This verse clearly says that these people were 'asleep' i.e. in a state of nothing. If they were saints, then the majority of people (protistants and catholics) would say then their spirits would have gone straight to heaven. But think about it. Heaven is a perfect place, it will be awesome. Would it be fair of God to cast all these souls back out of heaven, back into dirty mortal bodies on a #ty corrupt world?
These people died before Christ came. So do you mean they died believing that the Messiah would come?
by shmick25: No, it makes no logical sense. It does make sense that because they had died believing in Christ, then as a reward they received more life on earth, back into an environment they were familiar with, to bring joy to their families and to demonstrate the power and love of God. (By the way, this is just a small scale event of what will happen at the end of time).
The Bible, Jesus, teaches us how we should live. We have the 10 Commandments in the Old Testament and other teachings by Jesus in the New Testament. We have the choice to follow these teachings or not. We chose hell ourselves. Hell is where we will not see God. Why would we want to see God if we didn't worship Him or follow His teachings during our lives?
by shmick25: So quickly about hell. It says in the Bible, that God will do away with sin for eternity. Now, if he lets hell exist, so that evil souls can be tormented forever and ever that means that he has not removed evil. Again, this is not logical. The only way to remove sin would be to destroy everything that is evil, just like the Bible says God will do. Could you really be happy in heaven knowing that possibly your dad, mum brothers sisters, friends are being tourtured while you are in paradise? I am pretty sure you would not want to worship a God like this.
Originally posted by SomewhereinBetween
Purgatory then is a house in heaven, or something else? Do the souls of the dead sleep there until the return of Christ when they are awakened?
The Catechism is the interpretation of scripture and tradition at various councils of the Church by inspired men. It does point the way to God through Christ and does not contradict what the Bible claims.
Why do we have prayers for the dead, as in funerals?
Yes, we believe all of this.
I guess you are saying that there is no hell.
I understand this to mean that no one went to heaven before Christ came. These people were the ones waiting in limbo for Christ to come before they could go to heaven.
These people died before Christ came. So do you mean they died believing that the Messiah would come?
The Bible, Jesus, teaches us how we should live. We have the 10 Commandments in the Old Testament and other teachings by Jesus in the New Testament.
We have the choice to follow these teachings or not. We chose hell ourselves. Hell is where we will not see God. Why would we want to see God if we didn't worship Him or follow His teachings during our lives?
Luke 17:28 - Likewise also as it was in the days of Lot; they did eat, they drank, they bought, they sold, they planted, they builded; 29 But the same day that Lot went out of Sodom it rained fire and brimstone from heaven, and destroyed them all. 30 Even thus shall it be in the day when the Son of man is revealed.
Originally posted by djohnsto77
Queen of love,
Queen of mercy,
Queen of peace,
Queen of angels,
Queen of patriarchs and prophets,
Queen of apostles and martyrs,
Queen of confessors and virgins,
Queen of all saints,
Queen conceived without original sin,
Queen assumed into heaven,
Queen of all the earth,
Queen of heaven,
Queen of the universe,
Originally posted by southern_cross3
Here's how I know what is and isn't false:
If it agrees with the Bible, it's true.
If it does not, it's false.
And if one decides to not believe certain parts of the Bible, they might as well dismiss it all, in which case they have no faith in God, nor any belief thereof.
Thank you I think I understand. JPII may be in a halfway house at present waiting to go to Heaven when Jesus comes the second time.
Originally posted by MahreeIn my own words, not necessarily correct definition, this is the way I look at purgatory.
A "halfway" house on the way to heaven. If I go to purgatory I will eventually go to heaven. So going to purgatory is not a bad thing. When people pray for us after we are dead this will help to purify us and move us from purgatory to heaven. Prayers for the dead do not help anyone in hell. They have chosen not to be with God.
When we are purified of all sinful tendencies we will be able to enter heaven.